IS NEW YORK CITY REFORMED?
By M. E. K.
THE reform elements of New York City are seething with excitement over the sale of liquor on Sunday. After the city had been “Parkhursted” and “Lexowed” and a clean reform ticket had been elected, it was supposed that it would closely resemble the garden of Eden before the fall of man. But the actual facts in the case show that political reforms, like human beauty, are only skin deep. Mr. Strong, the new reform mayor of New York, thinks that the question of liquor-selling on Sunday can be best settled by allowing the saloons to remain open during a part of the day. He has made a public announcement of his mind on this subject; and so, although the law now says no liquor shall be sold on Sunday, since the reform mayor thinks it may be done with impunity, the saloon men do not fear arrest very much. Sunday, Jan. 19, was expected to be a very dry day in New York City, and Superintendent Byrnes had given orders to arrest all violators of the excise law. Nevertheless 5000 saloons did a rushing side-door business all day, and there were only 173 arrests made. Various reasons may be given for the paucity in numbers of those who were arrested for breaches of the excise law. The saloon man, or some one well acquainted with those who patronize his place, stood guard at the side door, and allowed only those to enter who were known to be regular habitués of such places. The police are not always Argus-eyed, and can hardly be expected to see through their backs, which is that portion of their bodies which they generally turn toward saloons. More than all, public opinion in New York City does not yet favor the closing of saloons on one day more than another, and it is very difficult to enforce an unpopular law. The clergy and the W. C. T. U. are protesting vigorously, but no apparent effect is yet perceivable; and this is probably all that the Parkhurst crusade and the Lexow investigation will accomplish, so far as the sale of liquor is concerned. It shows what we have often pointed out in these columns,—the utter hollowness71 and transient character of political reforms. The soul of the reform was all in the breasts of a very few men. The rest were for awhile carried away with the storm of enthusiasm, but the majority are like the fishes to which the saint preached. They listened attentively, but when the sermon was over,— “The pikes went on stealing;
The eels went on eeling;
Much delighted were they,
But preferred the old way.”
When laws do not receive the support of the majority of the people, they are a dead letter, and a law generally broken ought not to be on the statute books; for contempt toward a poor and unwise law may lead to the same feeling toward the best and wisest measures. The limitation of the sale and consumption of liquor is a consummation “devoutly to be wished;” but it can only be entirely restrained when the appetite for it in poor depraved human nature has been taken entirely away. The gospel is the all-powerful and only sufficient remedy, but since all men will not receive the gospel, the probability that liquor-drinking will entirely cease is not very great. M. E. K.