AdventAI

SUBSTITUTES FOR FLESH-MEATS.

By W. H. Wakeham

From Review and Herald, Vol. 71, No. 38., September 18, 1894

BY ELDER W. H. WAKEHAM.

(Lincoln, Nebr.)

In adopting a vegetarian diet, many fail to supply in their daily menu the elements which abound in the flesh of animals, and which are necessary for the proper nourishment of the body. Thus attempting to live on an impoverished diet, they find themselves growing gradually weaker till, finally, in despair, they return to their former “mixed diet,” and obtaining immediate relief from some of their distressing symptoms, they conclude that vegetarianism is a mistake, and “health reform” a failure.

The greater part of the nutritive portion of all lean meat is composed of albumen and fibrine, which belong to a class of food elements termed “albuminous,” or “nitrogenous.” These elements are useful in building nerve and muscle tissue, and unless supplied in some form in the proper proportion, the body will not be well nourished. Fat is also a necessary element, and is found in greater or less quantities in the flesh of animals. Vegetarians quite commonly supply this element in the form of butter. That these necessary elements—albumen and fats—may be obtained without recourse to flesh-meats or the fat of animals, in its ordinary form, the facts set forth in this article will fully demonstrate. First I will give a table showing the actual amount of nitrogenous matter, fat, and the total nutritive material of one pound of each of the most commonly used meats, with exception of pork, which, for various reasons, needs not to be taken into consideration at all:—

Food Nitrogenous material Fat Total nutritive matter
Lean beef 3.1 oz. .6 oz. 4.5 oz.
Lean mutton 2.9 “ .8 “ 4.5 “
Veal 2.6 “ 2.5 “ 5.9 “
Poultry 3.4 “ .7 “ 4.1 “
White fish 2.8 “ .4 “ 3.5 “
Salmon 2.5 “ .9 “ 3.7 “

As has been previously ascertained, an ordinary working adult requires, for the best nourishment of the body, twenty-one ounces of nutrient material, three ounces of which must be nitrogenous matter. If the proportion of the nitrogenous to the carbonaceous material is continually less than this (one to six), the system will become impoverished. If, on the other hand, an excess of the nitrogenous matter (that is, more than three ounces a day) is taken into the system, the eliminative organs will be overworked, as all excess must be carried off as waste matter. The liver and kidneys will suffer the most, as they are the chief organs engaged in the elimination of uric acid, which is the product of an excess of nitrogenous element in the food, and the chief cause of rheumatism.

But by the above table we see that in order to get the proper amount of nutrient material (twenty-one ounces), one would need to eat nearly five pounds of lean beef a day; but in so doing he would get over fifteen ounces of nitrogenous elements, or more than five times as much as the system could use. This shows that those who eat largely of flesh will be pretty apt to get an excess of the nitrogenous elements, and will consequently suffer the evil results mentioned above, as well as many others which it is not in the province of this article to mention.

I now present a table in which will be found a number of vegetable productions which contain these necessary elements in proportions to meet all of the requirements of the body; and in some cases in larger quantities than they are contained in any of the flesh-meats. Each item represents one pound of material:—

Food Nitrogenous material Fat Total nutritive matter
Wheat (Mich. diehle) 2.2 oz. — 14. oz.
Corn (Flint) 1.6 “ .8 oz. 13.5 “
“ (sweet) 1.8 “ 1.3 “ 13. “
Oatmeal 2.4 “ 1.1 “ 14.5 “
Peas (dried) 3.9 “ .6 “ 13. “
Beans (white) 4.3 “ .5 “ 13. “
Lentils (Ger.) 5.2 “ 1.4 “ 12. “
Walnuts 2.5 “ 9.1 “ 14. “
Hazelnuts 2.8 “ 10. “ 14.3 “
Sweet almonds 3.8 “ 8.4 “ 13.9 “
Peanuts 4.5 “ 7.4 “ 12.8 “
Bananas .6 “ .1 “ 4.2 “
Dates 1.4 “ — 10.7 “
Milk .7 “ .6 “ 2.3 “
Eggs 2.3 “ 1.7 “ 4.2 “

In the above table I have purposely omitted the per cent of starch, sugar, and salts contained in the foods given (these being included in the total), the purpose being not to give a complete analysis of the articles mentioned, but to show the relative amount of nitrogenous matter contained in each article of food. It will be observed that wheat, corn, oatmeal, bananas, and dates contain about the right proportion. And it is interesting to note in this connection that each of these is a staple article of food in some part of the world. Bananas form the chief food of many of the natives of South America and the tropical islands. The date is a staple food in Turkey and Arabia. Oatmeal is so largely used in Scotland that an English lexicographer once defined “oats” as “food for horses in England, and for men in Scotland,” intending it as a slur on the Highlander. But a native wit replied, “Where do you find such horses as in England, or such men as in Scotland?” Thousands of people in America subsist largely on Indian corn, and wheat is a staple article of diet throughout the civilized world.

It will also be seen that the legumes contain a larger amount of the nitrogenous elements than any of the flesh-meats, also a comparatively good proportion of fat. The nuts are very rich in vegetable fats, in some cases containing sixty per cent, and compare favorably with the meats in the amount of nitrogenous matter contained. Another point worthy of notice is that the total nutritive value of these vegetable productions is nearly three times that of the flesh-meats.

In reply to the objection that is sometimes raised that the albuminous matter found in vegetable productions is not so nourishing as that found in the flesh of animals, I give the following from the eminent German chemist, Baron Liebig:—

“Vegetable fibrine and animal fibrine, vegetable albumen and animal albumen, differ at most in form. If these principles in nourishment fail, the nourishment of the animal is cut off; if they obtain them, then the grass-feeding animal gets the same principles in his food as those upon which the flesh-eater entirely depends. Vegetables produce in their organism the blood of all beings. So that when the flesh-eaters consume the blood and flesh of the vegetable-eaters, they take to themselves exactly and simply the vegetable principles.”
“Vegetable foods, in particular corn [grain] of all kinds, and through these bread, contain as much iron as the flesh of oxen or as other kinds of flesh.”—Quoted in “Ethics of Diet,” p. 291.

It might be added that the gluten of the wheat is the most easily digested of all forms of the nitrogenous elements. Surely God made no mistake when, providing for man’s dietetic needs in the beginning, he gave him simply the “fruits of the earth.”