AdventAI

OUR NATIONAL CONSTITUTION AGAIN.

By W. H. Littlejohn

From Review and Herald, Vol. 71, No. 19., May 8, 1894

Its Defect. An Objection Considered.

BY ELDER W. H. LITTLEJOHN,

(Battle Creek, Mich.)

There is room for doubt as to whether it would be possible to suggest any line of policy to which objections of some sort could not be offered with more or less show of plausibility. The only thing to be done, therefore, is to adopt one which, all things considered, presents the fewest difficulties and dangers.

There are those whose judgment should command respect who have expressed the fear that my proposition in a former article, so to amend the United States Constitution as to prevent the citizens of a State from enacting laws that would contravene the rights of conscience, could not be carried out without hazarding the life of the republic. This fear is based upon the fact that the action proposed would increase the power of the general government at the expense of that of the States. While agreeing with my critics in the main as to the danger of consolidating too much power in the general government, I am still of the opinion that in the case in hand, the danger suggested is imaginary rather than real.

The action proposed in my article did not contemplate the transfer to the general government of complete jurisdiction over the question of religious liberty in the sense of authorizing Congress to enact laws for the granting or withholding of religious liberty in the various States. What I proposed was that the Federal Constitution should be so amended as to prevent the exercise of religious intolerance in any one of the States of the Union. The power conferred in this way upon Congress would be negative in character. That is, it would not enlarge its jurisdiction in the sense of enabling it to legislate for the individual States in matters of religion; but would simply authorize it to enact such laws as might be necessary for the enforcement of the amendment prohibiting the States from passing statutes interfering with the rights of conscience. In the exercise of that power it would be restricted to the enactment of uniform laws which would apply with equal force in every State of our federation. Such laws would be enforced through the United States courts, their constitutionality being passed upon by the same judicature. Such limitations enforced by such courts would afford a sufficient guaranty of uniformity in the application of the laws of Congress, and such uniformity would shield the separate States from being discriminated against in the matter of congressional enactments. The result would be that when the proposed amendment was carried out in good faith, religious liberty would be guaranteed in every State in the Union. The carrying out of the amendment in good faith by the Congress would be secured in two ways: First, By the integrity of the courts; secondly, By the fact that every law of Congress would be universal in its application, and thus render it for the interest of every State to see to it that the laws in question were just and constitutional.

In that provision of the Constitution which guarantees a republican form of government to every State in the Union, we find an illustration of the effect which would be produced by the amendment proposed in this article. The provision mentioned simply authorizes Congress to secure a republican form of government to each of the States. When they enjoy that, Congress cannot interfere with them. When they seek to overthrow a republican form of government, Congress can prevent their doing so by enacting laws authorizing the use of the United States troops, if necessary, to the accomplishment of that end.

Another illustration is found in the amendment to the United States Constitution prohibiting involuntary servitude in this country save in the cases mentioned in the amendment. All that Congress has to do with that amendment is to see that it is properly carried out. No intelligent citizen of the United States would have the Federal Constitution changed in the particulars in question. He apprehends no danger that the national legislature will abuse the power thus conferred; or at least he feels that such a danger is not worthy of mention when compared with the benefits that the amendment secures. Religious liberty is a greater boon than a republican form of government, or even than personal liberty from the physical standpoint. This being true, why is it any more blameworthy to guard it by restrictions in the national Constitution than it is to guard, by like restrictions, physical freedom and a republican form of government? Nay, more; is it not infinitely more imperative that religious liberty should be guaranteed in the Federal Constitution than it is that a republican form of government and the freedom of the person should be thus guaranteed?

So much for the objection that the proposed amendment would increase somewhat the powers of the general government. While the writer frankly concedes that the caution of his critics would, generally speaking, be justifiable, he has shown that in the case in hand the danger intimated is so slight and so remote as hardly to be appreciable.

Turning now to the situation as it is, he proposes to inquire next into the actual necessity for the change demanded. The action which he favors is not based upon an imaginary danger, or something which may or may not occur. It is rendered necessary by an evil, the existence of which none can deny, and the gravity of which cannot be disputed as long as we concede that it is one of the legitimate functions of good government to secure complete protection to its citizens in matters of conscience. That religious persecution is actually taking place in some of the States in this Union at this time cannot be denied. In the States of Arkansas, Georgia, Tennessee, Maryland, and Pennsylvania, not to mention others, conscientious observers of the seventh day of the week have been fined and imprisoned under State laws for working on Sunday in an inoffensive manner, after having rested upon the only day that God ever commanded any man to hallow. Ex. 20: 8–11.

Deny the individuals in question the right to do as they have done, and you will deny the principle that in matters of religion the majority has no right to dictate to the minority. Again, deny the correctness of that principle, and you have repudiated the theory upon which our government is based. Practically speaking, itp. 292 makes no difference whether Sabbatarians are right or wrong in their sabbatizing. That they are conscientious in what they do, the sacrifices which they make for their faith furnish abundant proof. They should, therefore, be shielded from persecution at all hazards. Does our form of government at this time secure that end? Go to the States named for a reply to that question. Go stand by the grave of R. M. King, who was hounded to his death by the unrelenting bigots of Tennessee because, forsooth, he would not observe the Sunday as they observed it. Again, go to the same State, and see some of his brethren compelled to work in the chain-gang as they were because they would not acknowledge the divine authority of a Sabbath which the Scriptures have never recognized as anything more than a day to be devoted to secular affairs. Quibble and prevaricate as you may, if religious persecution is not practiced in this country at this time, it never was practiced in the darkest days of the Inquisition. To those who are suffering for their faith as Sabbatarians are suffering in our day, it seems like the bitterest irony to declare that our government has hitherto secured to its citizens complete religious liberty.

These, I repeat, are the actual facts of the situation. One hundred years have passed since the adoption of our present form of government; and, as stated in a previous article, a single hour has not existed when there have not been upon the statute books of many, if not of a majority of the States of this Union, laws under which conscientious men and women have been liable to fine and imprisonment for doing what God has given them the right to do in his word. This condition of things has been brought about by religious zealots, it is true; nevertheless it is a fact of history, and proves that our ideal of perfect religious liberty to all cannot be worked out under our present system. What, then, is the remedy? or, rather, how shall the remedy be applied? The monster of religious persecution must be throttled in some way. Shall he be crushed by a single blow in this our fair domain? or shall the battle be waged first in one State and then in another, as proposed, until all the States of the Union shall have guarantees of religious liberty in their constitutions? If so, we shall struggle with the odds all against us.

The ancients tell of an enormous serpent called the “hydra,” which is said to have had many heads, each one of which, when cut off, would be replaced by another unless the wound was cauterized. This fabled creature furnishes a fitting illustration of the condition of things in this country at this time. There are now forty-four States in the Union; let each one of them represent a head of the monster, religious intolerance, and the parallel is complete. Kill religious persecution in Maryland, or Georgia, or Tennessee, or any other State to-day, and it is liable to spring up again there to-morrow. As matters are now, the same people who incorporate religious toleration in their constitution to-day may eliminate that principle to-morrow. In this way the battle may be carried on indefinitely. While a portion of the States recognize the rights of conscience, another portion may deny them.

The man whom the crisis demands is some modern Hercules who can sever the heads from the body of this modern hydra of religious intolerance with one blow, and so cauterize the wounds that they will never produce another head. To throw off the figure, the times demand a leader or a party who can organize victory complete and universal on the line of the rights of conscience in this nation, by securing such an amendment to our national Constitution that religious liberty shall be guaranteed to every citizen on every foot of our domain. If the Constitution were so amended, it would be forty-four times more difficult to perpetuate in this country the practice of religious oppression, than it is now. The writer does not say that even were the Constitution amended as he suggests, religious intolerance would never spring up again in this nation. The United States Constitution might be changed back again to its present wording, or it might be overridden entirely by religious fanatics, in the passage and enforcement of unconstitutional laws, but the difficulty of oppressing those who differ with them in opinion would be increased a thousandfold to the bigots who seek to compel all men to accept the standard of their faith or bite the dust. “Eternal vigilance” is the price of religious as well as civil liberty.