AdventAI

A HISTORICAL ESSAY ON BAPTISM

By D. T. Bourdeau

From Review and Herald, Vol. 71, No. 22., May 29, 1894

Under the Form of Questions and Answers.

BY ELDER D. T. BOURDEAU.

(Battle Creek, Mich.)

1. According to the avowal of the Catholic Church, what was originally the form, or mode, of baptism? — Immersion, as appears from the following testimonies:—

(a) The French-Latin Dictionary, written and published by a society of Catholic priests at Trévoux, France, in the last century, article Baptism, says: “The primitive church baptized by immersion, and even to this day the entire Greek Church baptizes the same way; indeed, the Greek word βαπτίζειν signifies to plunge.”

(b) In L'Encyclopédie méthodique, published in Paris, France, from 1782 to 1832, Theology, Vol. I., article Baptism, we find the following words: “We would like to know why Protestants, who profess scrupulously to follow the primitive church, have not renewed the custom of baptizing by immersion.” The same voluminous work, Theology, Vol. II., article Immersion, says: “Immersion, the action of plunging in water any body whatever. It is certain that during the first centuries of the Church, the custom was to administer baptism by immersion; that is, to say, by plunging the individual in water from head to foot. It appears that St. John thus baptized the Jews in Jordan; that Jesus Christ administered baptism in the same way through his disciples. John 4:2. Thus, in the beginning, to baptize was to plunge in water, or cover with water, the entire man.” “According to the instructions of the apostles, the person who was baptized by being buried in water and then coming up out of water, commemorated the resurrection of Jesus Christ. St. Paul says to the Colossians: ‘Buried with him in baptism, wherein also ye are risen with him through the faith of the operation of God, who hath raised him from the dead.’ Col. 2:12.”

(c) The New Testament with Commentary, by Le Père des Carrières, published with the approbation of the Archbishop of Quebec, has the following note on Rom. 6:4, 5: “The baptismal water in which, according to the ancient custom, the one who was baptized was entirely immersed, was, as it were, the tomb in which he was buried, and from which he came forth with a new life—the life of grace and of righteousness which was given him by Jesus Christ.” Such testimonies could be greatly multiplied.

2. Did the leading Reformers of the sixteenth century speak in the same sense?

(a) In his sermon on baptism, Luther says: “The word ‘baptism’ comes from the Greek βαπτισμός, and from the Latin mersio, and signifies, to plunge one entirely in water, so that he will be entirely covered.” And in another place he says: “Baptism is a Greek word which can be translated immersion, as when we plunge something in water that it may be entirely covered. Although it is almost entirely abolished,—for it is no more customary to plunge children, only a little water being poured on them,—I desire that those who are to be baptized be totally submerged, according to the signification of the word and the ordinance. It would be well to have a perfect and accomplished sign of a thing so perfect and so accomplished.”—Catechism, article Baptism, pp. 131 and 132.

(b) Calvin certifies that “the word ‘baptism’ signifies to plunge entirely, and that it is certain the custom thus totally to plunge was anciently observed in the church.”—Institution chrétienne, tome II., livre 4, p. 19. Speaking of cases of baptism recorded in the New Testament, he says: “From what is here said, we can gather that John and Christ administered baptism in plunging the entire body in water. We see here (Acts 8:38) how the ancients used to administer baptism; it was customary with them to plunge the entire body in water. Now the minister sprinkles only a few drops on the body or on the head.”—Comment., tome II., pp. 61, 62, and 607.

3. Were infants baptized in the early days of the church? “In the early days of the church, only adults who presented themselves freely and with a consciousness of what they were doing, were baptized.”—La Vie chrétienne dans les premiers siècles (Christian Life in the First Centuries), par Aug. Néandre, chap. 9, p. 343.

4. What valuable testimony does L'Encyclopédie des Sciences religieuses (the Encyclopedia of Religious Sciences), published under the direction of F. Lichtenberger, dean of the faculty of Protestant Theology of Paris, contain on this point? “In the apostolic age, baptism was administered by immersion, and was followed by the laying on of hands. Acts 8:17; 19:5, 6. It is very probable that it was conferred only on adults. John baptized after a confession of sins, and the apostles themselves administered baptism only to those who repented of their sins, or in whom the desire to be baptized led others to suppose that they had repented.”—Encyclopédie des Sciences religieuses, tome II., article Baptême.

5. What testimony has the late and lamented French historian and senator, M. De Pressensé, left on infant baptism? “No question has been more fully discussed than that of infant baptism. The most distinguished church historians of today acknowledge that this custom cannot be traced to the apostolic age.”—Hist. des trois premiers siècles de l'Église, tome II., p. 488, Note G.

6. Was immersion practiced only in the days of the apostolic church? “In the first centuries of the church, baptism was conferred by immersion.”—Dictionnaire de l'Académie française.

7. How long was immersion the rule in the church? “The rule followed till the twelfth century, was to baptize by immersion, by plunging in water the body of him who received the sacrament. The inconveniences and dangers attending this practice led to the adoption of the simpler mode of sprinkling.”—L'Abbé C. Brandeville, dans le Dictionnaire de la Conversation et de la Lecture, par Dukett et d'autres écrivains, tome II., article Baptême, Paris, 1851-1858.

NOTE.—If “the inconveniences and dangers attending” immersion (?) did not prevent Christians from being immersed before the twelfth century, why should they constitute an insurmountable barrier in the way of Christians being immersed after that time? The answer is easy: The masses of professed Christians lost their first love and become weary of bearing the true cross of Christ, which is so light to those who have learned of the Master.

8. Did early Christians in England practice immersion? The French Catholic Historian Fleury, in his histoire ecclésiastique, tome V., p. 627, speaking of the ancient custom in England, says: “The bishop Paulin in 627 established his seat in the city of York, by consent of King Edom, and continued to preach freely during the last six years of the reign of that king. He baptized, among others, the children of the king; namely, four sons. He baptized many of the nobles and of persons of notoriety. The fervor of that people was so great that Paulin, having come with the king and the queen in a land called Ardregin, remained there thirty days catechising and baptizing, doing nothing else from morning till night. In those beginnings he baptized in rivers, because oratories and baptistries had not yet been built. This shows that they baptized by immersion.”

(Concluded next week.)