A CANDID STATEMENT

13%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Nov 6, 1894

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 71, No. 44.

Read the full edition

A CANDID STATEMENT.

The New York Weekly Tribune of Oct. 10, 1894, contains in its “Asked and Answered” column a query concerning Sunday observance with an unbiased answer appended. We commend it to all our friends who cherish the idea of Sunday sacredness. The question and answer are as follows:—

“SUNDAY OBSERVANCE.

“J. B. (Rugby, Tenn.): ‘Please tell me in the “Asked and Answered” column of the Weekly Tribune when, why, and by whom the Christian Sabbath was changed from Saturday to Sunday.’
“The observance of Sunday instead of Saturday as a day of rest was instituted by an edict of the Emperor Constantine, issued A. D. 321. It reads: ‘Let all judges, and all people of the towns, and all the various trades be suspended on the venerable day of the sun (venerabili die Solis). Those who live in the country, however, may freely, and without fault, attend to the cultivation of the fields, lest with the loss of favorable opportunity the commodities offered by heaven be destroyed.’ This was the first of a long series of imperial constitutions, most of which are incorporated in the Code of Justinian, Book 3, Title 12. By the constitutions comprised in this title of the code and headed by the quoted edict, pleasure was forbidden, as well as business. No spectacle was to be exhibited in a theater or circus. If the emperor’s birthday fell on a Sunday, its celebration was to be postponed. On the other hand, Code 3, XII., 10, distinctly directs the torture of robbers and pirates, even on Easter Day. ‘History does not furnish us with a single proof or indication,’ says Sir William Domville, one of the most eminent Protestant divines of his age, referring to the subject of Sunday observance, ‘that it was observed as a Sabbath previous to the Sabbatical edict of Constantine in 321.’—‘Six Texts,’ p. 241.
“Various reasons are assigned for the changing of the Sabbath from Saturday to Sunday, all of which are founded upon the proof established by Scripture passages (Acts 20:7–11; 1 Cor. 16:2; Heb. 10:25; Rev. 1:10, and others) that the apostles and first Christians were wont to assemble and hold public meetings on this day. But some churches met also on Wednesday, some on Friday, and some on Saturday; none of these days, however, was observed by the church as a Sabbath.
“Says Mosheim, with reference to this subject: ‘Many also observed the fourth day of the week, on which Christ was betrayed; and the sixth, which was the day of crucifixion.’—‘Ecclesiastical History,’ Part 2, Chapter 1. The Rev. Dr. Heylyn, after stating that Saturday was retained in many of the eastern churches, says: ‘The Sunday in the eastern churches had no great prerogative above other days, especially above the Wednesday and the Friday.’—‘History of the Sabbath,’ Part 2, Chapter 3. The only valid reason why Sunday was selected for the Christian Sabbath seems to be one of expediency. This day consecrated to the sun was already held sacred by the pagans, and so it was much easier to compel them to abstain from labor on this day than on any other. Besides, in order to make the new faith acceptable to the Gentiles, compromises had to be made, and one of these compromises was the adoption of the old pagan holiday of Sunday for the Christian Sabbath. This is admitted by many prominent clergymen. Thus Mour, an eminent English divine, after admitting that we borrow the name of this day from the ancient Greeks and Romans, and allowing that the old Egyptians worshiped the sun, and as a standing memorial of their veneration, dedicated this day to him, says: ‘So that Sunday being the day on which the Gentiles solemnly adored that planet and called it Sunday . . . the Christians thought fit to keep the same day and the same name of it, that they might not appear causelessly peevish, and by that means hinder the conversion of the Gentiles.’—‘Dialogues on the Lord’s Day,’ p. 22.
“Another advocate of the first-day observance makes a similar apology in the North British Review (Vol. XVIII., p. 409): ‘That very day was the Sunday of their heathen neighbors and respective countrymen, and patriotism gladly united with expediency in making it at once their Lord’s day and their Sabbath.’”