AdventAI

CHRISTIAN SCIENCE.

From Review and Herald, Vol. 71, No. 14., April 3, 1894

We can almost thank the Inter Ocean for its inane comments upon the Sunday-school lessons, since its “expositions,” from the standpoint of Mrs. Eddy’s theology, have caused us to look into some of her books. We have not had so much fun in many a day. It is better than a circus to a small boy. In fact, Mrs. Eddy’s “science” is a whole Midway of barbaric conceits, which are no more related to each other than the Circassian and the Polynesian. The most orthodox expressions are jumbled in with all the paganisms that were ever dreamed, and the cloud of Polonius that was “humped like a camel,” “backed like a weasel,” and “very like a whale,” was a marble statue beside it. One is reminded of the showman’s exhibition of the fiction, Daniel in the Lion’s Den, who, on being appealed to to determine which was Daniel and which the lion, replied, “Which is Daniel and which is the lion? Now, gentlemen, it makes no matter to me; you just pays your money, and you takes your choice.” If you believe in the personality of God, you will find it on one page; if you believe in a pantheistic universe, you will find it on the next; and if you don’t know what you believe, you will find plus and minus, affirmation and denial, follow each other so steadily through the whole book that you can come out at the end of it as creedless as you began.

The funniest part of the whole is where Mrs. Eddy becomes profound. For a good scholar the English Bible is usually sufficient, but an ignoramus is always appealing to “the original.” And for Mrs. Eddy the name of our first ancestor, Adam, has as marked a fascination as his “tomb” had for Mark Twain. She wrestles with it in each new edition, until it would seem as if she had made it the subject of all the blunders of which it is possible to make it. In her edition of 1885, she says, “Adam is from the Latin dæmens.” A most astonishing bit of philological information, since the Hebrew was a dead language before the Latin was born. Then in 1886 she asserts that “Adam is identical with the Latin dæmon.” Still more wonderful, since “dæmon” is not Latin at all. And finally, as if to complete the tale of all conceivable absurdities, she asserts in one book that “its meaning is a damn,” and in another place that it “ought to be interpreted as a dam.” Here you can take your choice between the Latin or the Teutonic, after you have compensated Mrs. Eddy for her erudition.

We could fill the whole page with similar blunders which would disgrace a school-boy’s composition; and yet this is the high-priestess of a cult that one of our “great” dailies parades before its tens of thousands of readers!—Interior, March 1.