THE BARBERS’ SUNDAY-CLOSING LAW

8%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Mar 6, 1894

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 71, No. 10.

Read the full edition

THE BARBERS’ SUNDAY-CLOSING LAW.

It will be remembered by the readers of the REVIEW that the last Michigan legislature passed a law entitled “the barbers’ Sunday-closing bill,” making it a crime for a barber to perform his usual occupation on Sunday. This was done at the request of the “Barbers’ Union,” which comprises the majority of the barbers of the State, who wanted Sunday for other purposes. There was nothing to hinder any barber from closing his shop if he wanted to do so, without the law; but each barber was afraid that other barbers would keep open, and so their cupidity led them to call for a law to compel themselves to do what they could do without the law, but which they had not moral stamina enough to do. At their desire, the bill was passed. It will now be in order for merchants, blacksmiths, and farmers to combine, to have special laws passed compelling them to keep Sunday. It may be objected that there is not such sharp competition between those engaged in other occupations, as there is in that of barbers, and that no one will hold such work to be a necessity. We are not so certain of that.
Imagine two rival farmers, living on adjoining farms, each with fifty acres of wheat, cut, shocked, and ready to go into the barn or stack. Sunday morning it looks like rain; there is danger that the fruit of the whole season’s labor will be lost. One farmer hastily gathers his help, puts several teams to work, and secures his crop. The other idles away his time smoking on the front porch, or, giving him the benefit of good intentions, goes to church and leaves the crop to Providence. At night the rain falls, and continues to fall for several days, until the wheat sprouts in the shocks, and the crop is ruined. Now has not the idle or conscientious farmer a strong case against the wicked (?) neighbor? His observance of Sunday has caused him to suffer a great loss, and he thinks, Why should my neighbor gain, when I am compelled to lose? How it would have soothed his feelings, and made his loss seem less severe, if his neighbor had only been compelled by law to let his wheat lie out in the rain and spoil. A “farmers’ closing bill” would be to him a remedy for all this inequality, so that no other farmer could get the start of him. Therefore such a law must be obtained. The power to equalize the farmer’s profits lies in the legislature, and hence to the legislature it must go!
Similar illustrations may be drawn from many other occupations, all showing the folly of such laws. But, right or wrong, the law must stand. Several Detroit barbers refused to obey the said law, and continued to shave their customers on Sunday, gathering in the barbers’ wheat, while the Barbers’ Union was losing theirs. So the busy barbers were arrested, tried, and convicted. A test case was carried to the supreme court of the State, which court has just handed down a decision, affirming the constitutionality and binding force of the law. Henceforth barbers must gather their shekels (their wheat) on the gathering days appointed by the State, and if a man cannot get to the barber Saturday night before midnight, he must feel a stubbly chin on Sunday, and try to devote his mind so completely to divine things that he will forget this inconvenience; and if any one unused to shaving should attempt to perform the time-honored custom of shaving himself on Sunday morning, and should sever his jugular in so doing, the members of the supreme court can console themselves by remembering that another very high court once declared that it was better that one man should suffer than that the whole nation should perish!
The court holds that experience teaches that one day’s rest in seven is necessary for the health of most individuals; that it is a sanitary measure; and that that is the best reason for the law. Experience has demonstrated nothing of the kind. Nations celebrated for their power of body and mind have had no weekly rest day. Greek and Roman history will ever stand in contravention of this decision. It is the unanimous testimony of all physicians, and confirmed by the common sense of every individual, that the nightly rest is far more important as a means of recuperation and the maintenance of health, than is any periodic day of rest, recurring at regular intervals. Shall, then, the police power of the State be invoked, and for sanitary purposes all persons be compelled to take a certain amount of sleep, at a certain time? How would the barber, who rejoices that he can now have his Sunday night for fun and folly, feel if he should be approached by a brass-buttoned custodian of the public health, and told that it was time for him to go to bed, that the law demanded it, and the court had sustained the law! A sanitary measure, indeed! Never was there a more flimsy attempt to conceal the real intent and animus of a measure, than is this fictitious plea of sanitation.
Sunday is a religious institution, an ecclesiastical dogma, whose pedigree sustains no relation to sanitation; but it may be traced through Colonial and English Church and State history to its very fountain head,— Church and State Rome. It is a religious barnacle, clinging to the ship of state, gathering other barnacles of a similar nature, and threatening to engulf the noble vessel in a sea of ecclesiastical despotism, where many a gallant ship of state has already gone down. It is as a religious institution that it is upheld by the State. Calling it a sanitary regulation is a very ingenious way to avoid the unpleasant fact that, in what is popularly supposed to be a purely secular government, religious institutions are fostered and supported by the State. But such sentiments will deceive no one who looks beyond the apparent to the real cause of such laws.
As a specimen of the loose way of reasoning indulged in by the press upon this decision, we will quote the following editorial note from the Detroit Tribune of Feb. 21:—
“The supreme court has sustained the barbers’ Sunday-closing law on the broad ground of the police power of the State to secure to its citizens one day of rest in seven as a physical necessity. Many individuals, as the court says, do not possess the power to observe a day of rest of their own volition, and the State has the right to intervene for the protection of such. In fact, the State has the same right to fix a day of rest as it has to fix hours of labor. The decision is a notable victory for working people of all classes.”
Here, again, the law is placed upon the broad platform of a “physical necessity.” Persons have not the power to rest, therefore the law has a right to intervene for their protection. But how many persons have not the moral power to rest nights, when their system demands rest far more than it does the weekly rest? Nightly rest is natural; weekly rest is purely artificial. Must the State interfere for their protection also? Must it strengthen the “volition” of the night loungers by police soporifics duly administered? If not, why not?
Another clause of the above is especially worthy of our attention: “In fact, the State has the same right to fix a day of rest as it has to fix hours of labor.” But does the State fix certain specified hours of labor, or only the amount of labor? Does it specify time or quantity? All must admit that it is a specific quantity and not a specific time that is pointed out. The State has declared that a certain amount of time shall constitute a day’s work, but the exact time during the twenty-four hours of the day when this work must be done, the State has not ventured to decide. There is, therefore, no analogy whatever between the law of the State fixing hours of labor, and the law appointing a day of rest. Should the State point out what definite portion of the day shall be used for labor, and what part for rest, making it a penal offense to labor on any other part of the day, then the law fixing hours of labor, and the law appointing a weekly rest day would be similar; otherwise there is no similarity whatever. To say that they are similar may be according to the decision of the supreme court, but it is supreme nonsense nevertheless.
As to whether this is a victory for the working classes or not is a question. It is about the same kind of a victory for labor that a law compelling saloons to close on Sunday, while they are open the other six days of the week, is a victory for temperance. That is more of a victory for Sunday than for temperance, and this is a greater victory for Sunday and to the church which it represents than it is for the workmen and freedom. A law making six days of ten hours each a week’s work, the same as ten hours constitutes a day’s work, and not fixing the day when the work must be done, giving to each man the right to select his day of rest, according to his religion, convenience, or kind of work engaged in, the same as he regulates his hours of work in the day, would conserve the liberty of the working classes. Specifying the days of work and rest in the week takes away his liberty just as much as specifying the hours to work or rest in a day would do. There can be no true freedom where there is ecclesiastical despotism, and the barbers’ Sunday-closing bill, passed by the legislature and confirmed by the supreme court of Michigan, is a relic of such despotism.
M. E. K.