THE CHURCH AND THE REORGANIZATION OF SOCIETY

4%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Michigan · Aug 7, 1894

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 71, No. 32.

Read the full edition

THE CHURCH AND THE REORGANIZATION OF SOCIETY.

The Church is the people of God in the world, but not of it. Society consists of the world (i. e., the unregenerate and unspiritual mass of mankind) plus Christians (i. e., spiritual, regenerate men), considered as to their secular relations and interests.
The demand is made that the Church address herself to the reconstruction, or rectification, of society. We are told that to attempt this is the proper mission of the Church; that to accomplish it is to bring in the kingdom of God; that we have, heretofore, devoted ourselves too exclusively to the salvation of souls, and have preached and talked too much about a future life. Now we should devote our attention largely to the affairs of the present, and endeavor by direct effort to change the condition of society in the interest of human welfare and happiness in this life, and for the prevalence of “righteousness;” i. e., justice and equity among men; in other words, to reform, regenerate, and rule the world for the good of the race and the glory of God.
It is alleged that indirect influence, however valuable, is not enough, and will never effect what humanity requires. Therefore, the Church must change her methods and plan of operations, and, without abandoning spiritual work, devote a very large part of her energies to moral reforms, good legislation, re-adjustment of political, social, and industrial conditions, sanitation, education, providing proper amusements, etc.,—in a word, become a great humane agency. Thus, entering upon this “new crusade” in this “new era,” it is asserted that the Church will be only fulfilling her long-neglected mission, and will become instrumental in transforming the State into the kingdom of God.
No doubt this movement will grow. This “new departure” will have a host of supporters. It falls in exactly with the earthly and materialistic temper of our times; it appears noble and “altruistic;” it will fascinate and enlist many ardent and hopeful minds. Nevertheless I believe it is a false departure, wrong in principle, and sure to end in evil and disaster. I will state my reasons for this belief as fully as the space at command will permit:—
1. It is unscriptural.
I put in evidence the whole New Testament, from cover to cover. Not a line or a word, fairly interpreted, can be made to favor this new departure; the whole is against it, directly or indirectly. In Christ’s time every evil of society existed in monstrous forms, but he said not a word about reforming these evils. He refused to decide in domestic difficulties (Luke 10: 40-42), in cases of equity (Luke 12: 13, 14), and in questions of politics, even where there was, to use a current phrase, a “moral element involved.” Mark 12: 17. He declared his kingdom to be not of this world (John 18: 36), and forbade the use of force to further his cause. Matt. 26: 52. His great commission, sweeping on to the “consummation of the age,” was simply to preach the good news, baptize believers, and then teach them to observe all his commands.
The apostles and primitive Christians obeyed their orders. They said nothing about reforming the evils of society, intolerable as they were. They were determined to know nothing but Jesus Christ and him crucified. 1 Cor. 2: 2. Their weapons were not fleshly, but spiritual. 2 Cor. 10: 4. Their sole aim was the conversion of sinners and the upbuilding of believers. Paul’s explicit teaching is, What have I to do with judging those who are without—outside of the church? 1 Cor. 5: 12. It is true that in time Christianity wrought marvelous improvements in society; but it was by indirect influence, not by direct endeavor.
Moreover, it is distinctly revealed that it is not God’s purpose to “convert the world” or make society what it ought to be, prior to the promised return of our Saviour. We are expressly told that the tares and the wheat, the wicked and the righteous, will grow together until the consummation of the age; then, by angelic hands, all things that cause stumbling and those who do iniquity will be removed. Matt. 13: 30, 37-43. A bad rather than a good state of things is predicted, as the present age draws toward its close. Luke 18: 8; 2 Tim. 3: 1; 2 Pet. 3: 3. The constant hope and expectation is the second coming of Christ. Titus 2: 13.
We would also do well to remember that in this new departure, as we have no divine authority for it, but the contrary, we can expect no divine help; we shall have to rely on human resources which have been tried for this purpose a thousand times, only to fail. We shall be like Israel attempting the conquest of Canaan against the divine command, and driven back in defeat and disaster. Of all hopeless undertakings, the most hopeless is one which could succeed only by special divine help, but which God has not commanded, which is out of the line of his revealed purposes, and which he has virtually forbidden.
2. It is founded on an erroneous view of the kingdom of God.
The Bible has much to say about the kingdom of God, of Christ, of heaven. Unfortunately, popular views of this subject are very loose and indefinite. The advocates of the new departure claim that this kingdom is a definite thing, as much so, I suppose, as baptism or heaven. They say it is not religion, piety, the cause of Christ; not the Church; not heaven, but is to be on earth; not present, but future. So far, I am sure, they are right and in harmony with the teachings and trend of Scripture. But when the advocates of the new departure assert, as they do, that the kingdom is to come gradually, through the agency of the Church, until human society is transformed into this kingdom, before the return of the Lord, then they fly the track of Scripture teaching entirely. This view is erroneous and misleading because; (a) It mistakes as to the time of the kingdom. This is to be at the consummation of the present age, when the Son of man shall appear and sit on the throne of his glory. (b) It belittles the conception of the kingdom. The common idea is simply that Christ will reign over subjects. But the saints are not to be simply subjects. A satisfactory definition of the kingdom of God may be thus expressed: The holy and happy dominion of Christ over and with his people on the earth, long predicted and expected, to come in glory at his return. And then, or beyond, are the new heavens and earth and the New Jerusalem. (c) If we make that kingdom to be merely a good and religious state of society, we not only belittle, but annihilate the Scripture idea of the kingdom of God.
In strange contrast to this is an alleged kingdom of reconstructed mortal human society, and the astounding teaching that if men are ever to see the kingdom of God, they must see it “on this side of the grave;” i. e., in “flesh and blood.”
This is only a nightmare, born of indigestion from too strong a dose of modern “advanced thought;” a caricature thrown on the curtain by the false light of evolutionary naturalism—a ghastly caricature of the kingdom which the little flock is to inherit. Let us turn from this vanity; let us wait for the Lord Jesus from heaven; let us rejoice in hope of the glory of God. The kingdom will come in its time. Amen. Even so, come, Lord Jesus! Earth waits for her King.
3. It is fraught with danger.
It is not a harmless dream, which may cheer the weary pilgrim, nor a high ideal, which, though unattained, may stimulate to holy endeavor. It is an ignis fatuus of the marsh, or a mocking mirage of the desert, luring to danger and despair. My indictment against it on the practical side has five counts; but the space left permits me, at this time, to do little more than state them.
(a) It tends to heresy. This idea of the kingdom is so contrary to the obvious meaning of the New Testament that it can be logically held only with loose views of inspiration, and we all know to what that tends. Nor is it uncharitable to note that some of its advocates are already undervaluing “doctrine” and “denominationalism,” and showing a tendency to “new theology,” and so-called “higher criticism.” This is not accidental.
(b) It tends to destroy the spirituality of the Church. It has been said disparagingly, that our theory has been that the world simply furnishes raw materials to make Christians out of. “I thank thee, Jew, for teaching me that word.” They are raw materials and dead materials, too, till vivified by the word and Spirit of God. But natural men can undertake the rectification of evils in society; if the Church makes that her work, spirituality will gradually die out; she will become raw and dead herself. The Church will not reorganize the world, but the world will reorganize the Church.
(c) It tends to strife and every evil work in the Church. It would be impossible, for example, to bring in political, social, and industrial questions, on which well-meaning men differ, without transferring secular strife and bitterness from the world to the Church.
(d) It tends to apostasy. What is more characteristic of the Roman apostasy than the idea of the Church ruling the world, and undertaking to do everything that anybody, anywhere, ought to do? Thoroughly carried out, this new departure would produce an apostasy worse than the Roman—modern, skeptical, hopeless.
(e) It tends to betray the best interests of mankind. The largest hope for society lies in the indirect influence of a vital, spiritual, aggressive Christianity. The new departure would result in abandoning this hope in the expectation of doing what is impossible. And alas! it shows a decided leaning toward socialism, the deadliest foe of liberty and civilization—the exact opposite of true, self-sacrificing Christian communism.
In conclusion let me say, It is a pity for one to spend his life and energies in compassing vanity, and have this word come true of himself and his work:—
Diving, and finding no pearls in the sea, Blame not the ocean, the fault is in thee.
—James Willmarth, D.D., in the Examiner.