AdventAI

BEGGING THE QUESTION.

From Review and Herald, Vol. 71, No. 15., April 10, 1894

In the Gospel Messenger of Feb. 6 (the organ of the Trine Immersionists), an inquirer is represented as asking this question: “‘Why is not the commission given in Matt. 28:19 so worded as to teach trine immersion plainly, if that was the mode of baptism that the Saviour intended to enjoin upon his followers?’ The question,” says the Messenger, “is a fair one, and deserves a candid answer.”

After such an introduction we looked for a frank and candid consideration of the point involved in the question. What was our surprise and disappointment, therefore, in finding that the only answer attempted was this: “This commission, or baptismal formula, teaches trine immersion so clearly that no other form of immersion was used in any of the congregations established by the apostles for more than five hundred years after the death of Christ.”

This is the gist of the answer, of course amplified somewhat in the remainder of the article. But what has this to do with the question? The question pertained to the wording of the formula, not to the faith or practice of the church, however far back such practice may be traced. But nothing is said in the answer about the wording of that instruction. Assertions are very cheap truck. We have heard it so often glibly asserted that “Sunday was kept from the very days of the apostles down,” that we are prepared to rate assumptions at their true value. There is no secular history that runs back to the days of the apostles; hence it is useless to try to prove from history what the congregations established by the apostles believed and practiced. Of the apostles and their work, and the first churches established, we have the record in the New Testament. Between that record and secular history there is a missing link, an unbridged chasm; and when some custom comes to light away back in earliest history, on the later side of this chasm, if it corresponds with what appears in the Scriptural record on the other side of that historical break, we may conclude that such custom was continuous from the apostles down. But if, on the other hand, on the later side of this blank, it appears in a form which does not correspond with anything found on the other, or Scriptural side, or if it appears as something new, not previously mentioned, we cannot say that it was introduced in the days of the apostles and continued from their time; for the apostle assures us that even in his day the “mystery of iniquity” was working, and that immediately after his day men would arise speaking perverse things to draw away disciples after them. So corruptions and divergences from the truth began with men of perverse minds in days that even touched the lives of the apostles themselves.

The first question then, is, What do we find concerning any custom or church ordinance in the New Testament record itself? We find nothing in that record to prove or even suggest three plunges face foremost into the water for baptism. We do find, however, that there is one baptism, not three. We find baptism an act representing Christ’s burial and resurrection; but who could ever conceive that the body, in Jewish burial, was laid in the tomb upon its face, and especially that it was taken up and laid down three times in that way? And who can think of the people coming up in the resurrection backward? The one use of the participle “baptizing,” shows one act, not three. Why the three names are used is evident, because in the experience culminating in the act of baptism three agencies,—the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit have been concerned. We repent toward God, we have faith in Christ, and we look to the Holy Spirit for sanctification.

The answer, then, to the question of the correspondent introduced above, we think should be, that the commission would have been worded so as to teach trine immersion, if it had been designed to teach it.