AdventAI

THE BASEL PROSECUTION.

From Review and Herald, Vol. 71, No. 38., September 18, 1894

[Our publishing house in Basel, Switzerland, has been harassed by evil-minded persons who have caused several complaints to be made of Sunday work. At the last trial in the municipal court a fine of two hundred francs, and three weeks’ imprisonment, or sixty-one days in prison, was inflicted. This falls upon brother Holser personally. The case was appealed, and in the following letter he gives an account of the case in the court of appeals. Following the letter we give an epitome of the twelve points of the appeal which, had we space, we would gladly give entire.—Ed.]

Basel, Aug. 30, 1894.

DEAR BROTHER: This morning our case came off in the court of appeals in Basel. As it was difficult for me to express my ideas clearly and forcibly in German, I decided to write the appeal and have it translated; thus I would stand a better chance to bring out our position. Heretofore they have always interrupted me, making it impossible to bring out as much as was desired.

Our hearing was all that we could have desired, so far as opportunity to bring out our position was concerned. There were six judges on the bench. After the clerk read the accusation and the fine of the police court, the president asked me what I had to say. I thereupon read what I had written, nine pages of manuscript, written with the typewriter, making twelve points; and in addition a number of extracts from speeches of leading Sunday-law advocates in Europe, showing that it was a religious day that they wanted, and then an extract from a printed speech of a Basel pastor, in which he declared that the Sunday-law advocates regarded themselves as the public conscience for those that are indifferent about Sunday.

During the reading, which occupied about twenty-five minutes, all paid close attention and kept very quiet. There seemed to be a good spirit present. When I had finished, the State’s attorney spoke in a very indecisive way, and did not seem to have any clear point to present. Most of his time was devoted to a sort of an apologetic presentation of the reasons for the fines. He made scarcely any reply to the points which I had made, and closed with the statement that he believed the fine just, and that it should be sustained. His speech was very cloudy; he seemed to talk as though he had a hard, dry time of it.

When he had finished, the president inquired if any of the judges had questions to ask me. One of them, who had been a Jew, asked me if we held to the modern translations or to the original of the Bible, and then without giving opportunity for a reply, continued to argue that in the original it was not a command to work six days, but is more in the sense of a simple statement, or fact, or at most, the permission to work; and then quoted from Gen. 3:16, “In sorrow shalt thou bring forth children,” stating that the “shalt” here is the same as in the commandment, and has the same meaning; and concluded with the remark that our whole mistaken position was due to our misconception on this point. Without giving time for reply, another asked the question if we knew which was the seventh day, and then continued to argue that as we did not know, all our assertions were of no force.

He sat next to the president, and as soon as he began on this point, the president interrupted him, asking him to confine himself to questions and not to discuss points. Nevertheless the old gentleman made the remarks that he desired to make. Again, without giving me opportunity to reply,p. 598 a third began, stating that he understood that our headquarters were in England, and desired to know how it was with our working there; he then proceeded to remark that his own observation in England showed that Sunday was well observed there.

I now had an opportunity to reply, and beginning with the last, stated that our headquarters were in America, but that we had publishing houses in London, Norway, Australia, and America, and in every one we worked on Sunday. Then, replying to the second, I stated that we knew exactly which was the seventh day by all history, by eight millions of Jews, and could prove it by astronomy, as compared with the records of history; for by astronomy we could prove the accuracy of dates to a minute from the time of Ptolemy, and knew that since his time there could not have been a day lost; that we were certain that the Jews had the right day in the time of Christ; for he, being the Creator, kept the Sabbath that he had commanded in the law, and showed us how to keep it.

Then replying to the first, I stated that laying aside the question of command to work six days, the gentleman himself admitted that there was a permission to work, hence we had the right from God to work, and man had no right to rob us of it; and that all could readily understand that the laboring man could not exist under present conditions without working six days in the week. Hence this Sunday law certainly did make it oppressive to those that exercise their rights of conscience in keeping the seventh day.

One question of the judge I omitted, and that is if we do not keep Good Friday and other similar days, when they did not come on Saturday! I replied that we kept none of these days, because they rested wholly on human authority, and were given us by the Catholic Church, and that God expressly warns us in his word against these papal institutions.

Here the president declared the hearing closed, and asked us to retire. The whole proceeding lasted about forty-five minutes. The judges did not manifest the least disrespect; they were quite old men, and had a kindly appearance.

For a few moments after my reading it seemed as though we were engaged in a theological discussion. And I would not be surprised if the matter took more of this turn after we retired, for they were about three quarters of an hour in reaching a conclusion; then we were called in to hear the sentence, which was that the decision of the police court was sustained, and ten francs added for costs.

We now have sixty days in which to appeal to the supreme court. It is our intention to print the argument presented in the Basel court of appeals, and circulate it as extensively as possible, in the meantime instructing our churches in the principles of religious liberty, and get them to work as much as possible, and then near the close of the sixty days to make the appeal to the higher court.

Just now the Catholics are bestirring themselves, and are beginning to call for the return of the Jesuits, so this may prove a very favorable time for bringing out our principles.

GROUNDS OF APPEAL.

1. That it is my religious duty to rest the seventh day, and work the remaining six days of the week; and that by so doing I do not invade the natural rights of my fellow-citizens.

2. That to lay aside my secular work on Sunday is to accept a rival institution to God’s Sabbath.

3. That as a weekly rest-day is assured to all employees in our publishing house, we meet the object of Article XIV. of the factory law.

4. That the enforcement of Sunday laws on Seventh-day Adventists is a violation of Article XLIX. of the Federal Constitution.

5. That by refusing to lay aside our regular secular work on Sunday, we do not resist God’s order in civil government.

6. That the enforcement of Sunday laws on Seventh-day Adventists imposes an unjust fine of sixteen per cent on them for freedom of conscience.

7. That Sunday laws are religious, and oppressive to all who do not accept Sunday.

8. That it is the duty of the State to protect the individual in his natural rights.

9. That there is no liability of more days than Saturday and Sunday being chosen as rest days, if all are left free to choose.

10. That we cannot truly represent the gospel while submitting to Sunday laws.

11. The decision of the police court under consideration concerns not me only, but directly all employed in our publishing house; and indirectly a whole denomination.

12. That to enforce Sunday laws would oppress, imprison, and banish an honest, temperate, industrious people, to the everlasting disgrace of free Switzerland.

I appeal from the decision of the police court of Basel, rendered Aug. 16, 1894, and request indemnity for 665 francs, the loss occasioned me by the seizure and sale of my goods to satisfy former fines for Sunday work.

Respectfully submitted.