AdventAI

THE CHICAGO SUNDAY ORDINANCE.

From Review and Herald, Vol. 71, No. 27., July 3, 1894

[During the summer of 1893 the question of the observance of Sunday was a live subject in Chicago. The conflict over opening the World’s Fair upon Sunday, the appeals to, and decisions of, the courts, and the intensity of feeling that was aroused upon both sides of the controversy, will not soon be forgotten. That is all in the past, and it is not now known which party won, what some one has called the “battle of Chicago.” After the close of the Fair, the Sunday question has not been much discussed until lately a Sunday-closing ordinance was passed by the city council. The mayor’s veto, has, however, prevented the vote of the council from becoming a city ordinance. The reasons which led Mayor Hopkins to veto the ordinance may be gathered from the following extract from the official veto. They are worthy of the careful study of every American citizen.—M. E. K.]

“In most of the States all worldly labor or business is prohibited on Sunday, following in that regard the British statute enacted under the reign of Charles II. But in Illinois a different rule prevails. Worldly labor and employment are only prohibited in case they disturb the peace and good order of society. This distinction has been expressly recognized by our supreme court in the following language: ‘The offense by that [British] statute is the performance of labor or business, and by ours it is the disturbance of the peace and good order of society.’ And the appellate court, in construing our Sunday law, declares: ‘Labor on Sunday is not of itself punishable under this statute, nor can it be said that the statute prohibits labor on Sunday. The offense that is punishable is the disturbance of the peace and good order of society.’

“It is owing to this distinction that our courts have held that a contract made on Sunday is valid, and that even the operation of a reaping machine on the Lord’s day is not in itself punishable. In considering the ordinance passed by your honorable body at its last meeting, providing not only for the closing of certain stores and of barber-shops on Sunday, but also prohibiting the sale or barter of certain articles, whether done publicly or privately, we should keep in mind that it is not an enactment by the supreme law-making power of the State, with authority unlimited except as far as restricted by the Constitution, but a mere ordinance or by-law of a municipal corporation having no powers except such as are expressly delegated by its charter. The power to regulate Sunday observance is not in terms provided for in the general incorporation act, and can only be derived from the general police power granted to the city, which in turn must be exercised in harmony with the general policy of the State in relation to the subject in question.

“The ordinance was not passed in obedience to a demand of the people for the preservation of the peace and good order of society on Sunday by closing certain stores, but in consequence of the desire of certain employees of retail stores and barber-shops to procure by municipal enactment a much-needed day of rest. That desire is well justified, and every legitimate means should be employed to accomplish its fulfillment. It is a deep sense of the justice of their cause which led me long to hesitate as to my duty in the premises. Labor is struggling to throw off the shackles which have so long held it in bondage, and every proper attempt to secure to it its just rights, to elevate it to the position of dignity which it so highly deserves, will find inp. 421 me an enthusiastic supporter. But I cannot sanction a measure, which, under the guise of a police regulation for the preservation of the peace and good order of society on the Sabbath, so radically interferes with the private affairs of the citizens. The greatest measure of individual liberty compatible with the public welfare, is too precious a principle of our government to be sacrificed to prohibitive municipal legislation, and this ordinance, should it become a law, would establish a precedent which might some day become particularly obnoxious to the very cause of labor itself.

“I cannot take the view that in a large city the keeping open of a shoe-store or of a barber-shop disturbs the good order of society, however desirable the closing thereof may be from the standpoint of the overworked employee or in the interest of a religious observance of Sunday. And I agree with Mr. Justice Walker, when, in delivering the decision of our supreme court on the validity of Sunday contracts, he asks:—

“‘Must a person be criminally punished for writing a letter to a friend on Sunday? or a barber for shaving a customer? or a person for selling another a cigar? or purchasing or reading a newspaper on Sunday? and almost innumerable like acts? The statute could never have been adopted in such a spirit and for such purposes.

“In examining the question whether this ordinance can be justified as a police regulation for the preservation of the peace and good order of society, we should remember that this is a great commercial metropolis; that numerous lines of street and steam railroads, necessarily operated not only on week days, but also on Sundays, run through its territory from the heart of the city to the remotest outskirts like the arteries of the human body; that a somewhat limited but still considerable traffic surges through the streets on Sunday; that gas and electric works, water-pumping stations, furnaces of rolling mills, cannot stand still on Sundays; that the great newspapers are printed on that day in millions of copies and delivered by numberless carriers, sold from thousands of news-stands, and cried by newsboys in every thoroughfare, and that these conditions of unavoidably noisy urban life are radically different from the rural stillness prevailing in a small country village.

“In all American Sunday legislation but two leading theories are found. Upon one theory all worldly labor, or secular employment, is prohibited on the ground that it is the duty of the State, as a sanitary measure, to enforce upon all the people one day of rest in seven. The other theory is, that all the people should, if they choose, have an opportunity to enjoy one day of seven, and to protect this privilege such labor and amusements as would disturb the peace and good order of society on this day of rest should be prohibited. Which of these is the proper theory upon which to base Sunday legislation is a matter about which there may be fair differences of opinion; both of them, however, are intelligible.

“But the ordinance under consideration proceeds upon neither. To require persons engaged in only a dozen of the hundreds of lawful avocations pursued in this city to refrain from them on Sunday, certainly cannot be justified upon the theory of the enforced observance by all people of a day of rest. This ordinance singles out the merchants of certain lines, and permits all others to keep open as heretofore. It proceeds upon the theory that while the sale of a yard of calico or of a pair of boots disturbs the peace and good order of society, the selling of a lady’s bonnet by the milliner, of a box of cigars by the tobacconist, of a lamp by the crockery dealer, does not interfere with proper Sunday observance. Nor is it directed against the running of factories, of printing-presses, of blacksmith shops, boiler works, or any of the numerous industrial pursuits, the prosecution of which is necessarily attended with infinitely more noise and disturbance than the shaving of a customer by a barber or the sale of a ring or a watch by the jeweler. This discrimination is in itself conclusive proof that the object of the passage was not the exercise of the police power of the city, but the otherwise very laudable object to enforce a day of rest for the employees of a few stores therein enumerated.”