A MEETING of rather a strange nature to be held in a Christian church was held in the Wesleyan church on Lonsdale St., Melbourne, Sunday afternoon, March 18. The announcement for the meeting, as it appeared in the Age of March 17, ran as follows:—
“Chinese Cabinet-makers and Obsolete Sunday Laws. New Legislation Demanded. To-morrow, three o’clock. Central Mission, Wesley Church. Speakers: Rev. A. R. Edgar, Hon. Alfred Deakin, and Joseph Winter, Mrs. L. A.”
The meeting was held ostensibly for the purpose of creating sentiment in favor of protecting European laborers by talking down Chinese cabinet-makers laboring on Sunday; but from the turn it took, it seemed to have been held for the purpose of creating sentiment in favor of protecting a religious institution, rather than of protecting Europeans or anybody else, the Chinese cabinet-makers being taken simply as a convenient occasion for making a beginning in this direction. Judging from the nature of the speeches made, Sunday legislation and Sunday enforcement was the subject, rather than the protection of any class of men. Where the people are somewhat enlightened on the subject of religious liberty and the dangers of religious legislation, movements in favor of such legislation very naturally take on an attitude not altogether natural or real.
Whatever wisdom or good policy there may be in governmental restriction upon immigration or the importation of alien labor, we were hardly prepared to hear from the pulpit of a professed missionary people the statement that “we make no secret that we would rather have the room of the Chinaman than his presence.” This seemed like a direct insult thrown in the face of “the heathen at our door.” At least we did not think “From Greenland’s Icy Mountains,” or the text, “Where there is neither Greek nor Jew, circumcision nor uncircumcision, Barbarian, Scythian, bond or free,” would have come in very appropriately just then.
But it seemed the sense of the meeting that the poor Celestials might be tolerated if a law could be secured compelling them to desist from working on Sunday. They were working too much, and the Europeans could not stand the competition. A Sunday law, it was thought, would quite meet the exigencies of the case. Rev. Mr. Edgar said, “We want to bring a pressure to bear upon the premier” to remedy this thing. The Hon. Mr. Deakin in the course of his address said:—
“Chinese labor needs regulating in a country like this. The Chinese are a standing menace to the country. It is the virtues of the Chinaman that make him the more dangerous,—his industry, his patience in learning, his initiative ability, his constant application.”
This we thought strange doctrine to come from either the State or the Church. The Bible teaches men to be “diligent in business,” and sound political economy shows that the idle and indolent, and not the industrious, are a menace to the country. When did virtues become vices, and need regulating by civil law? What sort of political economy can it be that teaches the wisdom of enforced idleness? If Chinamen have a right in a country at all, they certainly have a right to employ themselves in any honorable business to the extent of their ability. It is not the business of the State to attempt to force the religion of the Bible upon any one, or to see that men conform to any religion or religious customs. If any church desires the Chinese or any other people to do as it does in religious matters, we submit that the consistent course for it to attain this end is to convert them to its faith and teachings, and not attempt to bring the pressure of civil law to bear upon them, or insult them and drive them out of the country. Somehow this Sunday-enforcement question does not have the right ring to be compatible with the charity, the persuasion, and the world-wide missionary spirit which are so inseparably connected with the gospel of Christ.
The concluding words of Mr. Deakin’s speech were full of significance; they contained the dead-fly of church domination. He said:—
“There is no future for the State which encourages such things, and there is no future for the Church that permits the State to allow such things.”
This implies that the Church is a superior power to the State; that it is the guardian of the State, and that it may properly assume to control the State and direct its affairs. But this is the papal theory through and through. The papacy never claimed more. And nothing more is needed than the carrying out of this theory to have all the horrors and persecutions of the Dark Ages lived over again. Few seem to comprehend what is involved in such statements.
The closing remarks of Mr. Edgar showed that the logic of the theory involved in Mr. Deakin’s statement just quoted was to be carried out, and that the enforcement of Sunday observance on Chinamen was but a beginning of what was contemplated. He said:—
“We have made up our minds thoroughly upon this question. We have only touched the fringe of the business; but we intend to press into the center.”
Surely this Sunday movement will bear watching.— W. A. C., in Bible Echo.