WHICH WAY?

20%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Michigan · Aug 7, 1894

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 71, No. 32.

Read the full edition

WHICH WAY?

The Christian Reformer urges that this is a Protestant Christian country, deplores the increase of Sunday desecration, and says: “There is but one remedy for all these national ills, and that is a return to the religion of our fathers. This cannot be done without a proper regard for the Sabbath.”
The above statement suggests some questions: With 9,000,000 Catholics in this country, with other millions under Catholic influence, and with many millions with no religion at all, how can the nation, as a nation, return to the Protestant Christian religion, which the Reformer declares to have been the religion of those who settled this country?
Again: Granting that Sunday should be kept, that the religion of our fathers should again be practiced, and that we can get back to it, how shall we proceed? Shall we by law compel the observance of Sunday, that we may again possess the old-time religion? or shall we in some way become possessed of that religion, that Sunday may be observed? Do we get religion out of Sunday, or Sunday out of religion? It strikes us that if there is any real sincerity in this proposal of the Reformer, it would see that the religion is of the first importance, and that any and every attempt to bring about the particular observances of any religion whatever, without a return to the religion itself to begin with, will prove a dismal failure. This would be like tying fruit into dead branches to deceive oneself with the vain hope that the tree is still alive.
Sunday is not kept, because people do not regard it as their fathers did; and the Protestant churches, by their failure to receive and observe the Sabbath of the Scriptures, and their acceptance of the Catholic, traditionary Sunday, have been obliged to take the consequences,—the holiday Sunday. Puritanism has always striven against it, and the fight is still kept up; but the holiday character of Sunday observance grows continually, and bids likely to do so in the future. No persecution of Bible Sabbath-keepers can give holiness to Sunday, nor take from it the holiday character, which, outside of Puritanism, it has ever borne, and which it inherits from its pagan origin. M. E. K.