WHERE IS THE DEFECT?

13%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Dec 25, 1894

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 71, No. 51.

Read the full edition

WHERE IS THE DEFECT?

A NATIONAL Reformer in the Christian Statesman of Dec. 15 says: “Under it [the United States Constitution] we have grown to be a great and prosperous and happy people. But there is one fatal defect.” The intentional omission of the name of the Deity, and also the failure to recognize the Christian religion as the religion of the United States, is in the mind of this writer the fatal defect referred to.
Admitting that there is a “fatal defect” somewhere, we are inclined to the opinion that it is in the logic of this writer, rather than in the United States Constitution. His own admission of the growth and prosperity of this nation would help to locate the fatal defect somewhere else than in the fundamental law which does so much to give stability to the nation and to shape its progress.
How a nation can start from the small beginning that this nation did, leading out on a new and untried principle of government, and then grow in the space of a hundred years into a “great and prosperous and happy people,” and at the same time have a fatal defect in the foundation of the government, passes comprehension!
We are reminded of the words of General W. T. Sherman, as once reported in the Statesman. The General was interviewed by an ardent National Reform lecturer, and urged to favor the cause of the religious amendment to the Constitution with his influence. Said the General, “The country has prospered for one hundred years with the Constitution as it is, and it will prosper for another hundred if it is let alone. I would advise you to get a parish and go to work.”
General Sherman was right. The country has prospered with the Constitution as it is; and because the country has prospered is an excellent reason that the Constitution should be left as it is. Do the people of Austria, Spain, and Ecuador, where religion is established by law, excite our jealousy? Are we anxious for their measure of prosperity? If it should be said that in these countries it is the Catholic religion that is so established, we may ask, What difference does that make? The greatest wrong is in the act of establishment and not in the religion. Catholics do not persecute where they do not have control of the civil power. Protestants have invariably persecuted when they have had such control.
What is the remedy for persecution? “Keep the Church and the State apart.” Our fathers applied the remedy to the Federal Constitution. It has not failed thus far, unless it has been abused and overridden. When the United States turns her back upon the liberty guaranteed in the Constitution, she has turned her face toward persecution and despotism; and there can be but a little way before national ruin will be reached.
M. E. K.