THE STRUGGLE FOR RELIGIOUS LIBERTY.
By M. E. K.
To coerce others in religious things is one of the most natural impulses of the human heart. Paganism, in all its various forms, is but giving a religious sanction to all the natural emotions and passions of mankind; and to compel every one to conform to its rules is an important part of every pagan system of religion. Were it necessary to prove this statement, numerous citations could be made, both from sacred and profane history. The religion of Jesus Christ is, in its very nature, entirely different from this. Its purpose is to change the human nature by a reception in and through Christ of the divine nature. 2 Peter 1:4. Jesus Christ, as a representative of God on earth taught no doctrine of coercion in matters pertaining to man’s relation to God. “If any man thirst, let him come unto me, and drink” (John 7:37), were his own words in describing the way that mankind should be saved. And again, by his Spirit through the beloved John, he said, “Whosoever will, let him take the water of life freely.” Rev. 22:17. These words of Christ cover the whole ground of Christian doctrine and duty. “The grace of God that bringeth salvation hath appeared to all men, teaching us that, denying ungodliness and worldly lusts, we should live soberly, righteously, and godly, in this present world.” Titus 2:11, 12. That is the teaching, and in regard to it every one must act for himself. We can teach others how they ought to live in relation to all the points of Christian faith and practice. “Knowing therefore the terror of the Lord,” we can “persuade men,” and beseech them to be “reconciled to God” (2 Cor. 5:11); but the gospel gives us no right to compel any one to perform any act of religion that grows out of our faith that Jesus Christ is the Saviour of the world. The failure to retain this grand principle of Christian doctrine led to the “falling away” in the church and the bringing in of the corrupted gospel which is embodied in the Romish system. The Church was united to the State, and the pagan idea of an enforced observance of religious duties took the place of the doctrine of the freedom of the individual in religious things, as taught by Christ. This change in the fundamental principles of Christianity made the Catholic Church a persecuting power. The principle was first authoritatively stated by Augustine, thus: “It is indeed better that men should be brought to serve God by instruction than by fear of punishment or by pain. But because the former means are better, the latter must not, therefore, be neglected. . . . Many must often be brought back to their Lord, like wicked servants, by the rod of temporal suffering, before they attain the highest grade of religious development.” And of Augustine and his theory, Neander says: “It was by Augustine, then, that a theory was proposed and founded, which . . . contained the germ of that whole system of spiritual intolerance and persecution which ended in the tribunals of the Inquisition.” The Catholic Church adopted this principle, and has acted upon it ever since. Not only has the Catholic Church held to this antichristian principle, but all other churches which have, like her, been united to the State, have done the same. The various State churches of the Old World, while freeing themselves in some degree from the errors and superstitions of the “mother church,” have still retained the principle, the very seed from which all these errors grew, the idea of a church established by the civil law,—a church supported by the State, and the doctrines of the Church sustained and enforced by civil penalties inflicted by the laws of the State. This relation of the State to the Church prevailed in all the countries of Europe when the discovery of America turned the eyes of the people toward the West, and the colonization of the New World was begun. Happy would it have been for the people of America if this pagan idea, which had been ingrafted upon the Christian Church, could have been left in the Old World, and never have crossed the waters to corrupt the religious life of the people, and impede311 the material growth of the colonies which were planted in the western wilds. Such was not the case. It came with the Pilgrims on the “May Flower,” and fastened its roots in the rocky New England soil. It found a place in the Virginia settlements, and grew with their growth. It became imbedded in the laws of the colonies. It was a part of the heritage which we received from the mother country. Like the country from which they came, the colonists established religion. In Virginia, Episcopalianism was joined to the State. In Massachusetts, it was Congregationalism. The persecutions which were endured by those who dissented from these established religions, are well known to every intelligent person. In the colony of Massachusetts modest, Christian women were stripped naked to the waist, their wrists fastened to the tail of a cart, and thus they were whipped from town to town, their sufferings mocked by a jeering mob led on by the ministers, who took great delight in the brutality they had themselves incited. All the charge they could bring against these persons was that their religious practices disturbed the peace of the community,—the disturbance being a mental disturbance, because these persons would not do as the members of the church wanted them to do. Roger Williams, whose memory all true Americans now delight to honor, was banished from the colony of Massachusetts, and found among the savage denizens of the forest an asylum which was denied him by the priests and priest-ridden people, who claimed to represent in their lives the religion of Jesus Christ. These persecutions in the colonies previous to the Revolution, and the Christ-like patience and heroism with which they were borne, caused a revulsion of feeling, and a more tolerant spirit came in; but the union of the church with the government of the colonies prevailed until the beginning of the American Revolution. The Declaration of Independence, drawn up by that great American statesman, Thomas Jefferson, was the grandest asseveration of the rights of man that ever startled a world slumbering in the chains of both civil and religious despotism. “Life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness” were declared to be “unalienable rights,”—rights that no one, no government, could take away. As there can be no civil liberty without religious liberty, the Declaration of Independence was, although perhaps unknown to the majority of those who sustained it, a statement of the religious as well as the civil rights of the people who rallied to make that declaration good. Joined together as one, by their subscription to, and support of, this immortal document, the American colonies make good their claim that “these United States are, and of right ought to be, free and independent States.” This civil freedom, wrung from the mother country at the price of patriot lives, would hardly have been worth what it cost but for the religious freedom, which, as we have said, was in the Declaration of Independence, and which came into existence a little later as a logical sequence to civil liberty. During the continuance of the seven years’ struggle, the patriot leaders had time to study the features of the governments of the Old World, to find the causes which had resulted in the practical enslavement of the larger portion of the people. One of these causes they found to be the union of the Church with the State. By this union the freedom of thought of the world had been stifled. If Galileo discovered that the earth moved, the church stood ready to condemn him, and the civil power was ready to carry out her behests. Silence or death was the only alternative offered. These things were seen clearly by the new champions of liberty of the western hemisphere, and they determined to direct the course of the new government committed to their hands in a way to avoid the difficulties concerning religion which had operated so disadvantageously to the good of the Old World, and whose evil effects had been clearly seen in the New. But a difficulty at once arose. The proposed union of States left each State independent in all things not specifically mentioned as belonging to the United States; and as some of these colonies, now to become States, had their State churches already established, to which they still clung with great tenacity; and as Congregationalism in Massachusetts was fearful that any yielding of church authority might lead to a triumph of the English Church over them; and as the English Church people in Virginia had the same fear in regard to the Congregationalism of Massachusetts, there was no effort made to overthrow these State churches, but it was determined that the United States should set them a good example in this respect; and, therefore, the first amendment to the Constitution was adopted, which declares that, “Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof.” Article VI. had also declared that, “No religious test shall ever be required as a qualification to any office or public trust under the United States.” The States fell into line with the United States, and in one way and another repealed their State religions; and it is the boast of the States of the West that they were “free born,” and that in them no man was ever persecuted for his religion, and that their soil has never drunk a martyr’s blood. Proud as is the boast, and pleasing as is the picture, we greatly fear that the picture will not last, and that the boast cannot much longer be made. The history of these latter years, and the shadow now being cast upon the future, lead us thus to conclude. Our reasons for this position, briefly stated, are these:— 1. The growing power of the Catholic Church in the United States. The influence of this church in the past is well known. Many strong nations have been cast down by her. She aspires to rule in civil as well as in religious affairs. She may now, while quietly making great advances, deny that she hopes to control the country, but she cannot deny the history of the past, and she boasts that “Rome never changes.” She now has the control of many of our large cities, and her power is continually augmenting by a large immigration of ignorant people who are completely under the control of the priests. We now have in this country an “American pope,” with headquarters at Washington, who will heal the divisions that have been arising, and mold the Catholic Church in the United States into one solid body, whose votes will be cast as they shall be directed from the secondary “seat of the beast,”—Washington. 2. The course now being pursued by the majority of the Protestant ministers and people of our land. Not only are they not awake to the designs of the papacy, but they are clasping hands with that church. They are conceding everything to Rome, while Rome concedes nothing. They are becoming filled with vainglory and love of power, and have become infected with a wild, unholy crusading zeal to control the country and to influence legislation in the interests of the dogmas of what they often call the American Church. Of the way in which they do this, and the special point at which they are now aiming, we will speak later. 3. The presence in this country of a body of religionists who are confessedly hostile to religious liberty, and who are working with all their power to destroy it. I refer especially to the Reformed Presbyterian Church. This church declares that the government of the United States is atheistic. They want the clause of the Constitution forbidding religious tests to be repealed. They hold that this nation is, and should in the Constitution be declared to be, a “Christian nation,” and that none but Christians should hold office. In this way they would establish the “kingdom of Christ”! And these principles, so subversive of religious liberty, of the Constitution, and the very genius of American civilization, are working like leaven among many of the Protestant denominations. Articles which in their intent aim to uproot the fundamental principles of American liberty, and subvert the whole framework of the government, as conceived by the fathers of the republic, are freely admitted into the great religious papers, which represent American Protestant opinion, and they are now beginning to bear their baleful fruit. That the ground upon which they work and the way in which they purpose to impose religious restrictions upon those who dissent from them, may be clearly understood, it will be necessary to take a brief glance at the past.