We have given a hearing to about every religious denomination on the subject of the Sabbath, and shown the utterly groundless nature of all the arguments that are urged in favor of the first day of the week as the rest day of the Lord. We now have occasion to listen to what the Friends, or Quakers, have to say in reference to the same. A correspondent has sent us a leaf from a recent issue of the Friends’ Expositor (date not given), setting forth the views of that denomination upon this subject. To this we are willing to give the same careful consideration as to the views of any others.
The article trots along innocently in the runway of theories long ago exploded, and now generally abandoned by those best acquainted with the present progress of the Sabbath discussion. It starts out, however, with the following statement, which to us is very encouraging:—
“The country is flooded with publications abounding in arguments to prove that the ‘seventh day’ of the week is the only true Sabbath, and endeavoring to show that the first day of the week has no divine sanction whatever.”
This is good. We have designed to flood the country with just this kind of reading-matter, and if we have succeeded so far that people begin to recognize it, it is so far very gratifying. We are glad to see it admitted, and also that these books abound in arguments. That is likewise the way we designed to have it. For brevity’s sake we will designate the extracts from the article under notice, upon which we wish to comment, by the letters “F. E.” (Friends’ Expositor).
F. E.—“All of this effort is accompanied with a zeal that might be most telling, if it were according to knowledge and in some useful and worthy cause.”
Answer.—The Bible is the source of all true knowledge on this question; and is not our zeal according to the Bible? If not, let it be shown. But if it is, then, certainly, it is “according to knowledge.” And as for the “cause,” there is no more “useful and worthy” cause than turning the minds of the people from error to truth, and none will be in the end more “telling.”
F. E.—“The Sabbath that God ordained and hallowed was more than a day of twenty-four hours. It was an institution, a moral principle, unchangeable in its nature, and belongs as fully to the first day of the week as to the seventh, if it can be shown that this transfer has been made in the divine order; and of this we shall give some proof.”
Ans.—God, by resting upon a day, and then blessing and hallowing that day, that is, setting it apart to sacred use, made an institution called the Sabbath; but that institution could no more exist without that particular day, which was rested upon, blessed, and hallowed, than we could have a tumbler of water without a tumbler, or a house without the material of which it was built. Such a conception is absurd enough in itself, but is made still more so by the next declaration; that this institution, composed of the seventh day, belongs equally to the first day. An important condition, however, comes in here,—“If it can be shown” that such a transfer has been made, etc. We look for the promised evidence on this point, and here it comes:—
F. E.—“That the observance of the Sabbath should occur on the seventh day, in order to celebrate the work of creation accomplished in six days that preceded it, was indeed most fitting. . . . But in the birth, life, death, resurrection, and ascension of the Lord Jesus, there was laid the foundation of a new creation, infinitely more glorious than the first.”
Ans.—Ah! how do our friends know all this? Where did they gain such wonderful information? This is of course with them “according to knowledge,” but where did they obtain such knowledge? Is it possible that they can stand upon the circuit of the heavens, and take in and comprehend all the infinite power that brought forth the first creation, and then balance it up against the new creation, and pronounce the latter infinitely more glorious? It is really marvelous with what wisdom some people are endowed. But quite a number of things are mentioned as entering into the foundation of the new creation. Now which of these should be celebrated? Is it the birth of Christ? Is it some great event in his life? Is it his death? Is it his resurrection? Is it his ascension? These events were all on different days, and which one of these days should be taken as the one only supreme day to celebrate the new creation? These things the F. E. should have told us.
F. E.—“If the former creation was worthy to be celebrated by a Sabbath on the seventh day, much more is the latter by a Sabbath on the Lord’s day, or the first day of the week.”
Ans.—And how did the writer learn this? Where is the information to be found? Has God left it with man to speculate upon his works, and then change his institutions to meet their own finite ideas? If what is here called the latter creation is more worthy to be celebrated by a day, why did not the Lord give us some day for that purpose? But even if he had, what warrant would that afford us for disregarding the seventh day of the former creation?—None, whatever. If the first day has also been instituted, then we simply have two days to be observed instead of one. But, in the absence of all directions or any instructions of any kind on the subject, what presumption it is in man to take the affairs of the Lord into his own hands!
After some general remarks about Christ being the Lord of the Sabbath, and having power to make an animal which was unclean to the Jews clean to the Gentiles, the writer proceeds:—
F. E.—“Just so it does not impeach the unchangeable character of God, that the Son of man, by whom the fourth commandment was given forth, and the seventh day of the week appointed to the Jew for his observance of the Sabbath, should, as ‘Lord of the Sabbath,’ move its observance one day forward to the first day of the week for the Christian believer. Nay, this is most reasonable, and harmonizes with divine methods and dealings throughout.”
Ans.—Yes, but please tell us when, where, and by what means the Lord of the Sabbath ever has moved its observance forward one day, to the first day of the week. There is not a lisp of any such work to be found in all the Scriptures. On the contrary Christ confirmed it as it was, declaring that not the least jot or tittle of the law should pass away so long as the heaven and the earth endured. It is quite an interesting spectacle to see something that never happened held up as most reasonable and harmonious with divine methods! But the F. E. undertakes to show that our Lord did this, as follows:—
F. E.—“(a) The typical import of the Sabbath seems to require the removal of its observance to the first, or Lord’s day, of the week. But upon this we cannot dwell.”
Ans.—The Sabbath had no typical import. There was nothing typical about it. As it was instituted before the fall, in the garden of Eden, before a type could possibly have had an existence, it is altogether wrong to call it a type. But if it was a type, it was a type of the future heavenly rest of God’s people, not of another day just like itself.
F. E.—“(b) This day was distinguished from all other days of the week by our Lord, when, on its early morning, he rose from the dead. This was not an accident.”
Ans.—Why was the day of his resurrection distinguished, any more than the day of his birth, death, or ascension? The writer has already admitted that Christ’s birth, life, death, resurrection, and ascension, all entered into the foundation of the new creation. Then why, again, we ask, take the day of the resurrection for all this significance, to the exclusion of all the other days, which, in the very nature of the case, would be equally important? There is no reason for it whatever.
F. E.—“(c) On the first day of the week Jesus appeared to his disciples after his resurrection, as it is repeatedly declared.”
Ans.—Well, after Christ was risen, what else would he naturally do but appear to his disciples? It would have been very singular indeed if he had risen and then kept himself in hiding away from his disciples. His appearance was not to honor the day on which it occurred, but to prove the fact of the resurrection itself. And his appearance on the day of his resurrection was only to individual disciples. It can be easily shown that his first meeting with them when they were assembled as a body, was after the first day had ended, and the second day had begun. This meeting is mentioned in Mark 16:14 and John 20:19; but, mark, it was after the two disciples had returned from Emmaus. Mark 16:12; Luke 24:33. But the day was already “far spent,” or nearly expired, when they were at Emmaus (Luke 24:29), and they could not possibly have walked back to Jerusalem as they did, seven and a half miles, in time to reach the place before the first day would have ended and the second day would have begun. Then, “after eight days,” even calling that expression just a week (John 20:26), when the disciples were again within, would have been at the earliest possible limit on the second day, not the first, of the following week.
F. E.—“(d) It is almost certain that the descent of the Holy Ghost at Pentecost was on ‘the first day of the week,’ and that on that day the Lord Jesus began to ‘build his church,’ with the 3000 souls that gladly received the word and were baptized.”
Ans.—The Holy Ghost descended because it was the day of Pentecost, not because it was the first day of the week. And suppose there were 3000 added to the church then, there was another day in which 5000 were added. Acts 4:4. On the ground here stated, this day would have the best claim to be called the Sabbath.
F. E.—“(e) That the church from this time forward observed the first day, and not the seventh, as the Sabbath is beyond all reasonable doubt. It commemorated the resurrection of Jesus, which was a corner-stone doctrine in all of their ministry.”
Ans.—The church from that time did not observe the first day of the week as the Sabbath. There is no hint of it in the days of the apostles, nor in history, for over three hundred years after the time of the apostles. The observance of that day could not commemorate the resurrection of Christ, because it is not the right kind of service for that purpose. Baptismp. 263 is the divinely-appointed memorial for that object. Rom. 6:3–5.
F. E.—“(f) It was upon the first day of the week, when the disciples came together to break bread or to eat the Lord’s supper.”
Ans.—Suppose it was, what right have we to claim from that, that the day was therefore made into a Sabbath, and especially that that Sabbath was to usurp the place of the one which had been established at creation? The best critics deny that it was the Lord’s supper that they met to celebrate, but only the agape, or love feast, which was common to the early church. But whatever it was, the meeting was on Saturday evening, with which the first day, according to Biblical reckoning, began; and Paul traveled all the following daylight part of that day on the wearisome foot journey from Troas to Assos, nineteen and a half miles. His companions had been sailing all the night before. Acts 20:11, 13, 14.
F. E.—“(g) It was upon the first day of the week that Paul charged the church at Corinth to lay in store their offerings to the Lord,—an act of worship.”
Ans.—To lay our offerings in store, making it necessary to look over our secular affairs, to see how far the Lord has prospered us, is business for a business day, but not a part of the religious service at a religious meeting. It was proper occupation for a working day, but not for the Sabbath. That text alone is sufficient to prove that the first day was not the Sabbath, and was not so regarded by the apostles.
F. E.—“(h) John speaks of the Lord’s day in a way that clearly implies its general observance for public worship; and that this change of day for the Sabbath, was by the authority and teaching of Jesus Christ, and so understood by the apostles, is fully testified to by Justin and others.”
Ans.—A looser statement of the question, and one which indicates a more befogged view of the subject, it would be difficult to find. The Lord’s day of Rev. 1:10 was not the first day of the week, but the seventh day; and Justin never calls Sunday the Lord’s day. Much less does he ever call it the Sabbath. He simply says, “On the day called Sunday, we meet together,” etc. The day was never called the Lord’s day till the time of Tertullian, A. D. 200, and was not observed in place of the Sabbath till after the edict of Constantine in the fourth century.
F. E.—“(i) The example and practice of the apostolic church is good authority for us, since they were invested with power in the administration of the affairs of the church, which Christ declared would be sanctioned in heaven.”
Ans.—We have no objection to any one following the example and practice of the apostles. In fact, the trouble with the professed church to-day is that they do not follow that example and practice. But to the setting up of the apostles as examples of unscriptural and antichristian practices, we object. The apostles never gave any example for Sunday-keeping. They never gave any precept for it. They never held a meeting on that day, except in the first, or night, part of the day (Acts 20), and then worked all the light part of that same day. Their course of action, intelligently examined, shows that they devoted the day to secular uses; while on the contrary they did observe the Sabbath, the seventh day, according to the commandment, after the crucifixion of Christ. Luke 23:56. The book of Acts also is full of their recognition and observance of the Sabbath. So much for the position held by the Friends on the Sabbath question. How does it strike the reader? Is it not evident that they are at least half a century behind in the discussion of this subject?