AdventAI

A QUESTION ANSWERED.

By M. E. K.

From Review and Herald, Vol. 71, No. 25., June 19, 1894

THE following question occurs in a letter recently received at the Office: “If God commanded the children of Israel to keep the seventh day, in memory of their release from their hard task and bondage in Egypt, have we not also a right to keep sacred the first day, in memory of the resurrection of that dear Saviour?” etc.

This question shows the innate weakness of the arguments used to sustain the observance of Sunday. The premise here given has no foundation in fact, and then the conclusion drawn from this faulty premise does not naturally follow from it. God commanded Israel to keep the Sabbath, and the reason given is not local or national, but it is as broad as creation: “For in six days the Lord made the heavens and the earth, the sea, and all that in them is.” Ex. 20:11. Here is the reason, as given by the Creator in the most solemn manner. There is nothing in the Scriptures to show that they were required to keep the Sabbath in “memory of their release from their hard task and bondage in Egypt.” True, in the rendition of the commandments by Moses (Deuteronomy 5), after giving the substance of the Sabbath commandment, he adds: “And remember that thou wast a servant in the land of Egypt, and that the Lord thy God brought thee out thence through a mighty hand and by a stretched-out arm: therefore the Lord thy God commanded thee to keep the Sabbath day.” But Moses does not say the Sabbath should be kept in memory of the service in Egypt; but while they kept the Sabbath, they were to remember the hardships they had endured in Egypt, which is quite a different thing.

Our opponents are always in great haste to get away from the real and great reason given by God himself for hallowing the seventh day, to this statement of Moses, which they fancy gives them another reason.

But all that Moses says detracts nothing from the words of God. That they had been in bondage was a reason why they should keep all the commandments (see Deut. 16:12), but there was a greater reason than this, even for them, why they should keep them. That reason lies in the eternal principles of right and morality, upon which the law of God is based.

But look at the logic, or rather, absence of logic, of this question: Since God commanded men to keep one day, have we not a right to keep another day? Well, we should say, No. If the question had been, If God commanded us to keep one day, has he not a right to command us to keep another day? it would be a different thing altogether. Because God has commanded Israel, or any one else, to do one thing, gives us no right to do something else, certainly not anything that will be contrary to his will, as expressed in his law. We have no right to do anything that will nullify, or make void, what God has commanded. God’s law of ten commandments has no national or local application. It was committed to the Israelites because they were God’s especial people at that time; and Stephen, speaking in the gospel dispensation, says they “received the lively oracles to give unto us.” Acts 7:38. Let us receive these lively oracles reverently, and with the help of Christ live so that they may witness to the righteousness which is by faith in him.

M. E. K.