CHRISTIAN SOCIALISM

10%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Apr 24, 1894

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 71, No. 17.

Read the full edition

“CHRISTIAN SOCIALISM.”

A Religio-political Sermon.

“CHRISTIAN Socialism” was the subject of a discourse in a Methodist Episcopal church of St. Paul, Minn., on a recent Sunday. It was in the nature of a few words of advice to voters at the coming city election. The text was Ex. 18:21: “Thou shalt provide out of all the people able men, such as fear God, men of truth, hating covetousness.” This he claimed as evidence that the Israelites had a “government of the people, by the people, and for the people.” He said: “It was not Moses that made the selections, but the people themselves. Moses simply confirmed them.”
It is not a little strange how these modern would-be reformers, will dare to twist and pervert the word of God, in order to sustain their theocratical ideas. The facts are, as stated in verses 24 and 25, exactly the opposite: “So Moses hearkened to the voice of his father-in-law, . . . and Moses chose able men out of all Israel,” etc. Thus we see the people had nothing to do with the choice of those who were to be their rulers. And Moses also confirmed them, according to his own statement in Deut. 1:13–15. Moses said to the people, “Take [“give,” margin] you wise men, . . . so I took the chief of your tribes, wise men, and known, and made them heads over you,” etc.
In speaking of civil governments the speaker said: “There is a law in our nature which compels us to organize and govern.” If by this he meant that in a “government of the people, for the people, and by the people,” each person was to govern himself, it would be all right. But from what follows, he seems to forget that the officers in a republic are simply the servants, not the rulers, of the people; and that the people are the rulers and themselves supreme. But these would-be reformers forget their calling, and imagine that they are to rule the people and compel obedience to their dictates in matters religious.
We quote again: “In the Jewish theocracy God was compelled to furnish the people, not only with good laws, but with a good system of government; but when Israel asked for a king, he was very much displeased.” It is true that this was “a good system of government,” but it was a “theocracy,” pure and simple, where the people had no voice in the choice of their rulers. But when they turned and asked for a king, God said to Samuel, “They have not rejected thee, but they have rejected me.”
In this they did just exactly what these reformers are doing. They are turning away from a form of government that has been devised in the providence of God, and are repudiating its principles, and are asking for a king. True, they say their king must and will be Jesus Christ; for like those people of old who sought to take him by force to make him king, so these are determined, and expect to succeed by force of civil laws. But as Christ departed from those who would have made him king at that time, and hid himself, so now he has departed from them, because they have allied themselves to the State in civil contract, and are living in spiritual adultery; and when their king does come, and they crown him as king of the nation, it will be antichrist instead of Christ; for Christ has said, “My kingdom is not of this world.” Hence it follows that when they shall repudiate every principle of this government as Republican and Protestant, and there is a king, it will be a man-made kingdom, ruled by antichrist and by him alone.
But let us quote again: “In Israel during the time under consideration the people had the privilege of selecting their rulers, and in this particular our condition is similar. For in America the people rule.” Now the cases of the United States and the children of Israel, are just as dissimilar as is possible. That was a theocracy. This government is not. There, God chose their rulers and made their laws, because it was a theocracy. Here, it is not so, for the people elect their own officers, or servants, not rulers, and make their own laws through their representatives. But if these men could enact an actual parallel in form, God would not be in it at all, for he said that there would be no more a government after that sort, till Christ should come again. And so this could be only a man-made theocracy, an exact image and counterpart of the papal theocracy. And as God could not be in it without denying himself, the laws, whatever they might be, would be only human laws. Not even if they should ingraft the laws of God bodily upon the statute books, could they be more or have more authority, because it would only be the authority of the State back of it all, with some man or the courts exalted above God as interpreter of that law.
One more quotation must suffice: “In the case of Israel the people were splendidly governed, all things considered; and the reason, or secret, whichever you may term it, was to be found in the fact that none but good men were eligible to office.” Now that sounds well. But who are the good men? What qualifications are necessary? Under “qualifications for offices,” he says that “ordinary powers are not enough; for unless a public man has ability, sagacity, and practical discernment, he will be a failure,” etc. Then, citing the example of Moses again, he says: “Then from these he was to confirm, or install in office, only such men as feared God. . . . There must be the fear of God linked with the ability, before a man can measure up to the Bible standard.” Then quoting Carlyle, “If there be not a religious element in the relations of men, then such relations are miserable and doomed to ruin,” he indorsed it as his own sentiments, and said, “I believe it.” But why apply this to the State?—For the same reason that the Scriptures can be perverted and misapplied. It was to make a point, to sustain a false position, to maintain a dogma. H. F. PHELPS.