AdventAI

PHARISAICAL TRADITIONS.

By G. I. B.

From Review and Herald, Vol. 71, No. 27., July 3, 1894

That which, more than anything else, distinguished the Pharisees, was their zeal for the traditions of the elders, which they held to be not only equal to the authority of the Scriptures themselves but superior to them. Their doctrines concerning tradition relative to the Old Testament were very similar to those of the Catholic Church concerning the New Testament and tradition. They profess to accept the Scriptures, but when they conflict with tradition, the former are set aside, and the latter has the precedence.

The Pharisees claimed that when Moses received the law, there was also an oral law given to him, and given through him to Aaron, his sons, and the elders. This oral law was to explain the other, to tell what it meant. They claimed this was communicated from one generation to another till after the second destruction of Jerusalem. These traditions were finally written out in the middle of the second century after Christ in the book called the Mishna. There were comments finally written on this Mishna, which they call the “Gemara;” i. e., “Complement.”

The Mishna and Gemara together constitute the Talmud, and they contain the whole body of theology held to be the religious doctrines of the Jewish nation. These must be studied and learned by every one who teaches in Jewish schools.

In these traditions are some good things and some evil, and much that is foolish, childish nonsense. Our Saviour speaks plainly against these traditions, telling the Jews they made “void the commandments of God by their tradition,” specifying the fifth precept of the decalogue, which requires all to honor their parents. But they had a tradition which in reality set aside the command of God. He said, “In vain do they worship me, teaching for doctrines the commandments of men.” Matt. 15:9.

As tradition began to be largely received after the prophets ceased, about B. C. 400 or a little later, contentions began to manifest themselves, and parties arose among the Jews. The popular party accepted traditions, virtually giving them precedence over the Scriptures. Human nature, moved by the enemy of all good, naturally prefers human inventions to the word of the Most High. In all ages this has been proved true. Hence the sects, divisions, and various religious systems of our world. An honest desire to know God’s will, and a humble, reverential effort to perform it, never have resulted in such diversity. Pride of opinion, love of novelties, vain-glorious desires for prominence, and hair-splitting reasonings often bring such results.

The tradition party professed great love for the Scriptures, though they loved tradition more. They were called “Pharisees.” They easily succeeded in winning the support of the masses. But those more devoted and humble could not accept these traditions, but clung to the word of God alone and thought that sufficient. These were finally called Karaites. They in after ages constituted a strong party among the Jews. They are not mentioned by name in the New Testament, though doubtless many who received Christ were really of this belief. They seem to have been a more reasonable, pious people than any of the other Jewish sects. (For further particulars of them see “Mc Clintock’s and Strong’s Cyclopedia,” art. Karaites; also Schaff Herzog., art. Karaites.)

The circumstances existing in the Jewish Church after the time of the prophets were so similar to those of the Christian Church after the age of the apostles, that like results are to be observed in both cases; divisions, sects, discord, contention, unholy ambition, religious bigotry, a spurious theocracy, intolerance, persecution for religious opinion, tradition in place of the word of God, and the claim to have a right to control men’s consciences and force them to become good by legal enactments, penalties, and persecution.

We notice by way of illustration the extent and character of the Pharisaic traditions on the subject of the Sabbath, as given in “History of the Sabbath” and the “Sabbath Manual.” They enumerated about forty primary works which they said were forbidden to be done on the Sabbath. Under each of these were numerous secondary works, which they said were also forbidden. Among the primary works which were forbidden, were plowing, sowing, reaping, winnowing, cleaning, grinding, etc. Under the head of grinding was included the breaking or dividing of things which were before united. . . . Another of their traditions was that, as threshing on the Sabbath was forbidden, the bruising of things, which was a species of threshing, was also forbidden. Of course it was a violation of the Sabbath to walk on green grass, for that would bruise, or thresh, it. So, as a man might not hunt on the Sabbath, he might not catch a flea, for that was a kind of hunting. As a man might not carry a burden on the Sabbath, he might not carry water to a thirsty animal; for that was a species of burden-bearing; but he might pour water into a trough and lead the animal to it. . . . Yet should a sheep fall into a pit, they would readily lift him out and bear him to a place of safety. They said a man might minister to the sick for the purpose of relieving their distress, but not for the purpose of healing their diseases. He might put a covering on a diseased eye, or anoint it with eye-salve for the purpose of easing the eye, but not to cure the eye.

The reader familiar with the gospels will notice how Christ treated these traditions, and how angry the Pharisees were because he did not honor them. They had by their silly traditions made their method of keeping the Sabbath a yoke of bondage indeed. That day was to be a “delight, the holy of the Lord, honorable,” the best day of all the seven. But they had added to it till it was indeed a grievous burden. Our Saviour simply stripped off their traditions, and restored it to its original blessed character. Matt. 12:1–13; Mark 2:27, 28; Matt. 24:20, etc.

Thus had the Pharisees corrupted the worship of God in many ways. But our Saviour, the greatest reformer who ever lived, restored and spiritualized the worship, perfecting it and filling it with love and tenderness at his first advent. In the Christian dispensation a similar work of corruption has been wrought,—yes; one vastly more extensive. But a work of true reform will be seen previous to the second advent, bringingp. 424 back the principles and practice of the pure gospel of Christ to its original purity; casting aside every false tradition, and observing all the requirements of the gospel as Jesus and his apostles left it, preparatory to his return in glory, to give immortality and joy to his people.

G. I. B.