SPIRITUALISM

7%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Feb 20, 1894

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 71, No. 8.

Read the full edition

SPIRITUALISM

An Exposure and a Warning.

THE GENUINENESS OF MODERN SPIRITUALISTIC MANIFESTATIONS.

“Now the Spirit speaketh expressly, that in the latter times some shall depart from the faith, giving heed to seducing spirits, and doctrines of devils.” 1 Tim. 4:1. “He is antichrist, that denieth the Father and the Son.” 1 John 2:22.
Those who have considered with any care the phenomena and literature of Spiritualism will scarcely have failed to notice how much the name covers. Like the German “Poltergeist,” it may be said to summarize all the experiences of different ages which relate to the so-called supernatural, with the exception only of those phenomena which the Bible attributes to the immediate action of God himself. Among western nations it includes witchcraft, magic, necromancy, mesmerism, magnetism, electro-biology, electrical-psychology, table-turning, spirit-rapping, medium soothsaying, clairvoyance, clairaudience, trance-speaking, and every form of direct intercourse, supposed or real, with the spirit world. To these may be added that recent importation from the East; namely, Theosophy, or Esoteric Buddhism. We do not say that the name is correctly so applied in all cases; we do not say, for example, that mesmerism is a spirit force, but that the name is so applied, admits of no contradiction.
The question, Is there anything in Spiritualism? has been often asked, and has been answered in a great variety of ways. It is clear that this question is one of grave importance. “When the late President Day, of Yale College, first had his attention called to Spiritualism, a quarter of a century ago, he said, ‘Either nothing is in it, or the Devil is in it.’ No candid man, who knows its history during these twenty-five years, will now affirm the first wing of the president’s alternative. The second is as philosophical as it is Scriptural.” So wrote, twenty years ago, the author of a work on this subject, published by the Congregational Publishing Society of Boston. This alone, as coming from America, the stronghold of Spiritualism, should be sufficient to impress every thoughtful person with the importance of the question. “Either nothing is in it, or the Devil is in it,” is the postulate of President Day. “No candid person will affirm that there is nothing in it”—such, in substance, is the comment of our author twenty-five years later. The alternative is sufficiently startling.
“Better let the subject alone,” one sometimes hears said. But is it better? Supposing the phenomena to be genuine, how does this advice accord with the apostolic command, “Try the spirits whether they are of God”? 1 John 4:1. To try them does not mean to communicate with the spirits themselves, but to note the effect of their teaching, and, above all, to examine their pretensions by the word of God. “If Spiritualism turns out to be only a re-discovery of the ancient art of consulting familiar spirits,” says Joseph Cook, of Boston, “there is no necessity of denying the reality of such communication, but there is a great necessity of proclaiming with Biblical emphasis its untrustworthiness, mischievousness, and wickedness.”
The time has gone by for ignoring the existence of the movement, whatever its origin or tendencies may be. During the past fifty years, Spiritualism, like a deadly upas-tree, has been striking out its roots in all directions; and though its effects, thus far, have been mostly felt in America and on the Continent, England has by no means escaped the contagion. Twelve years ago a public writer asserted that “there is more necromancy practiced in the British metropolis in one week than in the whole land of Canaan in any twelvemonth before the children of Israel came into possession of it”; and no less a person than Dr. James Edmunds, the quondam president of the London Dialectical Society, affirms that “the medium is becoming the adviser of superstitious women and the rival of the priest.” Nay, further; he asserts that “Spiritualism is being adopted by many persons in whose hearts other faiths have hitherto been enshrined, and it is becoming a great disintegrator of the ancient strata of religious dogma.” Several years ago, William Howitt, the poet, estimated the number of Spiritualists at 20,000,000, and drew attention to the extensive “spiritual” literature in America, France, Switzerland, and Germany. The “Report” of the Dialectical Society contains a list of over 400 works on this subject; and perhaps this represents less than a fifth part of the present literature of Spiritualism. Such being the case, it becomes imperative to inquire, What effect has Spiritualism on the lives of men? Is its influence for good or for evil?
First, however, it will be necessary to inquire concerning the reality of the phenomena of Spiritualism. Are the manifestations genuine? Mark—we do not ask, are all the manifestations genuine? Undoubtedly there is much imposture and trickery practiced by self-styled mediums in the name of Spiritualism; but is the whole system a fraud? Are all the manifestations spurious? Is every one of the twenty millions and more of Spiritualists on the earth to-day a deceived person—deceived, we mean, as to the reality of the phenomena, which attest, as they affirm, the truth of their religion? This is the question that we have first to answer.
The testimony of men of science is, of course, of the utmost importance in connection with such an inquiry. If we turn to Germany, we are at once met with the names of six eminent scientists who have given their attention to the subject; namely, Zöllner, Fechner, Scheibner, Fichte, Weber, and Ulrici. These savants, who are behind none in this country as careful investigators of facts, have all expressed their belief in the genuineness of spiritualistic manifestations. The three first-named are (or were) professors at Leipzig University, Zöllner occupying the chair of physical astronomy, Fechner that of physics, and Scheibner that of mathematics. Fichte and Ulrici were professors of philosophy, the one at Tübingen, and the other at Halle; and Weber is world-known as a professor of electricity and author of learned works on that topic.
Now these gentlemen rest their belief in the genuineness of spiritualistic manifestations on experiments performed in their own presence on several successive occasions. Let us notice one or two of these experiments:—
Here is one, performed by mediumistic means under the searching gaze of Professors Zöllner and Weber. “I pasted,” says the former, “half a sheet of ordinary writing-paper on a rather large wooden board, and blackened the paper by holding it over a petroleum lamp, and then laid it under a table at which W. Weber, Slade, and I had taken our places. Suddenly the board under the table was violently shoved out about a yard, and when I lifted it up, there was the impression of a naked left foot. I at once asked Slade to stand up and show me both his feet. He willingly agreed. After he had pulled his shoe off, his stocking was examined to see if there was any soot upon it; but nothing was found. He was then asked to have his foot measured, and the length of the impression was found to exceed that of his foot by four and a half centimeters.” To make assurance doubly sure; this experiment was afterward repeated with a closed book-slate, the paper (blackened as before) being placed inside. Professor Zöllner continues his account in these words: “To my great surprise Slade agreed that I should lay the book-slate (that, since I had blackened the paper, I had not once let go out of my hands) during the séance upon my knees, so that I could always see half of it. We had been sitting perhaps five minutes at the table, in the brightly-lighted room, our hands linked with those of Slade upon the table, in the usual manner, when I felt twice, at short intervals, that the slate upon my knees was pressed down without the slightest visible cause. Three knocks on the table announced that all was finished, and when I opened the slate, I found inside on one side the print of a right and on the other of a left foot, the latter the same as we had obtained the two previous evenings. My readers may judge for themselves how far it is for us, after such facts, to look upon Mr. Slade as a deceiver or a trickster. Slade’s own astonishment at the success of the experiment was almost greater than mine.”
Here is another experiment: The two ends of an unknotted piece of pack-thread were sealed together by Professor Zöllner, and the sealed ends were placed beneath his thumbs in such a manner that the rest of the thread (the loop, or curve) hung down into his lap. The experiment took place in a room with which the medium was not familiar. What followed? “While that sealed pack-thread hung, without a knot, in the lap of Professor Zöllner, and when the psychic was out of reach of the thread entirely, four knots were tied in it.” Four knots, tied without visible hands in an endless and hitherto unknotted piece of thread—consider that!
The above experiment was repeated in this country by Dr. T. L. Nicholl, a learned London physician. Here is his statement: “I cut four yards of common brown twine, examined it carefully, tied the two ends together in a single knot, which included both, then passed the united ends through a hole in my visiting card; tied a square knot and firmly sealed this knot to the card, and asked a gentleman to seal it with his seal ring. On this card I also put my signature and the date. The loop of the string, whose two ends were thus sealed to the card, I again examined, and found it free from knots. Six persons, including Mr. Eglinton and Mr. Colman, sat round a small table. The sealed card was placed on the center of the table, and the fingers of each person present placed upon it, while the loop hung down upon the floor. This position was maintained for about a minute, when raps were heard, and I examined the string. The ends were firmly fastened and sealed as before, and five single knots were tied upon it, about a foot apart—on the single endless string, observe, whose perfect fastening had never left my sight—where they now remain. It is certain that no mortal man could have tied these knots—equally certain that all the philosophers and all the ‘magicians’ of Europe cannot now untie them under the same conditions. Here is a fact which can be proved in any court of justice.”
But we have not done with the Leipzig professors. Professor Zöllner was curious to experiment concerning the power of matter to pass through matter, and for this purpose placed two conch-shells on the center of the table at which he was seated, the smaller being covered by the larger. What followed is best given in his own words: “As Slade was holding the slate in the usual manner under the edge of the table, to receive writing, something suddenly struck on the slate with a clattering sound,—as if some heavy body had fallen upon it. When, immediately thereafter, the slate was taken out for examination, the smaller conch-shell lay on it. Since the two shells had lain before me almost exactly in the middle of the table, untouched, and constantly watched, here was, therefore, the often-observed phenomenon of the penetration of matter, presented in a surprising and wholly unexpected physical manner. Immediately after Slade drew the slate from under the table, with the smaller shell on it, I seized the shell, in order to ascertain whether it had suffered any change. I came very near letting it fall, so very hot had it become. I gave it immediately into the hand of a friend, and he found it of a remarkably high temperature.”—From a London Paper.