DISHONESTY OR IGNORANCE: WHICH?

13%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Apr 3, 1894

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 71, No. 14.

Read the full edition

DISHONESTY OR IGNORANCE: WHICH?

If some of our clerical brethren of other denominations would so order their speech as not to force us to apply to them the term of “liar,” it would be very gratifying to us; for that term seems harsh and severe, and we dislike to use it. More pleasant would it be to look upon all, especially those in the ministry, as Christian gentlemen, and so speak of them. But when they come before the public with bold and barefaced untruths, what are we to call it?
We find an example of the wrong course here alluded to, in the Michigan Christian Advocate of March 10. In that issue one “Rev. L. Wigle” has an article of over a column and a quarter in length, entitled, “Seventh-day Adventism,” telling what a terrible people Seventh-day Adventists are, what evil they are doing, and what a dismal failure they have been from the beginning, generally. He affirms that they are in a state of confusion, apostasy, and disintegration; and to prove this he introduces the following testimony. He says:—
“One of their prominent men, Elder U. Smith, is compelled to make this sad confession: ‘The history of that once happy, united people has been marked by discord, division, confusion, new mistakes, disintegration, and apostasy.’ Sad confession, indeed, to be made by one of their own leaders!”
Now what are the facts in the case? That quotation is taken from the work called, “The Sanctuary and the 2300 days of Dan. 8:14.” On page 14 we speak of the Adventists at the passing of the time in 1844, concerning which we say: “They passed the point of their expectation and realized not their hope. That a mistake had been made somewhere none could deny. From that point the history of the majority of that once happy, united people has been marked by discord, division, confusion, speculation, new mistakes, fresh disappointments, disintegration, and apostasy.”
Of whom was this written?—Of Adventists in 1844, before there was a so-called Seventh-day Adventist in the world! Of how many of them was it spoken?—Of the majority only. But that word “majority,” Mr. Wigle carefully leaves out, and then claims that we spoke those words in reference to Seventh-day Adventists, when they applied to another people entirely. It is the First-day Adventists, not Seventh-day Adventists, of whom it was written, and of whom it was true. At first they were a majority; but the minority, who avoided the confusion which befell the others, by a further study of the prophecies, are the ones who have developed into the body known as Seventh-day Adventists, and who are now in the majority, as compared with any other class of Adventists, and who have been from the beginning a complete unit on all the fundamental principles of their position.
Is this a specimen of the extent of Mr. Wigle’s power of discrimination? If so, he is hardly competent to appear on any subject in the public prints. If it is not, and he intentionally perverted the language, as would seem evident from his deliberate change of the phraseology, then he comes under the charge first suggested in this article. It would be charitable, perhaps, to let him pass as one a little below par, intellectually, rather than as a knave. But we would take occasion kindly to suggest to our religious contemporaries that it is not safe for them to admit into their columns communications from correspondents who are wrought up to such a pitch of frenzy as Mr. Wigle evidently was when he wrote; for they will be almost invariably imposed upon by misrepresentation and falsehood.
The book from which Mr. Wigle took his quotation was published in 1877, seventeen years ago; and if such was the state of Seventh-day Adventism then, as he would have it appear, then it certainly ought by this time to have completely run out, instead of being in a state to call forth this frantic cry of danger from Mr. Wigle.