THE great effort that has lately been made by the American Railway Union to redress their real or fancied grievances by a strike of gigantic proportions, the apparent utter collapse of this effort in this direction, and the decided loss in popular support for the strikers which has ensued, will draw the attention of many minds to the question as to whether such labor unions are of any practical value to the public, or even to the laboring man himself. The disastrous effect to general business which has resulted from the strike, is convincing the majority of the people of the country that these unions are of no value to the public at large. Concerning the laboring man himself, one thing is certain: If they are of any service to him, he ought to be fairly prosperous; for there is no lack of unions of this kind. There are the Knights of Labor, the Federation of Labor, the American Railway Union, and to these might be added a very large number of organizations, cigar-makers, carpenters, bricklayers, shoemakers, glassblowers, in short, every conceivable trade has its union. The farmers have caught the fever, and the result is the Grange and the Farmers’ Alliance. So, if unions are a blessing to labor, labor ought to be enjoying much prosperity. The fact that it is not so is suggestive of the fact that these organizations, after all, have their disadvantages, and will not be able to bring about the desired results.
Following are some of the reasons why they are more or less unsuccessful: Only a portion of the laboring people will join these unions. Those who do not join have just as good a right not to join as others have to join. They are also just as truly laborers; they represent labor, and have a right to labor whenever and wherever they can find work to do. To say that they are not laborers, because they do not join a union, and to attempt to prevent their working, as is often done, is the quintessence of union tyranny. Every man has the undoubted right to hold himself aloof from all such organizations, and a large proportion of the laboring men in every avocation do so. This being the case, no union of laborers can authoritatively speak for all the laborers in that particular line of work. It may not be able even to speak for the majority. This will always be a standing hindrance to the claims of what is sometimes called organized labor to dictate its own terms of employment, and will be an indirect clog upon the power of labor unions. Again: every union must have an organization, officers, a place of meeting, general expenses, annual dues, etc. Here is a constant leakage of both time and money, which in manyp. 471 instances must be greater than any real advantage that is secured by the union.
Finally, the price of labor, like the price of anything else, is regulated more by the law of supply and demand than by any organization of labor. If the business depression now overshadowing the country should give way, and trade and commerce revive for a time, labor will again be in active demand, and hence the price for labor will be greater. Nothing else will have that effect. The outlook for such a condition of things at the present time is not particularly encouraging. M. E. K.