AdventAI

A POOR FOUNDATION.

By M. E. K.

From Review and Herald, Vol. 71, No. 8., February 20, 1894

A TRACT lately received, published by the Christian Publishing Association, Dayton, Ohio, attempts to sustain the observance of Sunday from the Bible in the following unique manner: It quotes John 20:26 thus: “And after eight days [from the old Sabbath] his disciples were within, and Thomas with them.” The event referred to from which the eight days were to be counted, was the appearance of Jesus to the disciples on the evening succeeding the day of his resurrection. John 20:19.

The absurdity of trying to make a period of eight days from the evening of one first day reach no farther than the evening of the next first day, which has been so often pointed out, has induced this writer, in his great anxiety to have both these appearances of Christ and his disciples fall on Sunday, to start his eight days a day farther back than the event, from which it is plainly manifest that the eight days are reckoned. He does this by his very ingenious insertion of the words, “From the old Sabbath.” But why date it from the old Sabbath? If we can pass back over the evening of the resurrection day, to find some point to begin the count, where shall we stop? The moment we pass that point, we are all at sea; we do not know what point or event to count from, and in that case the second appearance may have been only two days after the first appearance.

It is better to take the Bible narrative as it is. On the evening succeeding the resurrection, Jesus appeared to his disciples, while they, unbelieving and fearful, were hidden away in their own room for fear of the Jews. After eight days from that time, in order to confirm Thomas, who was absent at his first appearance, he appeared again. But upon what day the record does not tell, and if we could know, there would be no particular significance in it.

Neither of these appearances had anything to do with any proposed change of the Sabbath from the seventh to the first day of the week. There is no statement of such a change,—not even a hint of it in all the Scriptures. Indeed, the use of these texts to sustain the idea of a change in the Sabbath was never thought of until the sixteenth century, when English Puritanism, refusing to observe church holidays, and being hard pressed to furnish Scriptural evidence for the establishment of a new Sabbath, resorted to them much in the same way that a drowning man catches at a straw. The Bible Sabbath does not rest upon any such weak and inferential foundation.p. 123 It was made by certain distinct acts of God for that very purpose. He rested upon it; he blessed it; he sanctified it. Upon that basis the Sabbath rested in Eden; upon that basis it rests to-day. Truly, we may say of the Sabbath, as it is said of its divine Author, “Other foundation can no man lay than that which is laid.”

M. E. K.