ROME AND THE PUBLIC SCHOOLS

17%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Nov 20, 1894

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 71, No. 46.

Read the full edition

ROME AND THE PUBLIC SCHOOLS.

The contention over the public schools and the position of the Catholic Church in relation thereto have received much attention of late in this country, and even now no permanent settlement of the question has been effected. Settled in one State, it is liable to appear in another, and there is no prospect of a speedy settlement of this vexing question. The desires of the Catholic Church upon this subject are set forth in the Catholic Review, in the following manner:—
“We insist with all the earnestness of our soul that it is the bounden duty of the State to encourage, by every means in its power, the religious education of the rising generation. The safety of society, the salvation of the State, demand it. All that we can require of the State in this important work is that no partiality shall be shown to any one denomination. Let all be encouraged to give religious instruction according to their own views, and let each receive aid according to the number of children taught in each school. Let the State have a general oversight and superintendence of the secular studies without trenching upon the conscientious scruples of any class of religionists, especially in regard to historical studies, and let no partiality or injustice be shown.”
It will be noticed that it is the idea of the writer of the above that the State should aid the different “denominations” to teach religion to pupils in the schools according to the number that each have in the schools. That is to say, If there are twenty Catholic pupils and the same number of Methodist pupils in a school, the State should pay an equal sum to a Catholic and a Methodist to teach religion to the children of the school. Or if there is more of one kind of religion in the school than another, to employ and pay religious instructors accordingly. Further, this arrangement makes no provision for the training in religion by the State of the countless hosts of children, who, perhaps with their parents, have no religious predilections, or those who may be opposed to all religions. It can readily be seen that any attempt by the State to teach such children religion would lead to disastrous results, first to anger the parents and turn them into violent opposers of the government, and second to stir up strife among the various denominations; for however willing any church may be to see other churches teaching children religion at their own expense, they will be highly displeased to see some other church than their own teaching children religion at the expense of the State.
Again: This plan must be enforced, not by the United States but by the several State governments. Then in such a State as Utah will be, the State would pay the majority of teachers to teach the Mormon religion; for that religion is the prevailing religion there, and probably will be for all time to come. Viewed in these different aspects, the plan outlined by the Catholic Review is not only un-American but entirely impracticable.
There is another point in the statement of the Review that is worthy of attention. It would have no “trenching upon the conscientious scruples of any class of religionists, especially in regard to historical studies.” The above shows a very tender spot in the Catholic conscience. Impartial history discloses some very ugly things that were done by the Catholic Church. Civil powers were constrained by that church to put to death millions of people. Not satisfied with the slowness of some civil powers to exterminate those the church called heretics, but which she now denominates “separated brethren,” the Holy (?) Office of the Inquisition was established in many European and other countries; and these institutions of examination, torture, and death continued until the days of Napoleon Bonaparte. If the “conscientious scruples” of young and impressible Catholics could be spared the recital of these facts of history, it would be exceedingly gratifying to the Catholic Church; and no doubt it seems very cruel to that church that the State should coldly insist that these hard facts of history shall be taught in the schools. But it cannot be avoided. Should one church insist that unpleasant truths in regard to its history must not be taught in the schools, another would do the same, until all history would become a falsification rather than an illustration of the realities of the events of the past. Even the Mormon would not consent to have the facts of the Mountain Meadow massacre taught to his children. Such a state of things cannot be, and the only way to avoid these difficulties is for the public schools to give a secular education with the impartial facts of history, and let religion be taught at the home, the denominational school, and the church. And outside of these, in the highways and hedges, there is room for the religious activities of every denomination and every creed. M. E. K.