In the Question Chair

13%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Feb 20, 1894

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 71, No. 8.

Read the full edition

In the Question Chair.

[Designed for the consideration of such questions as will be of interest and profit to the general reader. All correspondents should give their names and correct post-office address, that queries not replied to here, may be answered by mail.]

365.— ETERNAL FIRE. JUDE 7.

Please explain the last part of Jude 7: “Suffering the vengeance of eternal fire.” Does this imply the continuance of the suffering at the present time?
M. E. N.
Answer.—It certainly does not imply present suffering, but denotes a transaction closed up and finished. Literally rendered, the passage would read: “Even as Sodom and Gomorrah and the cities about them in like manner, having given themselves over to fornication, and having gone after strange flesh, and suffering therefor the vengeance of eternal fire, are set forth for an example.” Peter, writing about the same time, brings up the same cities as illustrations. He says (2 Peter 2:6): “And turning the cities of Sodom and Gomorrah into ashes condemned them with an overthrow, making them an ensample unto those that after should live ungodly.” Now anything to be an example to the ungodly, must be a complete representation of what will befall them if they continue to live ungodly. The cities of Sodom and Gomorrah are set forth as such an example to them. But if the fate of those cities was everlasting conscious torture in hell, they never could be an example, because their punishment could never end. To illustrate, suppose the penalty of ten years’ imprisonment was affixed for a certain crime, and some one who had committed that crime was “set forth for an example,” suffering that term of imprisonment. He could not be an example till his imprisonment was finished. He could be no example to others, of a ten years’ term of imprisonment for that crime, when he had been in prison only five weeks or any period short of the whole term. Just so with Sodom and Gomorrah; the punishment they suffered was not eternal misery. Peter declared plainly what their punishment was, when he said, “Turning the cities of Sodom and Gomorrah into ashes condemned them with an overthrow.” So all the ungodly, if they do not repent, will likewise be condemned with an overthrow and turned into ashes. But ashes do not suffer conscious misery.
Why, then, does Jude use the term “eternal” fire? Mark what he does say. He does not say, “Suffering eternally in the fire,” nor even, “Suffering eternal fire;” but, “Suffering the vengeance of eternal fire.” And what would the vengeance of that kind of fire naturally be? What would be its inevitable effect?—It would be to turn whatever it preyed upon into ashes, just as Peter says it did the cities of the plain. It is called eternal, because the effects of it are eternal. Those cities will never recover from that overthrow. While the individuals who then sinned with so high a hand, will, as individuals, have their account to render, and their punishment to suffer, in the second resurrection and the second death, those cities, as wicked plague-spots on the face of the earth, will never again appear.
The word “eternal” is here used as in Heb. 5:9 and 6:2, where we read of “eternal salvation” and “eternal judgment;” not a salvation and a judgment eternally going on and never completed, but events, the effects of which will be eternal. (See this and like passages fully explained in the work, “Here and Hereafter, or Man’s Nature and Destiny,” for sale at this Office, price $1, post-paid.)