DR. HARPER AND THE REPORTERS

17%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Mar 27, 1894

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 71, No. 13.

Read the full edition

DR. HARPER AND THE REPORTERS.

THE president of the University of Chicago is having more or less trouble with the young gentlemen who report his lectures on the subject of the creation. He said at the beginning of his discourse on Saturday evening, that any report of his remarks must necessarily be unfair and non-representative of the thought; and that there were not three men in Chicago who could make a correct report of what he said. He did not believe he could do so himself.
All this being true, it will have to be admitted that Dr. Harper is an exception to public speakers in general. The Herald does not experience much difficulty in reporting a man who has something to say about a subject that he understands, and who is supposed to mean all that he says. Given a lucid and candid speaker, the Herald will agree to provide ten times three reporters who can give an accurate reproduction of a discourse. If Dr. Harper cannot be accurately reported, it may be because there is something wrong about his utterances.
In a private circular which has been distributed throughout the country, Dr. Harper says: “Criticism based upon newspaper reports is unfair and unjust,” because such reports “are made by men without any adequate knowledge of the subject they are treating.” This condemnation is rather too sweeping to be just. It is possible that the reporters of Chicago are not so apt in hair-splitting as is the president of the university; but, trained in a practical school, they are likely to detect a Bible skeptic as soon as anybody does.
If some of Dr. Harper’s recent lectures mean anything at all, they seem to mean that he is very dubious about the Biblical account of the creation, and they have been so accepted by clergymen and laymen alike. He may have some refinements of skepticism which other people are not able to comprehend, but the reporters who “boiled him down” and interpreted his hinted unbelief appear to the Herald to have preserved about all that his lectures contained that was worthy of remark.
Theologians who do not like to be criticised for preaching skepticism should not preach skepticism.—Chicago Herald.