In a general way religious liberty may be defined to be the right of every individual to enjoy perfect freedom in the matter of his religious opinions and practices. However, in the exercise of such rights, there must of necessity be some limitations. No man would be justified, for example, in insisting that it was his privilege to sacrifice human beings on the ground that according to his faith, such a sacrifice would be agreeable to the deity. The rule, therefore, seems to be that no man has a right, or should have the power, to violate in the name of religious conscience those great fundamental principles of morality which mankind intuitively understand to be so manifestly correct that they need no demonstration. Another limitation on perfect freedom of conscience, or rather of action, is found in the natural rights of those about us. We cannot be justified in insisting that we have the privilege of setting at naught the liberties of others, in order that our own may not in any way be interfered with. To illustrate: No one should be allowed for a trifling cause willfully and unnecessarily greatly to disturb others properly engaged in the act of worship in a suitable place.
Fortunately, when religious liberty is properly understood, it is possible even in thickly-settled communities, so to regulate the worship of discordant religionists that none of them will be compelled to relinquish any vital and reasonable point of faith or practice for the benefit of others. Such, however, is the selfishness and unreasonableness of men, that religious liberty can only be enjoyed when, by the power of the law, the rights of all are correctly defined and guarded. The province of the State, would seem to be that of securing to every individual and class of individuals an uninterrupted enjoyment of their rights of conscience as against every other individual and class. The State has no right to discriminate between religions. When it does so, it moves outside of its proper sphere, and religious liberty is gone. We see, therefore, that in order to the enjoyment of that great boon, governments must be constructed in such a manner that their whole power will be thrown on the side of perfect freedom of conscience and worship.
Unfortunately the record of the past has demonstrated that it is an easier task by far to start a government upon correct principles in this matter than it is to keep it running in that line. Thus far history does not furnish a single instance in which any nation has preserved religious liberty throughout its whole career, provided that nation has stood for any great length of time.
Our own government has approximated as nearly perhaps to perfect separation of Church and State as any one of which we have knowledge. So far as the general government is concerned, the model upon which it is constructed with reference to matters of religion is, for the most part, admirable. The provision of the Constitution which declares that “Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof,” would seem to go as far as words can go in the direction of guarding against religious intolerance on the part of the general government. It would appear that under the ægis of such a limitation of congressional power every citizen of this favored nation, through the aid of the courts, might be protected from religious persecution as far as national laws are concerned. This, of course, would not be true, however, unless the judicial branch of the government should do its full duty in asserting the authority of the Constitution.
When we have said this much, perhaps we have gone as far as we can, in the direction of proving that the guaranties of our Constitution are ample in the matter of protecting the religious rights of the citizen. Our system of government is composite in its nature. In addition to the general government, we have State governments to the number of forty-four. These State governments have a political autonomy of their own. Like the general government they have executive, judicial, and legislative departments. Each State has the power to legislate for its own inhabitants upon all questions, jurisdiction over which has not been bestowed upon the general government or surrendered by common consent.
Right here the thoughtful student of history discovers an alarming peril. He sees at a glance that the constitutional provision, which limits the power of Congress to curtail the religious liberties of the citizen, is negative in character. That is, it simply prevents Congress from establishing a State church or discriminating against any form of religion. In doing this it confers no power upon the national legislature to prevent a State from passing oppressive religious laws. Nor can the citizen of a State, the laws of which are of the nature in question, find any relief in the United States courts, provided such laws are regularly enacted in harmony with the constitution of the State promulgating them. This is so, because, as heretofore stated, the authority of State legislatures is not derived from the United States Constitution, but from the power delegated by its own citizens.
True it is that there are certain limitations in the United States Constitution upon the jurisdiction of the State legislatures, which cannot be set aside; but apart from those limitations, the inhabitants of a State may, by constitutional provision, clothe the legislatures thereof with such authority as they may deem wise. One of the general limitations of the United States Constitution is to the effect that the general government shall secure to the various States a republican form of government. Unfortunately that provision does not, as some suppose, furnish a guaranty of religious liberty to the citizens of the different States.
A republican form of government is simply a form of government where the people practically rule themselves instead of being ruled over by those whom they have not chosen for that purpose. But religious persecution by law may take place in a republic as well as under any other form of government. From this it will be seen that the provision of the United States Constitution guaranteeing a republican form of government to the States, does not by any means insure to their citizens exemption from intolerant State laws. That this is the case, the history of the past will abundantly prove. Slavery was morally and socially wrong, and yet Congress could not interfere for its abolition where it was supported by State law.
Again: religious intolerance has manifested itself in various States since the Constitution was adopted, but in not a single instance has the general government undertaken to interfere in the matter where that intolerance was based upon State laws which did not infringe upon the United States Constitution. Let the reader bear in mind here that we are not talking about Territories, but about fully-organized States.
Returning now to the proposition previously laid down, we repeat the assertion that our present form of government, though admirable in many respects, is lacking in one very important particular. The Constitution of the nation should not have stopped with the negative provision which barely prohibits Congress from restricting the religious liberty of an individual. The framers of that instrument should have gone farther, by clothing Congress with power to protect the citizens in the various States from religious persecution under the form of State laws.
The lack in question is so obvious that no intelligent person can fail to acknowledge its existence. At the same time that lack is to be attributed to unpropitious circumstances rather than to want243of perception or integrity on the part of the patriots who drafted the fundamental law of the nation. Men are not to be blamed for not attempting the impossible. With States jealous of each other and afraid of delegating too much power to the general government, it was only with the greatest difficulty that those States could be induced to confer upon the general government such powers as they did.
No matter how much we may regret the inability of our general government to accomplish more for religious liberty in this nation, the facts are as they are, and we must submit to the present order of things until a change can be wrought, which will secure to us what we desire, through an amendment to the Constitution. That such an amendment could not be obtained at the present, will hardly be disputed. While this is true, no time should be lost by the friends of equal protection to all in matters of conscience, in educating public sentiment up to the point at which they aim. Two things would be gained by such a course: 1. It would change their merely negative position into a positive one, a thing greatly to be desired, since it would place their antagonists on the defensive; 2. It would give a rallying cry to the hosts of fair-minded men in this country by which they could be gathered under one banner, and hurled against the enemies of religious freedom with an impetuosity that would make them resistless. In the thought that one is championing a great principle which is not only destined to secure his own rights, but also those of the whole nation, there is an inspiration which fires his heart and nerves his arm for the conflict as nothing else will.
That religious liberty could be maintained throughout the length and breadth of our country while the separate States have jurisdiction over that question, is a matter of serious doubt. Circumstances often favor the domination of one church or set of churches in a given State. Under this condition of things, that church or set of churches, naturally gravitates in the direction of the enforcement by law of their own peculiar dogmas.
We, therefore, under this, the best government upon the earth, stand only one chance out of forty-four of enjoying, in all the States of this Union, perfect freedom of conscience. In view of this fact we can form some conception of the magnitude of the defects in our fundamental law. That conception will be rendered more vivid when we recollect that Seventh-day Adventists have actually been imprisoned of late in several States of the Union, and when we recall the fact that from the incipiency of this nation to this time, there has never been a single hour in which the laws of the various States have secured to all classes unrestricted right of conscience, worship, and opinion. Do you reply that Seventh-day Adventists or other Sabbatarians have no religious rights which ought to be guarded by the government? If so, let me inquire why they should be made an exception to the general rule? Are they not men? Have they not consciences as well as you? Permit me to tell you something which perhaps you never knew before. They sacrifice more each year in the line of finances and position, for what they believe to be true, than all the orthodox churches of this country combined. Again, if the only test of a good conscience is to be found in the word of God, then the claims of Sabbatarians in that direction are certainly as good as those of any other class, since they observe the only Sabbath that God ever commanded any man to hallow. Ex. 20:8–11.
Some one has said that the difference between orthodoxy and heterodoxy is this: Orthodoxy is my “doxy,” and heterodoxy is your “doxy.” When you stigmatize the faith of Sabbatarians, or any other faith, as heterodox, you assume to be judge over the church of the Most High. Beware how you exercise that prerogative unless you have a special permit from the Almighty to transact that kind of business.
But suppose that I were to grant that you are justified in deciding that Sabbatarians and others are unsound in their religious belief, would that clothe you with authority to suppress them by law? To say that such was the case would be to deny every principle of religious liberty. To persecute a man because we think that he is wrong in his religious opinions is, per se, the very quintessence of despotism. The infidel, the Jew, the atheist, the agnostic, as well as the Christian, is entitled to the protection of the State in the peaceable enjoyment of his private opinions in matters of religion. Any other view would justify the horrors of the Inquisition. In these things there is no half-way ground. As stated above, a man should be protected in the enjoyment of his religious convictions, so long as he is not guilty of practicing immorality or other wrong in the name of his faith. The very fact that multitudes will now unblushingly advocate the oppression of those whose only offense consists in the fact that they do not come up to their standard of doctrine and practice, furnishes a most alarming evidence that we have fallen upon evil times, and that, as suggested heretofore, religious intolerance is destined to manifest itself even more fully than it has as yet in different parts of our beloved but imperiled country.