AN OPEN LETTER

5%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Apr 24, 1894

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 71, No. 17.

Read the full edition

AN OPEN LETTER.

BY ELDER L. D. SANTEE.
(Princeville, Ill.)
To the Editor of the Soldier.
DEAR SIR: Something over a year ago your paper commenced coming to my address, sent, I suppose, by some friend. I read, as its chief aim, “This paper is issued in the interest of the Christian Sabbath,” which the reading of your articles shows to mean the first day of the week. I have read carefully many of the articles published, and among your contributors there is certainly no lack of talent; but one cannot fail to be impressed with the utter lack of divine authority.
Your paper has never shown that Jesus ever took the name of the first day in his lips. You have not shown that Christ or the apostles ever kept it. You have not given any divine law for its observance; and yet, with the statement looking up at you out of your Bible, “Sin is not imputed when there is no law” (Rom. 5:13), you condemn those who choose to labor on a day that God has never made holy.
Your Soldier has a valiant title, but without a sword his work is a failure. In Eph. 6:17 I read that the sword of the Spirit is the word of God. You have not furnished him this weapon. Is it this lack that causes him to covet so eagerly the sword of man? I copy this extract from a later issue of your paper:—
“The Sabbath question will never find its proper place in the nation until its discussion is brought more fully within the realm of conscience. An awakened moral conviction throughout the land must precede civil Sunday statutes. Otherwise such legislation will be loose and below the divine standard. This moral awakening will transpire just as soon as Christian example is in accordance with the fourth commandment.”
Now can you not see that the fourth commandment does not say one word about Sunday? Which day did those who listened to God’s command spoken from the summit of Sinai, understand to be the Sabbath? Which day do you understand the fourth commandment teaches? It would be well if the Soldier had the candor of Balaam when he asks, “How shall I curse, whom God hath not cursed?” Num. 23:8. While reading your articles on the “Christian Sabbath” (Sunday) and your pleas for its observance, I have been reminded of Ezek. 22:28, where the false prophets said, “Thus saith the Lord God, when the Lord hath not spoken.” I learn that you are not a Catholic, but you are not as consistent as they; for they have for Sunday observance the authority of the Catholic Church, and they deem it sufficient, whereas you, professing to go by the Bible, have no authority.
I inclose you a copy of “Rome’s Challenge,” which I know not how you can answer. A million copies have been published and circulated, and not a single Protestant Sunday-keeper has been able to answer it. The Sabbath of the Lord, the seventh day of the week, is commanded and honored in both Testaments. No person from reading the Bible would ever get the idea that Sunday is any better than Monday. It was wrong to labor on the Sabbath, and the women taught of Christ, would not embalm his body until a secular day; so on Sunday morning they came to do that which they would not do on the Sabbath. 1 Cor. 16:2 furnishes a similar instance. We are doing work of the same nature for the poor in Chicago. We have sent boxes of things needful, but the work of sorting and packing is not suitable for the Sabbath; and Paul recognized this fact when he appointed the first day of the week as the day to ascertain how much they could afford to give and then to lay it aside.
Do not quote Rev. 1:10 and apply it to Sunday, unless you have some proof that Sunday is meant. John, when writing his Gospel, two years after he wrote the “Revelation,” called Sunday “the first day of week.” If he had referred to it in Revelation, he would undoubtedly have called it in his Gospel by the same title, unless we conclude that he was more inspired when writing Revelation than he was when writing his Gospel. I suppose you advanced the best arguments you could find in support of Sunday, but you have never shown from the Bible that there was ever a religious meeting in the daytime Sunday. You have only shown one evening meeting. Acts 20:7. You have not given a divine command for Sunday observance. In the light of these facts do you wonder that your work appears to us a failure? Doesn’t it look pretty much the same way to you?
Standard authorities frankly confess that there is no divine command for the observance of the first day. Are you willing to confess as much? “Smith’s Bible Dictionary,” Article “Lord’s day,” after giving all the texts referring to Sunday, speaks of the proof as “scarcely adequate;” that is, it doesn’t quite prove it.
“The Christian Sabbath (Sunday) is not in the Scriptures, and was not by the primitive church called the Sabbath.”—“Dwight’s Theology,” Vol. IV., par. 401.
“It is true there is no positive command for infant baptism, . . . nor is there for keeping the first day of the week.”—“Binney’s Theological Compendium,” pp. 180 and 181.
Now while advice isn’t always taken, suffer one word: Put “the sword of the Spirit, which is the word of God,” into the hand of your Soldier, and tell him to cease beating the air with his weaponless fists.
I would sooner run as Ahimaaz did, without a message (2 Sam. 18:22–30), than to bear a message that lacked the divine imprint. I suppose we both believe the Bible. In 2 Tim. 3:16 I read: “All Scripture is given by inspiration of God, . . . that the man of God may be perfect, thoroughly furnished unto all good works.” Now what scripture contains a command for Sunday-keeping? What scripture says that the apostles were in the habit of meeting together on the first day of the week? What scripture says the apostles or the primitive churches disregarded the Sabbath of the fourth commandment and observed Sunday in its stead?
Once more: I ask attention to Rom. 5:13: “Sin is not imputed when there is no law.” How can you appeal to the conscience when urging Sunday observance, as long as there is no law to convict that conscience of sin? The question is a pertinent one: “You profess to believe in the other nine commandments. Who gave you authority to tamper with the fourth?” I will not follow the gradual change to Sunday made by the fusion of paganism and Christianity and culminating in Catholicism, but I will make this proposition: If the Bible furnishes no evidence for Sunday-keeping, then it is only a human institution, even if it began in the apostles’ days.
The antiquity of a falsehood does not make it true. In the days of Paul, Hymenaeus and Philetus taught that the resurrection was past already (2 Tim. 2:18), but the doctrine was not and is not true. Many of your contributors are clamorous for a legal enactment compelling the keeping of Sunday. They do not realize the danger of religious legislation. Many fear (and their fears are not groundless) that Romanism will obtain control of the government. Should this prove true, and Rome enact religious laws which are repugnant to you as a Protestant and compel your obedience, she will only follow your precedent.
I am a Protestant in the fullest sense of the word, and that is why I refuse to accept the Catholic dogma of Sunday sacredness. I love and observe the Sabbath of the fourth commandment, but I ignore the rival that would usurp its place.
And now, dear sir, if you will furnish Scripture evidence that Sunday is the Sabbath, or Lord’s day, you may consider me a life subscriber to the Soldier. If you cannot, please discontinue it, as I have no sympathy with an institution that is founded on custom and tradition, and which makes void the Sabbath of the Lord God.