The case of Private Soldier Cedarquist, who refused to go on target-practice on Sunday, the punishment inflicted upon him by his superior officer, and the subsequent action of the War Department in releasing him and ordering a trial by court-martial of the officer who ordered his punishment, have before been noted in these columns. There is one point, however, that is worthy of mention in connection with this affair that probably is not generally known.
The War Department at the first determined to sustain the action of the officer! We learn this interesting fact from the Christian Nation of Aug. 15. It appears that when the case first came before the public, the editor of the above-mentioned paper addressed a letter to the War Department, protesting against the punishment of the soldier for his disobedience of orders. To this letter a reply was received from the Assistant Secretary of War, justifying the officer, and making the following statement:—
“It is not the opinion of this department that Private Chas. O. Cedarquist ought to receive a pardon. His punishment is very proper, and, as mitigated, is exceedingly mild. It is thought that upon reflection you will see that it is simply impossible that any soldier should be made the judge of the necessity of an order given him. And inasmuch as there is no question about the disobedience of Private Cedarquist, his punishment followed as a matter of course.
“Your general sentiments are very proper and are concurred in; but it is thought that to pardon Private Cedarquist would be subversive of discipline, without which an army is worse than useless.
“You will observe that the question of the advisability of target-practice on Sunday is not the one which presents itself. Permit me to say, further, that the department is taking the proper action in this matter aside from the status of Private Cedarquist.”
The above was the position of the War Department until the great hue and cry of the religious press led the President to interfere, reverse the opinion of the War Department, release the soldier, and order the trial of the officer. The whole affair is suggestive of the grip which the religious element has upon the government.
We have no words of condemnation for Private Cedarquist. His rights of conscience are as dear to him as ours are to us. At the same time, we shall hold that he is out of his place in the army. Moral questions, particularly if conducted on Christian lines, cannot come into the army, if any real service is expected of it. A man whose Christian conscience will not allow him to shoot at a mark on Sunday, but who has no compunction in regard to shooting at men on Monday, has a conscience too complicated for a soldier. It is very suggestive of the Russian robber who murdered and robbed a man, but refrained from taking some meat the victim was carrying home, because it was during the time when the church forbade meat-eating! The court-martial which was ordered by the President to try Major Worth has acquitted that officer of all blame, holding that the circumstances fully justified his action. Now let Cedarquist be discharged from the army, and take some peaceful employment, where he will not be compelled to shoot at a target or a man on Sunday. M. E. K.