AdventAI

DANGER IN ADOPTING EXTREME VIEWS.

By W. H. Littlejohn

From Review and Herald, Vol. 71, No. 15., April 10, 1894

BY ELDER W. H. LITTLEJOHN.

(Battle Creek, Mich.)

(Concluded.)

Once more: The writer can remember when Seventh-day Adventists, as a rule, would not vote at elections, for fear of receiving the mark of the beast. What a change has come over the spirit of their dreams in this matter! Not only are they ready to vote in this our day, but the zeal of perhaps the majority in this thing is at least equal to that of many of their fellow-citizens. It is not the change with which we find fault,—that change is a symptom of progress, and that progress marks the surrender of extreme opinions and the adoption of better ones. The writer will not pause to speak of the epoch when church steeples, church bells, church organs, etc., etc., were looked upon as of questionable propriety by many. That epoch is past, and every right-minded man is thankful for it. The object in alluding to it at all is to show that even Seventh-day Adventists have not been exempt from a weakness common to mankind. Were it replied that the extravagances in question were confined to men of mean abilities and doubtful piety, I answer that such is not the case. On the contrary, to the personal knowledge of the writer, one of the greatest and best men in our ranks was one who in early life went farther than most others in the direction of these extreme opinions and practices. Of this man it was once shown that he was a “chosen vessel of the Lord.” The person in question was not Elder James White. That gentleman was perhaps as free from fanaticism in all of its shades as any man among us. The individual alluded to has been gathered to his fathers. Peace be to his ashes. The writer loved him as he has loved but few men. He is glad to know also that the person in question lived to triumph over all the mistakes and weaknesses of his early life. His case is mentioned here for the purpose of pointing a moral.

It is frequently said that there is no danger in following the lead of such and such men, for they are led of the Lord. Now if this were strictly true in the abstract, then, indeed, there would be no danger in implicitly following the guidance of such persons. The error lies in the assumption that because a man is good, generally speaking, therefore his conclusions are always sound and safe. Saying nothing about the possibility that the man who was good yesterday may not be so to-day, it is beyond dispute true that the Lord has never vouchsafed to any one man the privilege of becoming a standard in matters of doctrine and duty for all men at all times. Find among us a man so honored, and you will have, if not an infallible pope, something but little better, an infallible Seventh-day Adventist.

The individual of whom the writer spoke above, it will be remembered, was pronounced by the Spirit of prophecy a “chosen vessel of the Lord.” This was indeed a high commendation, but to the positive knowledge of the writer, the one of whom these words were uttered was subsequently allowed to fall into very grievous errors,—errors not of the heart but of the head. Those who followed him then were involved in his mistakes. If there are any of our brethren to-day who are inclined to “make flesh their arm,” let them beware lest they share a similar fate. The Lord Jesus Christ is the only infallible guide. Every important opinion advanced by another should be challenged and examined before it is adopted. If it will bear the test of the Scriptures and of sanctified common sense, receive it; if not, reject it, no matter from whom it emanates.

What is said in this connection does not apply to one who speaks by direct divine inspiration. When one speaks in this manner, he speaks as the oracle of God, and what he says when thus speaking, should be regarded as final. But to say that a man is a good man, and that he is in a general way led of the Lord, is one thing; to say that he speaks and acts by divine inspiration, is another thing. That Luther was led by the Lord in a most marked manner in the management of the Reformation, will not be contradicted; but that he was infallible is emphatically denied. He erred grievously in many things. If not, why are we not all Lutherans in doctrine, instead of Seventh-day Adventists? Take, for example, the question of the eucharist. Luther believed in the doctrine of transubstantiation, or the doctrine that the body and blood of Christ are in the emblems really, as the heat is in the red-hot iron. We deny that the body and blood of Christ are in the emblems in any sense of that term. Zwingle held the correct view on this subject, and overwhelmed Luther in debate; but the latter not only refused to listen to argument, but turned his back upon Zwingle in a rage, when the latter, after the debate, advanced to greet him with a friendly shake of the hand. Luther, with all of his good qualities and led by the Lord as he was, furnishes a very poor example of the infallibility of men who are thus led only in a general sense. Even the apostles of our Lord were not free from mistakes, if indeed they were at all times entirely free from sin. If any one in their day had acted upon the principle that their utterances were to be taken under all circumstances as absolutely correct, he would have been led astray. Illustrations of this fact have already been given in the cases of James and John; but as it may be objected that the instances cited occurred before the day of Pentecost and therefore before the gift of the Holy Ghost in its fulness, examples will be produced this side of that event. Barnabas and Paul are about to start out on an extensive missionary tour. A disagreement arises between them respecting the utility of taking Mark with them. Here is the history of the transaction: “And some days after, Paul said unto Barnabas, Let us go again and visit our brethren in every city where we have preached the word of the Lord, and see how they do. And Barnabas determined to take with them John, whose surname was Mark. But Paul thought not good to take him with them, who departed from them from Pamphylia, and went not with them to the work. And the contention was so sharp between them, that they departed asunder one from the other: and so Barnabas took Mark, and sailed unto Cyprus; and Paul chose Silas, and departed, being recommended by the brethren unto the grace of God.” Acts 15:36–40. It is insisted by some that the words, “the contention was so sharp between them,” do not necessitate the conclusion that the parties to the controversy were angry with each other. Grant this, and then what? The fact still remains that they contended with each other respecting the course to be pursued in the matter of taking John Mark with them. But contention certainly implies a decided difference of opinion in the premises, and such a difference of opinion proves beyond dispute that both were not right in the positions taken. But if both were not right, then one was right and the other wrong.p. 228 If one was right and the other wrong, then, as both were apostles, it follows that this side of Pentecost, the private judgment even of apostles could not be relied upon under all circumstances, and that those who acted contrary to this principle were liable to be led astray.

Take another case: “But when Peter was come to Antioch, I withstood him to the face, because he was to be blamed. For before that certain came from James, he did eat with the Gentiles: but when they were come, he withdrew and separated himself, fearing them which were of the circumcision. And the other Jews dissembled likewise with him; insomuch that Barnabas also was carried away with their dissimulation.” Gal. 2: 11–13.

If we are to understand that the word “dissemble,” as used in this passage was employed in a bad sense; that is, in the sense of intentional deception, then Peter was guilty of both sin and lack of judgment. Sin, because he deceived intentionally; lack of judgment, because he who sins “misses his mark,” or greatly errs.

But again: In this controversy three apostles were involved. Barnabas and Peter were on one side, and Paul on the other side of the controversy. There was a right side and a wrong side to the question. Therefore if Paul was right, the others were wrong. If they were right, Paul was wrong. It was one against two, and two against one. The event proved that Paul was right. As a result we have two prominent apostles, who, to say the least, erred egregiously in the decision of a very simple question.

In view of this fact, what becomes of apostolic infallibility in deciding matters of doctrine and duty, when not under special divine guidance? But if the apostles of our Lord could not be trusted implicitly in determining points where their minds were not particularly illuminated for that purpose, would it not be the height of folly to surrender ourselves to a blind following of any man or set of men to whom it is not even claimed that the special apostolic anointing was ever vouchsafed? Whenever you can find an instance in which the apostles and elders of the early church sought for light from Heaven in the matter of duty, you have an honest and frank confession on their part that they did not dare to trust their own private judgment in such matters, lest they should make a mistake. The simple fact is, that they were very much like other men naturally; and that, when not led directly by the Holy Spirit, their individual opinions were of no greater weight than those of other men of equal ability and experience with themselves.

Scores of illustrations to this effect might be cited if it were necessary. Enough has been said already, however, to make it evident that he who pins his faith to the sleeve of a mortal man has no warrant in the word of God for so doing. He will be left, therefore, without excuse if he shall persist in such a course until he learns, as he is sure to sooner or later by a bitter experience, the full significance of the words, “Cursed be the man that trusteth in man, and maketh flesh his arm.” Jer. 17: 5.