ARE REVIEWS PROFITABLE?

17%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Jan 29, 1895

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 72, No. 5.

Read the full edition

ARE REVIEWS PROFITABLE?

On account of frequent requests that come to us to review certain books or articles, and reviews that are proffered for publication, we take this opportunity to make a few observations on the matter. There may be, and doubtless are circumstances when such reviews are profitable, but generally they are not.
In cases of obscure articles or books, a review is unprofitable, because the wants of our readers as a whole must be considered, and not those of a single community. A review can only take up isolated passages and statements, and the way they are quoted seldom does justice to the writer. The reviewer takes up what are to him the most salient points, or perhaps the most vulnerable ones, while the author would be sure to wish other points to be considered. It is well nigh impossible to quote detached passages from a writing so as to create an interest in the mind of the reader in the article under review as well as in the review, but this is necessary to render a review successful; and unless it be done, no one reads the review with profit or interest. Therefore, it is better in most cases clearly to state our convictions, without attempting to place them in contrast with something in which the reader has no interest.
Again: the review of another man's work, which necessarily contains personal allusions, is almost universally taken as an affront by the individual and his friends. It gives grounds for complaints of unfairness, and it almost always takes the coloring of a war on men, rather than of a dignified and candid annunciation and defense of sound principles.
Except when the article is well known, we believe that the only fair and successful way to conduct a review is to give the author an equal chance, and place his entire production before the reader, with our comments for comparison. A discourse may be reviewed with real profit only before the same audience that heard it. The same principle applies generally to articles.
G. C. T.