One of our religious contemporaries, whose creed on the nature of man is framed in accordance with the statement of the serpent to Eve in Eden, “Ye shall not surely die,” and which seems to prefer the old pagan fable of the immortality of the soul to the doctrine of life and immortality brought to light through Christ in the gospel, prints the following to set forth its ideas of the consciousness of the dead, and calls it “A Good Illustration” (!):—
“A clergyman once tried to teach some children that their souls would live after they were all dead; they listened, but evidently did not understand. Taking out his watch, he said:— “James, what is this I hold in my hand?” “A watch, sir.” “How do you know it is a watch?” “Because we see it, and hear it tick.” “Very good.” “He then took off the case, and held it in one hand, and the watch in the other. “Now, children, which is the watch? You see there are two, which look like watches. Now I will lay the case aside—put it away down here in my hat. Now let us see if you can hear the watch ticking. “Yes, sir, we hear it,” exclaimed several voices. “Well, the watch can tick, go, and keep time, as you see, when the case is taken off and put in my hat, just as well. So it is with you, children. Your body is nothing but the case; the body may be taken off, and buried in the ground, and the soul will live just as well as this watch will go when the case is taken off.”
The redeeming feature of this illustration is, that any child of ordinary intelligence, if he will bestow a little thought upon the subject, will discover its innate falsity and foolishness. For instance, of the two parts of the watch named, the works, or that part which “ticks,” is just as literal visible, and material as the outside case of the watch. But is the imaginary immortal soul, which this portion of the watch is taken to represent, just as literal and tangible an entity as the body?—Not at all. It is invisible, intangible, inaudible, and is even said to be immaterial. Then between it and the watch there is no comparison, and the illustration is no illustration at all.
If, when a person died, it was customary to trim off a few of the outer members, like the legs, arms, ears, nose, etc., and then the remainder, or, at least, some part of the body that was left, flew away as visible, tangible, and active as ever, there would be some fitness in the illustration, but not otherwise. In the death of the body every function of life ceases, and every organ, so far as we have any knowledge of it, is deprived of life and activity. Now, to illustrate this by a watch, every wheel should be removed, every pivot broken, and the whole thing demolished. Then put a part of it into your hat, and see if you can hear the other part tick. And that is the condition of man in death.
How did the children know that the watch was going when the case was in the hat? O they heard it “tick.” But when a person dies, and the supposed soul is separated from the body, how does any one know there is such a soul which has come from that body, and is alive and active, separate from the body? Do they hear it tick? Does it make any manifestation to demonstrate its presence? Our contemporary will probably say, “No.” Then where is the proof of its continued existence, like that of the watch? The Spiritualist would say, “Yes, we hear it tick. It comes around, tips up my table, knocks my furniture about, writes gibberish, and cuts up various antics, and so we know the soul is there, for we hear it tick.”
And that is all the evidence we have of any such existence, and this right in the face of the positive declarations of Scripture that “the dead know not anything,” that their “thoughts” are “perished,” and that they sleep till they are raised, at the last trump. All the doctrine of the immortality of the soul is good for, in the Christian world, is to “make the pope’s pot boil,” and to play into the hands of the Spiritualists. Protestant believers would do better to come back to the truth on this subject, as made plain in the word of God.