RELIGIOUS REFORMATIONS BY CIVIL LAW.
By M. E. K.
The opinion prevails with many that religious reformations are greatly aided by the civil power, and that it is one of the functions of civil government to enhance religious reforms. The Roman Church has always held this position. Thus the pope lately stated that it is the “duty of rulers to lend their support to religious creeds.” Many professed Protestants hold to the same mistaken idea. As an illustration of this position, there lately appeared in a paper devoted to the work of religious reform by civil law, the following report of a statement made at a large convention by one who favored this idea. The report reads thus: “Mr. R. M. Downey gave an address upon the topic, ‘From what source have the genuine reformations of the world proceeded?’ He maintained that there has never yet been a genuine reformation in which the State did not bear a most conspicuous part. Neither in the Bible nor in uninspired history is there a record of any.” Let us now test this position by the manner in which the greatest reformation that the world ever saw was brought about. Jesus Christ came into the world as a great reformer; and it is generally conceded that the reform which he inaugurated, and which was carried on for some time by his followers, was the most perfect reformation that ever was known in the world. It was an example and a type of what all religious reformations should be. The elements of true reformation may have entered into many public efforts of reform, but this one, instituted by Christ, was absolutely perfect in its inception and the methods used and advocated. By it thousands were turned from the power of Satan to God, and as early as the year A. D. 58, only about twenty-seven years after, it was charged against one of his apostles, who closely followed the methods of his Master, that he “throughout all Asia, . . . hath persuaded and turned away much people, saying that they be no gods, which are made with hands.” Now the question to be determined is this: What part did the State take in this great reformation? In response, a few Bible facts are herewith submitted. The ruling king of that State where this great Reformer began his work, tried to kill him when he was an infant, and although he was miraculously preserved, and against the wishes of the ruler escaped death, hundreds of innocent babes were put to death, so anxious was the State to get rid of the prospective Reformer. Later, when his work began to tell, and many believers were added to Him, the leaders of the Jewish State conspired together against him, and delivered him to the officials of the Roman State, who put him to death. This was the “conspicuous part” borne by the State in relation to the work of this, the greatest Reformer. But he arose from the dead, much against the wishes of the State, and his disciples took up the work of reformation under his direction, guided by his Spirit, and carried it on. How were they treated by the State? The leaders and representatives of the State summoned the apostles before them. They were threatened, beaten, and commanded not to speak any more in his name. This is a further proof of the “conspicuous part” acted by the State in this great reformation. Shortly after James was put to death, and Peter was thrust into prison. But God having a greater interest in this reformation than the State had, Peter was delivered. Paul was seized by the Jewish State, with the intention and purpose of putting him to death; but he escaped by placing himself in the hands of the Roman State, which, several years later, finding that the work of Paul and his fellow reformers was taking root in the Roman empire, took Paul’s life. Many more such cases as this might be adduced from the history of this great reformation to show the decidedly “conspicuous part” taken therein by the State at that time, and not until the doctrines of Christ and his apostles had become corrupted, not until the pure gold of the gospel was tarnished with heathen philosophy and “commandments of men that turn from the truth,” was the State inclined to help it along. The author of the above statement, if questioned, would be forced to admit that in numerous instances where the State has attempted religious reforms, it has made a miserable failure. The reformations in England and Germany may be cited as proofs that the State is a help in reformations, but they may rather be referred to as evidences that a reformation which succeeds by the help of the State is thereby shorn of much of its power, and is prevented from going on to a full return to God’s word. That reformations were carried on before the advent of Christ, partially by the help of the State, does not affect the point at issue, neither does the fact that from the fourth century to the present day it has been thought to be the duty of the State to do the same, affect the argument. The fact that neither the world nor any part of the world is now governed by a theocracy destroys the argument founded on this point from the Old Testament; besides, the miserable results of governmental religious reformations in modern history constitute a sufficient proof that this is not the gospel plan wherein is contained the citadel of truth on this point; namely, that the greatest Reformer ever known, who is our Example, carried on his work not only without the help and co-operation of the State, but with the State squarely opposed to it; and his disciples for hundreds of years had the same experience, yet never was the work of74 the gospel so successful as in those days. From these considerations the following principles may be deduced:— 1. Genuine reformations, being reformations of individual lives, are best carried on by men acting as teachers of spiritual truth, through whom God communicates his will. 2. When in the order of God’s providence the time comes for such a reform, the State is very often intensely hostile and endeavors to prevent it. 3. Sometimes when a reformation is in progress that has in it many elements of a genuine work, the leaders of the State, seeing in it the evidences of success, endeavor to throw the State en rapport with it, and in doing so get the credit of doing the work. But really in such a case the State becomes a curse rather than a blessing; since it thereby obtains a position from which it is able to dictate to the reformers, and often prevents the completion of their work, as was the case in the reformations in England and Germany. Finally, it is all told in the words of the prophet, “Not by might, nor by power, but by my Spirit, saith the Lord.” And again by the words of Jesus, “If my kingdom were of this world, then would my servants fight [use civil power to enforce my doctrines], but now is my kingdom not from hence.” M. E. K.