AdventAI

ROME'S SABBATH THEORY UNCHANGED.

By M. E. K.

From Review and Herald, Vol. 71, No. 7., February 13, 1894

It is possible that some persons who will read the articles reprinted from the Catholic Mirror, claiming that it was the authority of the Catholic Church alone that brought about the observance of Sunday in the place of the Sabbath, will be surprised at the frankness with which the claim is made, and perhaps they will think that this claim of Rome is something new. This is not the case. A reference to the standard books of the Roman Church will prove that they have always held this position, and ecclesiastical history shows that whenever any attempt has been made by the Reformers who separated from Rome to return to the Scriptures, the Roman Church has held up before them the fact that they did not keep the Sabbath according to the Scriptures to which they were claiming that they were loyal. A striking instance of this kind has lately come under our observation, in Bishop Burnet's history of the Reformation. The following are the facts as presented in the history:—

Upon the accession of Elizabeth to the throne of England, she immediately summoned the Parliament to meet, and the most important matters that were brought before it were those concerning religion. The questions concerning the succession of St. Peter, the nature of the mass, the right of the laity to partake of the wine as well as the bread of the sacrament, the propriety of reading prayers in a tongue unknown to the common people,—in short, all the principal points of difference between the present Church of England and the Catholic Church, were to be discussed. Nine disputants were appointed on either side. The leader of the papal party was Dr. Cole. The argument of this Romish champion against the use of the language of the people in the services of the church and in favor of the use of an unknown tongue is thus recorded by the historian:—

“The substance of it was, ‘that although it might seem that the Scriptures had appointed the worship of God to be in a known tongue, yet that might be changed by the authority of the church, which had changed the Sabbath appointed in the Scripture, without any authority from thence. Christ washed his disciples' feet, and bade them do the like, yet this was not kept up: Christ instituted the sacrament of his body and blood after supper, and yet the church appointed it to be received fasting: so had the church also given it only in one kind, though Christ gave it in both: and whereas the apostles, by authority from the Holy Ghost, commanded all believers to abstain from blood, yet that was not thought to oblige any now: and though there was a community of goods in the apostles' time, it was no obligation to Christians to set up that now: so that this matter was in the power of the church.’”—“Burnet's History of the Reformation,” Vol. I, p. 571.

The argument itself, as presented in writing by Dr. Cole, is also given in book 3, part 3, p. 292, and from it we extract that part which refers to the Sabbath commandment:—

“And this we affirm [the right to conduct the church services in a tongue unknown to the common people], first, because there is no scripture manifest against this our assertion and usage of the church. And thoughp. 103 there were any, yet it is not to be condemned that the church hath received. Which thing may evidently appear in many things that were sometime expressly commanded by God and his holy apostles.
“As for example (to make the matter plain) ye see the express command of Almighty God, touching the observation of the Sabbath-day, to be changed by the authority of the church (without any word of God written for the same) into the Sunday. The reason whereof appeareth not to all men; and however it doth appear, and is accepted of all good men, without any controversy of Scripture; yea, without any mention of the day, saving only that St. John in his Apocalypse nameth it Diem Dominicam; in the change whereof all men may evidently understand the authority of the church, both in this cause and also in other matters, to be of great weight and importance, and therein esteemed accordingly.”

The reasoning of Dr. Cole in this instance is well worthy of our careful attention. He cited several manifest departures from the Scriptures which the church had authorized, and upon this basis attempted to establish the principle that the church had a right to do so, and that having done so, and these changes having been accepted, they must not now depart from them. Really he tried to prove the rightfulness of one departure from the truth by the fact that they had made another departure of a similar kind,—the right to hold the services of the church in a language foreign to the people, by the right to change the Sabbath!

Let us notice the various points mentioned: The observance of the Sabbath, the ordinance of humility, the right of the church to receive the sacrament without fasting, also the right of the laity to partake of the communion in both kinds, and the duty of abstaining from blood, are all either plainly set forth or implied in the Scriptures, and neither the Roman Church nor any other church has any right to abrogate, change, or otherwise modify the word of God in reference to these matters. As far as the community of goods is concerned, which was also cited as something established by the apostles, but which the church had not kept up, it is sufficient to say that there is no Scripture to show that a community of goods was ever commanded by any of the apostles, but rather that it was a spontaneous and voluntary act of the brethren to relieve the distress that existed at that time among the poorer class of the disciples; and, therefore, not being commanded, as soon as the special and temporary necessity for this course of action ceased, the cause no longer existing, the disciples resumed the ordinary and natural way of each holding his own property. That this was so is evident from the fact that when Ananias sold his possession and then lied about it, Peter declared that it was Ananias's own, and that even after it was sold, there was no obligation upon him to give it away. It was not, therefore, a matter of apostolic command or direction. Aside from this one point, therefore, the argument of Dr. Cole was logical if not Scriptural. We say logical, because it must have appeared so to those, who, by their acceptance of the change of the Sabbath made by the church, were thereby pledged to every other change that she might authorize; for if the fourth commandment can be changed by the church, as those with whom he was disputing acknowledged had been done, then assuredly the smaller changes referred to, such as the introduction of prayers in the Latin language, or the withholding of the cup from the laity would be admissible, if authorized by the same church.

It is also worthy of note that Bishop Horn, in his reply to Dr. Cole, made no attempt to meet his argument drawn from the accepted change of the fourth commandment, but contented himself with making a straightforward argument from the Scriptures that public prayers should be in the language of the common people, which would indicate that he was not able to meet Dr. Cole in his argument upon this point, without surrendering his false Sabbath and going back to the Sabbath of the Scriptures. Thus Rome, through her agents, has ever held up before those who were venturing to question her authority the fact that by her authority alone Sunday had taken the place of the Sabbath; and that as they had bowed in submission to Rome in so great a matter as the virtual change of one of the primary commandments of God's law, it would be very unwise in them to question the same authority in matters of much smaller moment. How many persons have been prevented by such arguments from taking one step away from Rome, the judgment alone can reveal.

The examination which we have here given to this historical fact, will also show that had the English Church in her separation from Rome been as consistent in the matter of Sabbath-keeping as she was in the other points referred to, that church would inevitably have returned to the observance of the Sabbath of the Lord. But the prelates who organized the church of England had not got far enough away from the spirit of the mother church to deny entirely the authority of the church to make such changes as she saw fit. It is also to be feared that they were actuated as much by a wish to be independent as they were by the desire to return to a Scriptural foundation.

There is one other point that may be noticed with profit. The papal doctor, after telling how the church had changed the Sabbath, made the very naive confession that “the reason whereof [the change of the Sabbath], appeareth not to all men”! If this was the truth then, it certainly is the truth now; and we are glad that every day men are becoming doubtful of the authority of any church to change the positive commands and ordinances of the Lord. And they do not rest content with simply doubting the authority of the church to change God's commands, but they believe the words of God to be still the foundation of faith and practice, and so the number of those who “keep the commandments of God and the faith of Jesus” is steadily increasing. Let the good work go on, let the word of God stand out in bold relief against the doctrines and commandments of men, until all shall be able to “discern . . . between him that serveth God and him that serveth him not.” M. E. K.