It is not often that a person takes his stand on a position, every item of which is wholly non-Scriptural, anti-Scriptural, and false; but such a case appears to have come to light. In the Christian Standard (Disciple paper) of Jan. 20, a Mr. Ruble gives a report of a debate held by one B. F. Bonnel, in Oregon. He is represented as coming forth like a little David, with a little sling, and meeting a great Goliath of a Seventh-day Adventist, whom he proceeds to demolish with great skill and prowess, throwing the whole Seventh-day Adventist Philistine host into consternation and dismay! But somehow it strikes us that in the incident from which the illustration is taken, it was Goliath who did the boasting. But, from the way little David here launches out in boastful defiance, we imagine the reporter has confused the parties, and that the Disciple is the Goliath and the Seventh-day Adventist the David.
The proposition under discussion was the perpetuity of the Sabbath, which, of course, Mr. Bonnel opposed; and the following are the propositions by which he is said so wonderfully to have overthrown Seventh-day Adventism:—
1. He, Bonnel, showed, says the reporter, that the old covenant, which contained the Sabbath law, had vanished away. Heb. 8:5.
Answer.—The claim that the old covenant contained the Sabbath law is absolutely false. The Sabbath was no part of that covenant, any more than the law against theft and murder. Consequently the passing away of that covenant does not in the least affect the law or the Sabbath.
2. That Christians were under a new and better covenant. Heb. 8:6.
Ans.—As a mere statement, correct; but, as he uses it as an argument to show that the law has been done away, it is wholly false; for the new covenant is not a new law, but both the old and new covenants were made with reference to the same law,—that law which expresses man's moral obligation to God, which is the law containing the weekly Sabbath.
3. That the law existed, as a schoolmaster, till Christ came, and no longer. Gal. 3:25.
Ans.—Mixed again; for Paul is not talking about the law that contained the Sabbath. One ought not to take up a work on poultry, and claim that the author is talking about horses. There were two systems of law. One has passed away, while the other, containing the Sabbath, still continues.
4. That the law was dead to the Christian. Rom. 7:6.
Ans.—Rom. 7:6 contains not the slightest indication that the law is dead; but, as in verse 4, “Ye,” talking to the disciples, “are become dead to the law.” So in verse 6, that which dies is the same party. Does Mr. Bonnel read New Testament Greek? He ought to be able to do so, before he goes about demolishing Goliaths. But if he does, he knows the participle “being dead,” is in the nominative plural, agreeing with the word “we” before, not with law. A wonderful champion indeed, who will try to make a nominative plural participle (apothanontes) agree with a noun in the genitive case and singular number (nomou). Paul does not say we are delivered from the law, it being dead, as he would have said if it was the law which he wished to show had died. No, but we being dead to that wherein we were held. And what was that in which we were held?—It was sin, not the law. Now there are two expressions to describe this one change experienced in conversion. These are, first, That sin dies, the body of sin, the old man is slain; or, which is the same thing, we die. So it is proper to say “that being dead wherein we were held,” which is sin; or, “We being dead to that wherein we were held,” which is sin. These are synonymous expressions; but they refer to sin, not to the law.
5. That the law engraved upon tables of stone was the ministration of death. 2 Cor. 3:7.
Ans.—Paul is here talking about the ministration, not about the law, and Mr. Bonnel ought to know the difference between the ministration and the law. There was no ministration graven upon the tables, but only the law, in reference to which the ministration was performed, which explains the peculiarity of Paul's expression in this case. (See Bloomfield's New Testament on this point.)
6. That it was done away. Verse 11.
Ans.—There is not the slightest indication in 2 Corinthians 3 that the law was done away, but the glory of that ministration was done away. Verse 7. Let Mr. Bonnel look at the Greek on this point also, which completely establishes this proposition.
7. That it ended, and was abolished. Verse 13.
Ans.—It is the ministration, not the law, of which the apostle here speaks as passing away. The ministration under Moses gave place to the ministration of the Spirit under the gospel. The glory of the former passed away, being eclipsed by the greater glory of the present. But this is not the law in either case. It is the two ministrations that are spoken of.
8. That it was nailed to the cross (Col. 2:14) and taken away.
Ans.—Paul is here talking about the ceremonial law, not the moral.
9. That all sabbaths were a shadow of things to come. Col. 2:17.
Ans.—The yearly, ceremonial, sabbaths of the Jewish system, of which alone Paul is here speaking, were shadows; but the weekly Sabbath of Jehovah, which was instituted before the fall, and therefore before a shadow could possibly exist, cannot, by any possibility, be a shadow.
10. That it [the Sabbath] is typical of the future rest of God's people. Heb. 4:3.
Ans.—Then why in the name of reason does he not keep it? for every type must reach to its antitype. And, as the promised rest is still future, the Sabbath, if a type of it, is still binding, on his own showing. It is amusing to see a man come forth and try to play the rôle of David in his contest with Goliath, and then get all tangled up in his own sling.
In the foregoing propositions, which Mr. Bonnel tried to maintain, there is more error to the inch, linear measure, than we ever remember to have seen before in the same space. So much for his opposition to the Sabbath. But there was another proposition in debate, which read as follows: “That the first day of the week is the day designated in the Scriptures upon which Christians should meet to worship.” This, of course, Mr. Bonnel affirmed, and the Seventh-day Adventist denied.” After a mass of irrelevant inferences and deductions on this point, the affirmative finally reached this sublime conclusion; that “Christians have the right, if they choose to do so, to respect the Lord’s day, on which he arose from the dead, and brought life and immortality to light by the gospel.”
So, the whole grand scheme of Sabbath-keeping, as brought to view in the Bible, the whole significance of that glorious institution, the displays of God's power in its behalf, and the priceless blessings connected with it,—all dwindle down at last into the weak and flimsy proposition that a person has a right, if he wants to, to observe Sunday! Mirabile dictu! We thought this man was around slaying Goliaths; but instead of holding up the heads of giants as evidence of his victory, all the trophy that he can at last produce, is a dead mouse.
The reporter adds: “If any church in reach of brother Bonnel is troubled by these Sabbath Adventists, I advise them to send for him.” And we would advise our people to send for him, too; for he is just about the man to show up to the people the utter folly of the opposition to the moral precepts of Christianity, as embodied in the decalogue.