LEGISLATIVE ASSUMPTION AND PATERNALISM

8%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Mar 20, 1894

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 71, No. 12.

Read the full edition

LEGISLATIVE ASSUMPTION AND PATERNALISM.

They Received a Rebuke by the Supreme Court of Minnesota.

The supreme court of this State has recently handed down two very important decisions; the first, a vindication of the rights of the individual in his person and property against unlawful seizures and disturbance; the second, a rebuke to the spirit of paternalism.
It will be remembered that last winter, through the legislature of the State, the people sought to find, if possible, some redress from the burdens of an alleged coal combine. A committee was appointed to investigate, that, in its frantic efforts to secure the evidences, supposed to be in the hands of one J. J. Rhodes, as secretary of the combine, entered the private office of said Rhodes, and forcibly seized books, papers, etc.
Mr. Rhodes appealed to the courts, and sued the committee for personal damages to the amount of $50,000. The legislature at once made an appropriation for a sufficient amount to secure them from all personal damages, and were egged on by a wave of populism and thirst for power, to forget that they, as lawmakers, were themselves amenable to law and must proceed lawfully.
It was claimed at the time that if such proceedings were to be tolerated, “then anarchy is king. The strong may devour the weak, and courts and law and constitutions are worse than a mockery, and the dangers of the people have but just begun.” It will also be remembered that, all of a sudden, when the public was on the tiptoe of expectation that some of its burdens might be lightened, the committee disappeared from public view, and so remain to this day. They simply made a dash, and—was the boodle of the combine too tempting? The people cannot make answer. They do know that no report was made, and that the price of coal remains stationary. And now the people are asked to pay Mr. Rhodes the sum of $3500, which is the amount of damages assessed by the courts.
But the decision is timely, and will no doubt serve as a check to the usurpation of power in the future, and will serve as a barrier, for a time at least, against legislative tyranny, and defend the rights of the individual to be secure against unlawful searches and seizures, even by a legislative committee. The Pioneer Press of Jan. 5, in speaking of this right, has well said: “If a legislature could violate it at pleasure; if without the intervention of courts or the observance of legal forms, it could send its committees and officers to any citizen’s place of business, and carry away his books despite his resistance, then the courts and the reign of law might as well be abolished altogether, and the American state be placed under the guidance of a revolutionary assembly and a committee of safety, with full power of life and death.” The movement against the combine was a good and a just one, but it has received a severe blow by the extra-legal methods of its friends.
Another act of the same legislature, under the influence of the same wave of populism, was to enact what is called the “State elevator law.” This provided that the State of Minnesota should build and operate certain grain elevators, beginning with a mammoth concern at Duluth, for which a certain sum was to be appropriated.
The supreme court of the State decided this law to be unconstitutional, in a case brought by H. Rippe to restrain the commissioners from building such elevators. Judge Mitchel rendered the opinion, and argued that such a law would lead to startling results; for if, in the exercise of the police power of the State, it may build and operate one elevator at one point, it may build and operate a score at the same point, and may also build and operate one or more at any and all points where grain is raised to be stored and handled. On the same grounds, if the railroads and hackmen, or brokers and saloon men, and so on ad libitum should fail to accommodate the public, or overcharge, then the State, under this law, in the exercise of its police powers, might engage in any and all kinds of business, till everything would center in the State. The legislature would also have unlimited power to embark, at the expense and in behalf of the State, in any business or enterprise it sees fit, which is not actually prohibited by the Constitution. The police powers of the State are to regulate, not to engage in transaction of business. The judge virtually said that the people could have State socialism, if they desired; for the people are supreme. But they could not have it except by a change of the Constitution. The Constitution forbids it.
The decision is an impressive one, and the papers say that it “will arouse the people to a sense of their duty and their danger. It is not merely the elevator project, but a whole brood of political heresies which this decision strangles relentlessly.”
It certainly is a statesmanlike decision, full of sound American principles. But will it “rouse the people to a sense of their duty,” or of “their danger”? Wholly absorbed in their greed for gain and lust for pleasure, will they pass on till all their rights will “expire in a convulsion”? And as to the strangling of these “political heresies,” they are not so easily destroyed. The air is full of them. Their name is legion, while they multiply by spawning; so that, even though they are rebuked by sound American principles, there is little hope for the future. Were it not so, we would hope that the supreme court of Minnesota would always be actuated by American ideas whenever a case should rise affecting the rights of the people.
H. F. Phelps.