THE STRUGGLE FOR RELIGIOUS LIBERTY.
By M. E. K.
There have been three notable battles over the principles of religious liberty in this country. Two of them are in the past; the third is now in progress. To these we will now direct our attention. Immediately after the proclamation of American independence, a movement began in Virginia to carry out the principles of this declaration in religious as well as in civil affairs. The presbytery of Virginia, assisted by the Baptists and Quakers, sent an earnest remonstrance to the Virginia assembly, in favor of the disestablishment of the Episcopal Church in Virginia. The Episcopalians and Methodists opposed the measure. Thomas Jefferson was the leader of those seeking to disestablish the English Church.329 After a very severe contest, religious liberty triumphed. The year succeeding the close of the war, another bill was introduced into the assembly, which was designed to do under cover what had been voted down in 1779. This was “A Bill Establishing a Provision for Teachers of the Christian Religion.” Against this quasi-attempt to re-establish religion, Jefferson and Madison presented a united front. They argued with the clearest logic that if the State could establish the Christian religion, it could go farther, and define what particular phase of that religion was meant, and establish it. The result was that instead of passing this bill, another was passed, of which Jefferson was the author, entitled, “An Act for Establishing Religious Freedom,” which gave to Virginia religious liberty, the principles of which were afterward embodied in the United States Constitution, and from that have passed into the constitutions of the several States of the American Union. Thus was the first battle for religious freedom fought and won. The Presbyterians of Virginia, aided by the Baptists, Quakers, and others of liberal minds, and led by Jefferson and Madison, were, under God, the authors of the victory for freedom of religion in the initial struggle inaugurated in this country. When the adoption of the United States Constitution separated the church, or to speak more clearly, separated the maintenance of religion from the United States government, and when the States in their respective capacity as States pursued the same course, there were still left in the jurisprudence of the several States certain laws that were primarily religious laws, and which grew out of the relation that the colonies had in the past maintained with the church. That is, they were duties which Christians only should or can rightly perform, but which were enforced by the colonies and afterward by the States upon the non-Christian as well as upon the believer. The observance of Sunday, generally called the “Lord’s day,” is the most striking case of this kind. Here is an institution, purely religious, which none but believers in its sanctity will really observe, and such a one needs no civil law to compel him to keep it,—enforced by the civil law, not only on the believer, but on the unbeliever as well! We say civil law, because it is in what is called the civil code, but it is a religious law in all its intents and purposes. The British law (whence the American received it) was a religious law. Blackstone places work done on Sunday at the head of the list of “offenses against religion.” It might be further traced back to Rome. Christ did not authorize any compulsory duties growing out of the relations that Christians sustained to him. When a State attempts to do this, it does what Christ does not do for himself, nor has he authorized any State to do it for him. If we adopt the theory that the observance of a day of rest is based upon the perpetual obligation of the fourth commandment of the decalogue, and that the Sabbath is the seventh day, or Saturday; or if we hold that the fourth commandment is still binding, but so changed by the acts of Christ and his apostles that it now enforces the observance of the first day of the week, or Sunday; or if we entirely deny the binding nature of the fourth commandment, and rest our obligation to keep the first day upon the religious privilege of the believer to observe the day of the resurrection,— upon any of these considerations, the observance of either day is the performance of a religious duty, and with it the civil law has nothing to do. By association with our fellow-men, we can learn the duties which we owe to them; these duties may be defined and enforced by the civil law. The duties we owe to God, unfolded by divine revelation, and appreciated and understood by faith alone, are not and cannot be matters for the civil law to define or enforce. The basis for the observance of a day of rest is a religious basis, growing out of our relations to God, the knowledge of which we receive only by revelation; and the enforcement of it by the law of the State is an enforcement of a religious act, which, in the case of an unbeliever, is enforced hypocrisy, and hence incompatible with the principles of Christianity. We say that it is incompatible with the principles of Christianity, because the religion of Jesus is not a religion of compulsion, but a religion of love. No act of service toward Christ is pleasing or acceptable to him, which is not prompted by the love of the one who performs it. A compulsory worship is neither pleasing to Christ nor beneficial to the individual. These principles being true, the State has no right to enforce the observance of the Sabbath. It has the right to protect the worshiper upon any and every day from actual disturbance. Farther than this the State cannot go. The fact that there are clauses in most of the laws of the States exempting those who keep another day from the penalties of Sunday laws, shows that the law-makers doubted whether they had an absolute right to enforce such laws upon all classes; for if work upon Sunday were really a crime against the State, there could be no exception made to the general law. We know of no other punishable act where any exception is made, which proves that the Sunday law is an anomaly in the legislation of the country. In the investigation of this subject it is important to remember that while sometimes the same act, as murder or theft, may be both a sin against God and a crime against the State, there are many actions which do not have this double nature. Unbelief is sin, but it is not a crime against the State. It is not an action concerning which the State can take cognizance. The same is true of the observance of the Sabbath. The words of Paul to the Romans, although they may not apply directly to the weekly Sabbath, are good authority for the true basis of all Sabbath observance. “He that regardeth the day, regardeth it unto the Lord; and he that regardeth not the day to the Lord, he doth not regard it.”* Rom. 14:6. According to this it is useless to try to regard a day unless we regard it to the Lord; for if we do not so regard it, we do not regard it at all. For the State, then, to compel an unregenerate man to regard a day, is for the State to attempt to compel him to do what, in his unregenerate condition, he cannot do aright, and which the State has no more right to compel him to do than it has to compel him to be baptized or to partake of the Lord’s supper. It is really an enforcement of a religious act,—something utterly repugnant to Christianity, and contrary to the principles of religious freedom which have obtained in this country. It is also true that labor upon any day is not an act of incivility, and hence cannot be considered an act punishable by the civil law. The truth of this latter statement, if not demonstrated by the laws of the States which have retained special laws for the observance of Sunday, is nevertheless proved by the exemption clauses, which we have already noted, and more by the general customs of the people who do not regard labor on Sunday as they do other violations of the law. In fact, for many years this general feeling has almost made the Sunday law a useless incumbrance in the jurisprudence of the country. The people of the State of California have recognized this fact, and the statute books of that State are free from this relic of the union of the Church with the State, and the supreme court of that State has, very properly, pronounced Sunday laws unconstitutional.