AdventAI

ANSWERS TO CORRESPONDENTS.

By G. C. T.

From Review and Herald, Vol. 71, No. 28., July 10, 1894

391.—VARIOUS QUESTIONS.

1. Was it not proper to worship our Saviour during his ministry on earth?

2. Does the apostle in 1 John 3:9 include sins of ignorance?

3. Does not the expression in 1 John 4:1, “Try the spirits,” mean that we are to try the persons in whom the spirit is manifested? E. G.

1. There are several instances in the gospel accounts where it is stated that individuals “worshiped” Christ. But the word does not necessarily imply divine homage. It means literally kissing the hand toward one as an act of respect. Practically it means an act of respect as the eastern salaam, or salutation. The question as to whether Jesus was a subject of divine honors in his human capacity is one which seems to us hard to settle. It is closely connected with that great mystery of godliness of which Paul speaks in 1 Tim. 3:16: “God was manifest in the flesh.” When he came into the world, the angels worshiped him; but he did not seek to lead men to do so. He came to minister rather than to be ministered unto; and yet he was the Son of God. We are not disposed to deny that he was entitled to worship; but it is quite evident that he did not claim it.

2. The expression, “cannot sin,” refers to moral rather than physical inability. We sometimes say when enticed to do wrong, I cannot do it. Joseph replied to his tempter, “How can I do this great evil and sin against God?” He that is born of God cannot entertain the desire to sin, nor can he by any means consent to do so. But this does not necessarily imply that his life will be infallibly correct. He may deviate through weakness or ignorance from the exact lines of rectitude, even while it is his sincerest purpose to do all things as he should.

3. We suppose it does. But the means by which we test individuals and those by which we would try spirits, are the same. These tests are, first, The word of God. “To the law and to the testimony; if they speak not according to this word, it is because there is no light in them.” Isa. 8:20. Second, “By their fruits ye shall know them.” Matt. 7:20. In fact, the individual and the spirit which actuates him are so closely identified that it would be difficult to say in any case exclusively whether we were trying the individual or his spirit.

392.—CONCERNING CHURCH POLICY.

1. Has a church a right to exclude members for disorderly walk? or do the words of Christ that we should let both wheat and tares grow together until the harvest, forbid such action?

2. Among the qualifications and disqualifications for the office of bishop or elder, mentioned in Titus 1:7, is “no striker.” Does this refer to indorsing notes? And would doing so disqualify a brother from holding that office? H. C.

1. It seems clear to us that moral character should be a test of church-membership. If it be made such upon admission to a church, then retention within the church should depend upon the maintenance of the standard by which admission is obtained. That is, it would not answer to require that candidates for admission possess certain moral qualifications, and not require those already admitted to maintain those qualifications. So that if the question of morality is to be considered upon taking people into the church, it must be considered in keeping them there.

The church is “the house of God, which is the church of the living God, the pillar and ground of the truth.” 1 Tim. 3:15. Of it the temple was a type. And Jesus with a scourge drove the covetous traders—the den of thieves—thence. Paul says: “Christ also loved the church, and gave himself for it; that he might sanctify and cleanse it by the washing of water by the word, that he might present it to himself a glorious church, not having spot, or wrinkle, or any such thing; but that it should be holy and without blemish.” Eph. 5:25–27.

But a query will perhaps be presented here as to what we have to do with cleansing the church. Is it not Christ’s work to cleanse his own church? We reply, God works through agencies, often through human agencies. He has said to his church, “Whatsoever ye shall bind on earth shall be bound in heaven; and whatsoever ye shall loose on earth shall be loosed in heaven.” Matt. 18:18. And upon another occasion: “Receive ye the Holy Ghost; whosesoever sins ye remit, they are remitted unto them: and whosesoever sins ye retain, they are retained.” John 20:23. These words show very clearly that the church, under the guidance of the Holy Spirit, is to act a part with Christ in its own development. Other texts upon this point are equally or more explicit.p. 443

Christ gives directions for procedure in cases of personal grievance. At first the person aggrieved must go to the offender alone to tell him his fault. If this fail, “take one or two more;” and if this fail, “tell it unto the church: but if he neglect to hear the church, let him be unto thee as a heathen man and a publican.” Matt. 18:15–17. To us that means, Turn him out.

Again we quote from 1 Cor. 5:9–13: “I wrote to you by letter, not to commingle with whoremongers. But I say not, with the whoremongers who are in the world, nor (speak I) of the avaricious, or of the rapacious, or of the idol-worshipers, otherwise ye would be obliged to go out of the world. But this is what I wrote to you, that ye commingle not, if any one is called a brother, and is a whoremonger, or avaricious, or an idol-worshiper, or a railer, or a drunkard, or rapacious,—with him who is such, not even to eat bread. For what business have I to judge them who are without? But those within the body, judge ye, and those without God judgeth; and remove ye the wickedness from among you.”

We have copied from the Syriac Version, not because it changes the sense, but it is made a little more perspicuous. It evidently means that we have nothing to do with judging those without; God will do that, but we are to judge those within, and to remove the “wicked person” (margin) from among us. A recent translation gives it, “Drive the villain out from among your own selves.” Paul writes to the Thessalonians: “Now we command you, brethren, in the name of our Lord Jesus Christ, that ye withdraw yourselves from every brother that walketh disorderly, and not after the tradition which he received of us.” 2 Thess. 3:6.

Letting the wheat and tares grow together does not refer to church discipline; for the “field is the world,” not the church.

We do not by any means hold that the expulsion of members is the primary function of the church. The work of the church is to seek and to save the lost. And in the care of the erring it is the sacred duty of the church to restore and help; to forgive, and to encourage the least desire for a better life; to awaken if possible in the cold-hearted, the dormant spiritual energies. But where the life is an open reproach to the cause, where there is no response to efforts in their behalf, the church should uphold the honor of God’s cause by setting the offending members one side.

It is only by doing so that the church shows her regard for the true standard of morality to be above all consideration of numbers or popularity. It is thus that the reputation of the church of Christ is maintained, and with it the reputation of her members. It is thus that church-membership is made any assurance of Christian character. It is in exercising the powers delegated her from Heaven that the church gains and retains that respect with which she has been clothed by her Lord.

2. No; the word has no reference to that. Greenfield thus defines it: “A striker, one apt to strike [smite], one who is contentious, or censorious, or given to reproaches.” Liddell and Scott say: “A disputer, a fighter.” That has nothing to do with signing notes. It is true that the Proverbs warn us against becoming surety for other people, and experience has many, many times shown it to be bad policy to do so. But it is not a crime or sin per se. It can be no worse than giving money away, and we have a right to do that under certain circumstances. He who indorses an obligation for a friend and receives ample security for doing so, violates no principle of good business or equity. He who does so without security and with the understanding that he will pay if called on, that he is likely to be called on, and that he would rather pay it than not to accommodate a friend, has a right to do so, if his motive be right and the circumstances justify him. But to pursue such a course is unwise business policy, and will result in loss to the one who does it and often to the cause of God, and there is where the wrong lies. It is on business principles that Solomon speaks, rather than moral ground. But the text in Titus bears no allusion to this matter.

393.—THE CLEAN AND THE UNCLEAN.

Please explain the following verse: “I know, and am persuaded by the Lord Jesus, that there is nothing unclean of itself: but to him that esteemeth anything to be unclean, to him it is unclean.” If I esteem swine’s flesh to be clean, am I justified in eating it?

S. C. C.

No; for the text referred to does not read nor mean that. While it may be and is true that a person’s regarding a thing to be wrong makes it wrong to him, it is not true that a person’s thinking a thing to be good and right makes it so. If God says swine is unclean, and he does, it is unclean, whether a man thinks so or not. If he fully believes that it is wrong to do a certain thing, he violates his conscience in doing that thing, and virtually commits sin, although in another man it might not be sin.

To understand this and similar texts it is necessary to realize that the apostle is not speaking of physical or inherent uncleanness. He does not teach that there is no such thing as “filthiness of the flesh;” quite the contrary. But what he here alludes to is the far more perplexing question of ceremonial uncleanness, which in the Jew’s mind was associated with nearly every act and article of life. To the apostle’s mind the only distinctions in that respect were those which the mind regarded. He teaches us that it is a dangerous thing to trifle with conscience, and that it is conscience and that only that renders a thing ceremonially clean or unclean. G. C. T.