AdventAI

IN A MARYLAND JAIL FOR CONSCIENCE'S SAKE.

By Allen Moon

From Review and Herald, Vol. 71, No. 46., November 20, 1894

R. R. Whaley, a Seventh-day Adventist, is now serving out a sentence of ninety days in a Maryland jail, for having performed bodily labor on the first day of the week commonly called Sunday. Brother Whaley is a carpenter by trade, and in the month of June of this year he was engaged in building a church in the village of Church Hill, Md. The location of the church was on one of the principal streets of the place, and as he had respect for the people who regarded Sunday as the Sabbath, he did not labor on the church on that day. It was his custom to work on the church five days in the week and look after any little jobs about his house on Sunday that would contribute to the comfort of his family. This work was done in a very quiet way so as not to disturb any one, but he had recently changed his views on matters of religion as well as his church relations, and some of the good (?) people of the community took it upon themselves to watch him on Sunday, and found him engaged in some employment about his premises. He was therefore arrested and brought before a magistrate who fined him $5 and costs. The charge against him was that he had broken the Sabbath.

Brother Whaley pleaded not guilty to this charge, but he was convicted, the magistrate ruling that Sunday was the lawful Sabbath. An appeal was taken to the court of appeals for Queen Anne county. Brother Whaley continued to labor as before, and was arrested a second time, and charged with laboring on two separate Sundays, and was convicted in each case, and again he appealed to the higher court.

Monday, Nov. 5, brother Whaley's case came up for hearing in the court of appeals at Centerville, Queen Anne Co., Md., Judge Robinson presiding. Brother Whaley appeared in his own behalf. After the witnesses testified that they had seen him laboring on Sunday, brother Whaley addressed the court, explaining the reason for having pleaded not guilty to the charge of Sabbath-breaking, and stating that he observed the Sabbath of the Lord. He also gave some reasons why he did not regard Sunday as the Sabbath.

The Lord helped him to present his case in a clear and earnest manner, and a good impression was made upon the large company of people that filled the court room.

Judge Robinson spoke very pleasantly, but decidedly, defending the Sunday institution and affirming the decision of the lower court. He told brother Whaley, however, that if he would promise to do no more work on Sunday, he would only impose a fine in one case, which would amount to a fine of $5 and costs or thirty days in jail; but in case he did not agree to refrain from all labor on Sunday, he would give him the full extent of the law. As brother Whaley could not agree to the terms, he was sentenced to remain in jail thirty days in each of the three counts.

The remarkable thing in this decision is that the court held that this was a plain case of violation of law, and therefore the court was without discretion in the matter of sustaining the judgment of the lower court. But though the defendant had been convicted on three counts before the magistrate, the court could use its discretion and affirm the decision of the lower court in only one case, if the defendant would bow down to the papal Sunday.

On Friday, Nov. 9, W. G. Curlett was convicted of violating the old Maryland Sunday law, enacted in 1794, and sentenced to serve sixty days in jail. Brother Curlett lived in the country, andp. 732 he was engaged about his house and garden on Sunday.

The people of the community were much offended that an Adventist church should be built there, and a mob came and cut the ropes of the tent and broke some of the windows of the church; but when Elder Horton appeared on the scene, they fled, not, however, without making threats of greater violence. About this time brother Curlett was observed doing some work on his place on Sunday. He was arrested and brought before the magistrate, and held for trial before the court of appeals for Queen Anne county. He requested a trial by jury, and appeared in his own defense. His remarks were as follows: “I do not deny working on the first day of the week; but I deny the charge of having worked on the Lord's day, because the first day of the week is not the Lord's day. The commandment of God says: ‘Six days shalt thou labor, . . . but the seventh day is the Sabbath of the Lord thy God,’ and we must keep it. If any one can point to a single scripture showing that Sunday is the Lord's day and should be kept, I will confess that I am in error. I have lived in this county all my life, except eighteen months, and never was charged with wrong. I do not work on Sunday in defiance of the law; but because I must obey God's law rather than man's law. And Cardinal Gibbons has said that there was no authority in the Bible for keeping Sunday, and some of you gentlemen [to the jury], probably know of this.”

Here the case closed. The judge gave no charge. The jury brought in a verdict of guilty as charged, and brother Curlett was sentenced as before stated. ALLEN MOON.