AdventAI

THE STRUGGLE FOR RELIGIOUS LIBERTY.

From Review and Herald, Vol. 71, No. 22., May 29, 1894

(Continued.)

In the light of the Scriptures which we have quoted, and from the principles drawn from them, as well as from the history of our country, we may deduce the principle that the enforcement, by so-called civil laws, of the observance of any day of rest, is an infringement upon the natural rights of man, unwarranted by Scripture, and opposed to the genius of American liberty. And we may further conclude that any general attempt to enforce such laws must result in religious persecution, which would not only cause a vast amount of suffering, but would be a perpetual blot and disgrace to our country.

We will now consider the second struggle for religious liberty in this country. The Presbyterian Church, which had done a good work in favor of the disestablishment of the Church of England in Virginia, was moved thereto as much by jealousy of that church as by love for the principles of religious liberty. Many zealous religionists opposed the adoption of the United States Constitution, because it contained no recognition of God and Christ.

The Reformed Presbyterians, or “Covenanters,” have always refused to support the Constitution, and have labored with untiring zeal to destroy this palladium of American liberty. As early as 1815, the Presbyterian Church, aided by people of other sects, began to agitate for a better observance of Sunday. Finding that the non Christian part of the population would not be moved by their appeals to hallow the first day of the week, they endeavored to revive and put in practice the theory of Augustine, and to compel them to do so by the pains and penalties of the civil law. In Pennsylvania “Moral Societies” were organized, whose members watched for those who did not observe Sunday, and reported them to the civil authorities. They also, by a preconcerted effort, sent to Congress a large number of petitions, praying for stricter Sunday laws, and asking, or rather demanding, that the United States mails should not be carried on that day. Thus the incipient stages of an American Protestant inquisition began to be developed in free America. This organized effort to induce the government to enforce a religious idea upon all the people, and to inaugurate a policy of religious intolerance that would prepare the way for other acts which could only result in the sweeping away of the priceless liberty of which the Declaration of Independence had been both the assertion and the pledge, might have succeeded, had not God in his providence raised up a people with clearer ideas of the rights of citizens and the limitations of the powers of the State, and a champion who had the courage of his conviction. This people was the young and rising denomination known as the Disciples, often, though improperly, called “Campbellites,” and that champion was the founder of that society, Alexander Campbell.

Mr. Campbell engaged in the discussion of these questions with different persons, particularly with Andrew Wylie, D.D., president of Washington (Pennsylvania) College. These discussions were widely known, and had a great influence in rolling back the tide of religious intolerance. Mr. Wylie himself withdrew from the Presbyterian Church and joined another church which he considered more liberal in spirit.

The principles which Mr. Campbell enunciated in this discussion, and which he maintained by reason and logic, were these:—

“The whole of the precepts, or commands, of the Christian religion are contained in the New Testament.

“But there is no precept, or command, in the New Testament to compel by civil law any man who is not a Christian to pay any regard to the Lord’s day any more than to any other day.

“Therefore to compel a man who is not a Christian to pay any regard to the Lord’s day more than to any other day, is without authority of the Christian religion.”

The statement of his second argument is as follows:—

“The gospel commands no duty which can be performed without faith in the Son of God. ‘Whatsoever is not of faith is sin.’”

“But to compel men destitute of faith to observe any Christian institution, such as the Lord’s day, is commanding duty to be performed without faith in God.

“Therefore to command unbelievers, or natural men, to observe in any sense the Lord’s day, is anti-evangelical, or contrary to the gospel.”*

Such principles as the above, amply sustained by this profound logician, could not but have an effect upon the public mind. The result was the dissolution of the “Moral Societies,” and the complete failure of the attempt to bring about an observance of Sunday by appeals to the statutory law.

The action taken in the matter by Congress, in response to the appeals made for the stoppage of the United States mails upon that day, was equally clear and satisfactory.

The question was referred to a committee, ofp. 345 which Colonel Richard M. Johnson, of Kentucky, was the chairman. The report which this committee submitted has ever been considered as one of the best State papers ever presented to Congress. It took strong ground against the enforcement of a day of rest, and denied the right of the government to appoint a Sabbath. From the report of that committee, rendered in January, 1829, we take the following important extracts:—

“The committee look in vain to that instrument [the Constitution] for a delegation of power authorizing this body to inquire and determine what part of time or whether any has been made holy by the Almighty. . . .”

“The Constitution regards the conscience of the Jew as sacred as that of the Christian, and gives no more authority to adopt a measure affecting the conscience of a solitary individual than of a whole community. That representative who would violate this principle would lose his delegated character, and forfeit the confidence of his constituents.”

“If Congress should declare the first day of the week holy, it would not convince the Jew nor the Sabbatarian. It would dissatisfy both, and consequently convert neither. . . .”

“If a solemn act of legislation shall in one point define the law of God, or point out to the citizen one religious duty, it may with equal propriety define every part of revelation, and enforce every religious obligation, even to the forms and ceremonies of worship, the endowments of the church, and the support of the clergy. . . .”

“The framers of the Constitution recognized the eternal principle that man’s relation to his God is above human legislation, and his right of conscience inalienable. Reasoning was not necessary to establish this truth; we are conscious of it in our own bosoms. It is this consciousness, which, in defiance of human laws, has sustained so many martyrs in tortures and in flames. They felt that their duty to God was superior to human enactments, and that man could exercise no authority over their consciences. It is an inborn principle which nothing can eradicate. . . .”

“It is also a fact that counter memorials equally respectable, oppose the interference of Congress, on the ground that it would be legislating upon a religious subject, and therefore unconstitutional.”

“What other nations call religious toleration, we call religious rights. They are not exercised in virtue of governmental indulgence, but as rights, of which government cannot deprive any portion of citizens however small. Despotic power may invade those rights, but justice still confirms them. Let the national legislature once perform an act which involves the decision of a religious controversy, and it will have passed its legitimate bounds. The precedent will then be established, and the foundation laid for that usurpation of the divine prerogative which has been the desolating scourge of the fairest portion of the world.”

The report was accepted, the committee discharged, and the hope for compulsory Sunday observance, or for any action of Congress toward the exaltation of that day, was for the time being destroyed. It is a very interesting fact to mention in connection with this affair, that it is quite generally believed that this Congressional Committee employed Alexander Campbell to write their report to Congress, so that we have in this report, not only the opinion of the committee, but that of Mr. Campbell himself. With this view, a portion of the report is placed in the “Memoirs of Alexander Campbell,” previously quoted, under the head of Appendix B.

In the work then done by Mr. Campbell to hold in check the rising tide of religious intolerance, we find an illustration of the words of Scripture: “When the enemy shall come in like a flood, the Spirit of the Lord shall lift up a standard against him.” Isa. 59:19.

At the close of this sharply contested battle, those who were attempting to undo the work of the founders of the republic and to reconstruct the government upon a religious rather than upon a civil basis, defeated in their attempt, retired from the combat for a time, to nurse their defeat, and again plot for the overthrow of freedom and the establishment of governmental religion.

(To be continued.)

Notes

  1. *“Memoirs of Alexander Campbell,” by Robert Richardson, p. 528. ↩