No one doubts that Dr. Talmage possesses wonderful resources in the field of imagination; but he evidently overshoots the mark, when he departs from scenes terrestrial, and endeavors to exercise that faculty in reference to the realms above. He would no doubt be glad to have a real vision, and be caught up to the third heaven, as Paul was; but not being able to do that, he sits down and deliberately evolves one out of his own imagination. This is published in the Baltimore Morning Herald of Feb. 5, under the flaming headlines, “With an Angel Guide.—Doctor Talmage Sees the Heavenly Realm.”
He simulates the required conditions; that is, whether awake or asleep, dreaming or seeing, in the body or out, he could not tell; but he suddenly finds himself in one of the chief avenues of the holy city, and an angel of God, beholding his bewilderment, comes to him to act as his guide.
The first bad break the doctor makes is in his introductory interview with that angel. He says: “I said to the angel, ‘How long hast thou been in heaven?’ and the answer came, ‘Thirty-two years, according to the earthly calendar.’” Now, we venture the assertion that there is not an angel in heaven who has not been there much longer than thirty-two years! But the mystery is explained, when this angel turns out to be his mother, who departed this life that number of years ago! But, according to the Bible, angels are not made out of the spirits of dead people. The dead are sleeping unconsciously in the grave, awaiting the resurrection.
With this anti-Scriptural and Spiritualistic idea, all the rest of his supposed vision is largely tinged. He claims to have met writers whose religious hymns have been and are still very popular in the religious world, such as Watts, Wesley, White, Cowper, Bethune, Toplady, Bonar, etc. But what must strike the reader as a little peculiar, is the earnestness with which these persons inquired if their songs were still being sung on earth, as they used to be! Now, if these worthies, instead of calmly slumbering in the grave, as they are, were actually in the heavenly world, as the doctor claims to have seen them, we do not imagine they would have been quite so solicitous as to their worldly popularity as he represented. But it is hard for error to be consistent, and so the doctor, in this very vision, in another place, represents these angelic spirits as being able to come down and hover over their friends on earth, and know all that is going on. In this case, Watts, Wesley, et al., could look after their earthly reputation themselves, and not be obliged to inquire of every stranger that came from this earth to that place.
Another singular thing is the premium he puts on bad and vicious parentage. He says: “I found the highest thrones, the brightest garlands, the richest mansions, were occupied by those who had a reprobate father or bad mother.” The children of good parents and the ten-talented Christians, generally, were living in some humble tenement on a back street, while many of the one-talented, “had residences fronting on the King’s park,” with “back lawns sloping to the river,” the “highest heavenly nobility as guests,” and “the white horse of him who hath ‘the moon under his feet’ [whoever that may be] champing its bits at the doorway.”
So much of a worldly complexion, and so many glaring errors, mingled with many true views of what the glory of the heavenly world will be, and the privileges the redeemed will enjoy, crowned with eternal health and youth, with power to visit other worlds, and chant in matchless symphonies the praises of the Maker of them all,—these vitiate the whole. Before one ventures into such a field, in such a way, he would do well to be sure to have his ideas first brought into harmony with the teachings of the word of God.