[Designed for the consideration of such questions as will be of interest and profit to the general reader. All correspondents should give their names and correct post-office address, that queries not replied to here, may be answered by mail.]
371.—LUKE 3: 4, 5.
What is meant by the expressions in Luke 3: 4, 5 about the valleys being filled, mountains and hills brought low, the crooked being made straight, and the rough places made smooth, etc.? J. W. M.
Answer.—The passage refers, primarily, to John the Baptist, and the figures of speech introduced, such as mountains, valleys, etc., refer to the errors and wrong practices of the people, which would be corrected by the reforms which John and those who would come after him in the new dispensation, would bring about. Errors would be corrected, superstitions would be dispelled, abuses be abolished, and wrong practices of the people be reformed. John commenced the work and the gospel as introduced by Christ, and the apostles and their successors have been carrying it forward ever since. It will result at last in the great salvation which all flesh shall see, and in which many happily will share.
372.—JOB 14: 22.
Please explain through the REVIEW, Job 14: 22: “But his flesh upon him shall have pain, and his soul within him shall mourn,” and oblige a constant reader. J. F. G.
Ans.—The difficulty involved in this text, is, as to the time when it applies. The whole chapter is largely devoted to a discussion of the change that befalls man in death, and the preceding verse certainly applies to man’s condition in death: “His sons come to honor, and he knoweth it not; and they are brought low, and he perceiveth it not of them.” But does the next verse, the one referred to in the query, apply to the same time? It would seem evidentp. 235 that it does not; for if there is anything that survives death, it is what is popularly supposed to be the invisible, immaterial part known as the soul,—a part which is not in possession of flesh. A man in death does not have “flesh upon him” and a “soul within him.” This, then, cannot refer to his condition in that state; or what is termed the disembodied condition. It must refer to some time before the flesh is wasted away, or entirely consumed. Dr. Clarke gives the literal Hebrew and a Mr. Stock’s translation, both as to the spirit and the letter, thus: “But over him his flesh shall grieve, and over him his breath shall mourn,” upon which he comments thus: “In the daring spirit of oriental poetry, the flesh, or body, and the breath, are made conscious beings, the former lamenting its putrefaction in the grave, and the latter mourning over the moldering clay which it once enlightened.” Dr. Clarke considers this the most natural version offered. But it will be noticed that it speaks only of the body and breath, and represents both under the strong figure of personification, lamenting the consuming process that takes place in the grave, before the man is entirely wasted away. This is in harmony with the previous portions of the chapter describing the change which constitutes the complete and utter disintegration of the man. There is, therefore, no evidence here of a conscious spirit which survives the death of the body, and lives on in an uninterrupted existence.
373.—THE OLD AND NEW.
Will you please give your views of the spiritual application and significance of the parable in Luke 5: 37–39, particularly the last verse? “No man also having drunk old wine straightway desireth new; for he saith, The old is better.” J. A. H.
Ans.—That which called out the parables of the old cloth and the new, the old bottles and the new, and the old wine and the new (verses 36–39), was the questions that had been raised concerning the course of the disciples of the Pharisees and those of John, as compared with that of the disciples of Christ. Verse 33. John’s disciples fasted often, and engaged much in prayers, and the disciples of the Pharisees likewise; but the disciples of Christ ate and drank; and they wished to know what this difference meant. Christ explains that he had come to introduce a new system,—a system which had in it the active, aggressive, expansive forces of new wine, and it could not be shut up in old bottles, that is, the prescribed rites and customs, and methods of worship, pertaining to the former dispensation, which had grown rigid by age and worn thin by use. But this new system must have an altogether new environment, adapted to its nature, like the new bottles for the new wine. The question would then arise: Why, then, do not the disciples of the Pharisees and of John, especially the latter, fall in with the new order of things, and not fast and pray as aforetime, while the disciples of Christ eat and drink? O, he answers, this need not seem strange, for any one accustomed to old wine does not at once desire the new, for he naturally considers the old preferable. Just so with old systems and ceremonies to which men have long been accustomed. They do not readily change them for that which is new. These questions about the course of my disciples are therefore natural, and should be treated with patience. But the new was not on this account to be rejected. There never could be any “old” if there was not sometimes a “new.” As the matter then stood with relation to himself and his work, the existing prejudices in favor of the old would in due time wear away, and the new itself would eventually become old, and come to be preferred. The lesson to be learned is, that we should not cling unreasonably to what is becoming antiquated and worn out. And, on the other hand, we should not become so hasty in our work of reform as not to have patience with the timidity and hesitancy of our weaker brethren.