Not Made On the Cross—In Process Now.
DURING the week of prayer, when the reading on the Atonement was presented in the Tabernacle, the reader took occasion to digress, and speak of some of the errors that have sprung up in the Christian world on account of a misunderstanding of the subject of the sanctuary and the atonement. Among these errors is the idea that the atonement was made upon the cross. Being requested to write out some of the thoughts for the REVIEW, we present the following on this point:—
In the reading occurs this statement: “Every man’s destiny will be decided when this work [of atonement] is finished; for they for whom atonement is made, and who thereby have their sins removed, will be saved; while those whose sins are not thus put away, will have them to answer for, and will perish with them at last in the lake of fire.”
That this statement is true, is self-evident; for if it is not true, the atonement amounts to nothing. But if it is true, it will be seen at once that it has an important bearing upon the prevailing belief that the atonement was made upon the cross; for that which Christ did upon the cross was for the whole multitude of mankind. John said, pointing the people to Christ, “Behold the Lamb of God, which taketh away [margin, “beareth”] the sin of the world;” and Peter adds, “Who his own self bare our sins in his own body on the tree.” John 1:29; 1 Peter 2:24. Now if this was the atonement, the first conclusion would be that the sins of all men have been atoned for, and that consequently all will be saved. This would be universal salvation in its broadest sense. This would also be atoning for sins before they were committed, which would be universal license; for if an atonement has already been made for all the sins a person may commit, he has perfect liberty to commit them, and it does not diminish in the least his prospect of salvation.
But Universalism cannot be true; for the Lord declares by the prophet that “the soul that sinneth, it shall die;” and Christ will say to a multitude at last, “Depart from me, ye cursed, into everlasting fire, prepared for the Devil and his angels.” Ezek. 18:20; Matt. 25:41.
So, to avoid this dilemma, another conclusion is resorted to, which is that Christ did not atone for all men on the cross, but only for a chosen few, whom God purposed to save. But this would be also to atone for sins before they were committed, it would be foreordination and predestination in its baldest and most repulsive form; and it would contradict the testimony of both John and Peter, as quoted above. Thus, in view of the fact that what Christ did upon the cross was for all the world, these two huge and hideous errors have sprung from supposing that he there made atonement for the sins of men.
But if that was not the atonement, then what was it that Christ did upon the cross for all the world? and what is the atonement? and when is it made? If the subject of the sanctuary had not been lost sight of in the Christian world, and the priesthood of Christ had not been buried up under a load of fog and mysticism, theology would never have fallen into the error and confusion which prevail upon this subject.
In the sanctuary service we have presented before us an object-lesson on the process of the forgiveness of sin. The repentant sinner brought his offering to the door of the sanctuary; he confessed over it his sin, and thus transferred the sin from himself to the victim; the victim thus bearing the sin was then slain, and his blood ministered by the priest in the sanctuary. At the end of the year, the priest with another offering, went into the most holy place, the second apartment of the sanctuary, and sprinkled the blood upon the mercy-seat, beneath which reposed the law of God, the transgression of which made men sinners, and thus atoned for the sins which had accumulated in the sanctuary during the year, and bore them from the place, to be sent away on the head of the scapegoat, and to perish with him in the wilderness. This day was therefore called “the day of atonement;” and with this service, and with this day, the yearly round of ministration came to an end.
Now, all the offerings and all the sacrifices of the ancient, typical sanctuary find their antitype in Christ and his work, as the sacrifice and High Priest for the world. He acts in the capacity both of offering and priest. He is the antitype of the expiring victim, as well as the antitype of the ministering priest, but not both at the same time. And it is not a little surprising that people, in contemplating the work of Christ, should overlook the distinction between these divisions of his service. When he stood as the antitypical victim, the great sacrifice for sin, he was not acting as priest. But it is the priest only who makes the atonement, not the victim. And what part of his work was it that Christ did upon the cross? He there gave his life as the great offering for sin, the sacrifice on which the sins of all the world were laid. But he was not then acting as priest. “If he were on earth,” says Paul, “he should not be a priest.” Heb. 8:4. That is, no part of his priestly work is performed on this earth. All of that is accomplished in heaven. On the cross he bore the sins of the world, as the offering for sin. In heaven, having provided the offering, he pleads his blood, as priest, for all those who will come to God through him for pardon. These two positions should not be confounded. On the cross Christ offered himself as the sacrifice; in heaven he pleads his blood as priest, and makes the atonement. Therefore, though he bore on the cross the sins of all the world, that is, made a sacrifice which would be of sufficient merit to cover and cancel all the sins of every person who has ever lived, or is to live, on this earth, it does not follow that all will be saved; for all will not come to him that they might have life. John 5:40. But for all who will come to him and seek and accept his pardon, he will grant it on the strength of his sacrifice, and make atonement for their sins when the time comes for his mediation for the world to close and probation to end. For it will be noticed that according to the type, the atonement was the last act of the yearly round of service; and so, in the antitype, the atonement will be the last work of Christ in behalf of his people.
Thus, by a true view of this subject, Universalism is avoided on the one hand, and foreordination and reprobation on the other. For while provision is made for all, only those who will seek for it, will receive the benefits of it. Thus the atonement will be made by Christ at last only for those who have sought pardon through his blood, and it comes after its subjects have lived and committed their sins, and repented of them that they might be saved.
The subject from any point of view is full of interest and instruction; but its great solemnity at the present time lies in the fact that the final work of atonement by our Lord Jesus Christ has been going forward since the end of the prophetic period (the 2300 days of Daniel 8) that marked its beginning, in 1844, for almost fifty years. In the type it occupied only an indefinite portion of one day in the year. In the antitype, though there is nothing by which to fix the exact proportion of time, it must be comparatively brief, and that auspicious day be near when sin will have all been put away, and Christ appear without sin (a sin-offering) unto salvation, King of kings, and Lord of lords, to take his people to himself.