A CONFESSION AND THE RESULTS.
By M. E. K.
It is well known that at the present time there is a strong effort being made to bring about a better observance of Sunday. It cannot be disguised that the people, generally, do not regard the day as the Puritans of New England and their immediate successors regarded it. The reason for this change in sentiment, even among those who claim to be the spiritual descendants of the Puritans, is not difficult to find. The Puritans, with a narrow-minded ignorance in keeping with the age, actually believed that they were observing the fourth commandment in keeping Sunday for the Sabbath, and of course some people still hold to that mistaken idea, but it is now very generally given up, and we frequently find, even in Protestant religious papers, frank acknowledgments that keeping Sunday rests on another basis than the fourth commandment. The latest confession of this kind appears in the Christian Work of Nov. 15. The statement which we will quote occurs in a review of an article upon the subject of the Sabbath, which has lately appeared in the Nineteenth Century, from the pen of Dr. A. R. Wallace. The doctor holds that as the fourth commandment forbids labor by domestic servants, as well as that of the master of the house, that that master who works his servants all days is himself participes criminis to the sin of Sabbath-breaking. The doctor would obviate the difficulty by having some of the servants or members of the family relieved from labor on other days, so that they can do the work on Sunday, and still all keep the fourth commandment, but on different days, of course! He believes the fourth commandment is binding, but to him it only prescribes a day for physical rest, which may be taken any time that convenience and the general agreement of the family may suggest! Although agreeing in the conclusions of Dr. Wallace, the Christian Work offers the following criticism:— “We think it will be seen that Mr. Wallace puts Sabbath observance on a wrong basis, for while Sabbath (Sunday) observance in its spirit rests upon the fourth commandment, it is not accepted by the Christian Church as requiring literal obedience in form and method. This is shown by the change made to the first day of the week; by this act the church swept away the literalness of the command to rest on one day and on one day only; viz., the seventh day. Now it seems very clear that if Christian people can under certain exigencies change the rest day from Saturday to Sunday, they can by common consent—and common consent was the sole authority of the change—substitute one part of another day for an equal part of Sunday. In this way the Sabbath rest—one seventh—will be observed in spirit just as it now is observed in spirit in the change from Saturday to Sunday.” The difference between the above positions is that the first holds that the commandment is binding, and the second that the spirit of it only is binding. Since both sustain a day not mentioned in the commandment, they lay themselves open to grave criticism; but this is not our purpose, as we wish to call attention to the confession as to how the change of the Sabbath was made. It is frankly confessed that the change was made by the command of the church, and that alone; and from this statement the principle is deduced that other changes can also be made in the law. The conclusion is as good as the premise, and the premise is as good as the conclusion, but neither is just; for the whole argument is wrong from premise to conclusion, from base to capstone. And now what can be the natural result of teaching that “literal obedience” is not required by the Christian Church to the fourth commandment? What but a great laxity of observance, and a general habit of devoting the day generally supposed to be the Sabbath to anything and everything but worship? For as surely as the position is taken that the fourth commandment has been changed in such a degree as to make the observance of another day admissible, so surely the whole commandment is given up to whatever the varying minds of men may require. That there was quite a general agreement in the church does not make any difference. If it be admitted that the church can judge the law of God, we may expect that in this age of the world private individuals will claim the right to do the same. The result, as may be seen, is the increasing tide of no-Sabbathism. The Sunday holiday is the direct result of this unwarrantable tampering with the law of God. As an indication of how this is working, the following from the New York Observer of Nov. 15 tells its own story:— “Whither are we drifting? Are we not in danger of losing our precious Sabbath? Does it not look as if we are fast becoming, in point of Sabbath observance, very much like the Continental Sabbath? . . . A pastor in New York has enrolled among his church-members the names of four sisters. They are American born, but of German parentage, and bright, good girls. On his return from his summer vacation he inquired after the family, and especially a married sister residing a little distance from the church. Said he, ‘Tell sister that next Sabbath we will have our fall communion, and I hope she will be present with us.’ The reply was: ‘O, she will not be there; she has a ticket to go to West Point on an excursion, that day, and of course she won’t lose such an opportunity.’ This was said without a blush or a word of excuse.” The above illustrates the effects of the discovery that Sunday has no foundation in the Scriptures. As long as people could be made to believe that the fourth commandment required the observance of Sunday, that day secured in the hearts of the people the respect and deference that was due to the seventh day; but now that the spell is broken, and the fraud not only disclosed but openly confessed, the Sunday is stripped of its false Sabbatic trappings, and is more and more being regarded as what it actually is, an impostor, fit only for a day of recreation, a holiday. To correct this contempt of the Sabbatic institution, for which the action of the apostate church in meddling with the law of God set the example, the civil law is even now being invoked, that men may be compelled to observe a day which those who are most zealous for its enforcement are forced to admit has no authority in the Scriptures. And the strangest of all is that those who argue, like Dr. Wallace and the Christian Work, that people may consult their own convenience as to what day, or what part of a day, they may keep, are decided in their opposition to the working on Sunday of the conscientious Sabbath-keeper, who will not allow that the fourth commandment may be tampered with in the least, but who obeys it just as it is written, and according to its obvious meaning and intent. Such persons are to be taught that the free and easy way of keeping a day, or any parts of days they may choose, is only allowable in those who profess to keep Sunday, but who nevertheless do just as they please! It may be proper to observe in closing that there was no consistency in the change made by the apostate church from the observance of the Sabbath to Sunday, and consequently no further step or argument in justification of that change, or anything growing out of it, can possibly be consistent with it, or with the facts in the case.