DISTURBED ABOUT SUNDAY

5%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Jun 12, 1894

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 71, No. 24.

Read the full edition

“DISTURBED ABOUT SUNDAY.”

BY L. H. ROWE.
(Mandarin, Fla.)
The Florida Christian Advocate, a Methodist paper published at Leesburg, Fla., recently printed an article under the above caption, which was aimed at those who are observers of the law of God, and Seventh-day Adventists were repeatedly mentioned.
It is evidently intended to counteract, in a measure, the success of Sabbatarians in their efforts to get people to be Bible Christians. In several instances, members of the Methodist churches have forsaken their denominational home, and cast in their lot with the despised disciples who are trying to obey the Lord and walk in his ways. This fact, more than any other, has been the means of drawing the fire of a big Methodist gun, and the bomb already exploded was filled with all sorts of material. The writer of the article is not known to the readers of the Advocate, and it is possible he did not wish to gain notoriety, as he failed to subscribe his name.
Notwithstanding the fact that Sunday-keepers are “disturbed” in their minds, yet this Advocate writer begins by boldly saying that “for more than 1600 years the Christian world observed Sunday as the Sabbath of the Lord, with wonderful unanimity. What a wonderful statement for a professed Christian to utter! This man is either ignorant or is trying wilfully to deceive people. At any rate, in his attempt to maintain Sunday sacredness, he allows his zeal to get the better of truthfulness. Perhaps he has not studied history on this subject. Had he done so, he would have learned that the first-day Sabbath was absolutely unknown before the time of Constantine.”
But this writer goes on to say: “There arose in England a small sect claiming that Saturday is the only true Sabbath, and not Sunday.” Another misrepresentation in his first paragraph. But he quickly leaves that remark, and says: “This new Saturday Sabbath has been advocated for about 300 years, and yet has had so little force and so little of God’s blessing that there are now only a few thousand Seventh-day Christians in all the world.” This man must be a wonder to those who know him, as he is to those who know him not. Has he counted up the number of Sabbatarians? Has he ever enjoyed any of the “force” and “blessing” which are bestowed on those who “remember the Sabbath day, to keep it holy”? If he had, he would not talk so far from truth. And has he forgotten all the Christians who have kept the Sabbath from the days of Jesus to the present time? It seems so, from what he says. But we need not enumerate all those, as we do not like to boast of our great numbers, as some churches do.
This Methodist divine is much troubled at the questions raised by some of his members, however, and his tirade continues: “But for the fact that very little is said in our preaching and published in our papers to instruct the people as to the claims of Sunday, their [Seventh-day] arguments would receive hardly any attention.” Well, it is too bad, really! He thinks the matter “ought to be discussed,” and “the subject fully presented,” and so he attempts to discuss it.
He first draws what he calls “a parallel case,” from Acts 15, on the question of circumcision, where the Jews thought they should observe that rite in the Christian age. Then he compares Sabbath-keepers to those circumcisers, by saying: “Now these Seventh-day people say that except we keep the seventh day of the week, as the law of Moses required, we cannot be saved—a precisely similar case, with exactly the same argument.” Now this man knows, or ought to know, that the cases are not similar in any respect; for one refers to a ceremonial law and the other to the moral law of God, and not the law of Moses. Sabbatarians do not obey the laws which were “done away,” but they do yield obedience to the commandments of the decalogue. These commands have not in them anything of a typical character, hence they are binding on Christians everywhere.
But this writer thinks he scores a point against commandment-keepers, and tries to clinch his very weak argument with Paul’s words in Gal. 5:1–6, and exhorts his followers to “stand fast in the liberty” of Christ. But what is this liberty of the gospel, that so much is said about nowadays? Is it liberty to sin? Nay, it is freedom from sin. But “sin is the transgression of the law.” Now all who transgress God’s law are servants of sin; hence they do not enjoy gospel liberty. And this Methodist friend is informed that the only way he can escape the penalty of sin is to stop sinning. But he does not want to keep the law of God, yet he wants to evade its penalty, and so he says the entire law is “abrogated.” He places all Old Testament laws under the head of “the law,” and wipes out everything, both moral and ceremonial. Speaking of the “gospel plan,” he tells his people that the old law was only intended to prepare a people for the coming and work of the Lord Jesus Christ, and the law was then to cease. Very true, so far as typical laws were concerned; but this man confounds the moral law with that of types and shadows, and says all was “abolished.” Well, if this was so, I should accept the result. But it is a false position, for “where no law is, there is no transgression;” and our friend would be hard pushed in his effort to convince men that they are sinners if there were no law in force.
He says truly, however, that “the Christian’s king is Christ,” and that the great commission of Christ sent his apostles to teach “all things” he had commanded. But he forgot to note the fact that Christ instructed his disciples to keep the law of his Father as he also kept it.
This writer, farther on in his article, notes the force of the objection raised by Seventh-day Adventists, that “there is a distinction between the ceremonial and the moral law of the Mosaic code, and that the ceremonial law was done away, while the moral law, given in the ten commandments, was not abolished.”
In commenting on the above well-founded objection, he endeavors to break it down by saying: “So far as the ten commandments belonging to the law of Moses, they were removed with that law, and when our blessed Lord gave his law, he adopted all of the ten commandments as his and required them to be kept, . . . excepting the Mosaic form of the fourth, which he never repeated as his, nor required at any time.”
What a quibbler this man is! In one sentence he will say the whole law is “abolished,” and in another, that only one of the ten precepts is “abrogated.” He blows both cold and hot, anyway to get the Sabbath out of the law and get Sunday into its place! He makes many Bible quotations, to give his article a respectable appearance; but they furnish no proof of his position being true; on the contrary, they are against him, but he does not seem to see it. The Devil can quote Scripture, but he misquotes, and then misapplies it. I have often seen his agents do the same thing, twisting and turning the Bible to suit their views, but they always fail to make out their claims. So it is with the Advocate writer.
But he says in another paragraph that the covenant “written on tables of stone” had been “done away with” and “abolished.” And he quotes 2 Cor. 3:1–14, to prove his assertion. This evidence, however, is dead against him; for Paul never intimated that the ten-commandment law was “abolished.” Why do so-called Christian ministers pervert the apostle’s words? Nothing was ended but the typical law and “the ministration of death,” which refers to the work of the priesthood. The functions of the priest were not on “the tables of stone,” but had respect to the law written on those tables. Moses veiled his face so the people could not see his glory; and the glory of that which was “done away” pertained to the minister and not to the law itself. This fact is so clear that a wayfaring man can understand it, so we pass it by.
Omitting the writer’s remarks about the nine commands being worked over into the new covenant, which we do not question, let us note some things he says of the fourth commandment, as on this hinges all the arguments of the Sunday advocates. He says: “The preceding statement brings out a remarkable fact; namely, our Lord’s omission of the command to observe the Sabbath. It is the only one left out. He embraced all of the ten but this, and nowhere in the New Testament is this required in express words—a fact utterly irreconcilable with the Seventh-day view.” It is not at all irreconcilable to such view, for while not explicitly given, it is always implied wherever the keeping of God’s law is referred to, as not a jot or tittle has ever been taken from that law and cannot be.
But we will let the writer of the article cut his own head off in his effort to fasten the Sunday onto the “abolished” command. Hear him: “The only explanation of our Lord’s leaving out the fourth commandment during his life is this, that he intended to modify it by changing the day from the seventh to the first, in commemoration of finishing the great work of redemption by his resurrection; . . . but if the change was made then, why was it not done with full publicity and positive statement in holy Scripture?” Hear the answer he gives to his own query: “Because changes which would make a marked separation of Christians from Jews, and give violent offense to the Jews, were made quietly by command of Christ to his apostles, and by the instruction of the apostles to the body of disciples; and this was one of those changes.”
Well, perhaps Sunday-keepers are satisfied with that explanation of the change of the Sabbath. It does not take much to satisfy some of them. And this great Sunday apostle ought to come out of his den and let his followers crown him “lord of Sunday.” This man has finally settled the Sunday question! He has given the whole argument entirely away by claiming that the Lord made the change secretly, because he was afraid to do it in a public manner!
Sabbath brethren, how does that impress you? Could you settle on any point with so weak an argument as that on which the Sunday Sabbath is based? I can hear you all say No in concert. The above “explanation” does not explain anything. It is worthless.
Did space permit it, it could easily be shown that Jesus did not omit the fourth command of the decalogue; that he did not intend to change the day; that he did not finish the great work of redemption at his resurrection; that he was not afraid to make any change which he desired to make; and that he never instructed anybody to change the law of God.