AdventAI

THE STRUGGLE FOR RELIGIOUS LIBERTY.

By M. E. K.

From Review and Herald, Vol. 71, No. 23., June 5, 1894

(Continued.)

The third attempt of this kind to destroy the religious liberties of the people was publicly inaugurated at Xenia, Ohio, in the year 1863. An association was there formed, called the National Reform Association. Those who formed this association stated their object to be to “place all Christian laws, customs, and usages of the government upon an undeniable legal basis in the fundamental law of the land.” The Reformed Presbyterian Church, which we have before alluded to, was the chief organizer of this society. For a long time little progress was made; but during the last few years this society has found many allies, and they are now rapidly gathering what may properly be called a religious, or church party. One of their principal allies is the American Sabbath Union. This organization, which includes among its supporters many of the ministers of the various Protestant sects, is really a revival, under another and more specific name, of the Moral Societies of Pennsylvania in 1829, which Alexander Campbell so firmly and successfully combated at that time. This society employs persons called “field secretaries,” who travel from town to town, enlisting the local clergy to help them; and after preaching on the bindingp. 361 nature of the fourth commandment, and pointing out the terrible evils of Sabbath-breaking, organize leagues for the promotion of Sabbath-(Sunday) keeping, one special feature being to watch closely for all infractions of the Sunday law, and by complaint to the civil authorities deliver the offender over to Cæsar to be punished. They hope by this violent means to bring about the millennium and the moral regeneration of the world! They seem to think that if all could be compelled to keep Sunday, the battle for truth and righteousness would be gained! In order to accomplish this purpose they have made great efforts in some way to influence the United States government to commit itself to the position of a favorer of the Christian religion, and especially that it should in some way recognize Sunday as the Sabbath. They tried to induce Congress to pass an educational bill, appropriating money for school purposes to certain portions of the country, with the provision that in such schools there should be taught the principles of the “Christian religion,” thus reviving the very terms which Jefferson and Madison opposed in Virginia. This effort was doomed to failure. The next effort was to pass a Sunday law for the District of Columbia and the Territories. They were not successful in this plan, but they were not disheartened. Religious fanaticism always pursues its object with unflagging zeal, regardless of reverses, as the crusades bear witness.

The proposed World’s Fair offered these zealots the opportunity they had so long desired. When it was officially announced by the President of the United States that there would be held in the United States, and in the city of Chicago, in the year 1893, an exposition of the arts and sciences that have marked the progress of this and other lands since Columbus sailed toward the setting sun, they determined to make a mighty effort to control it in the interests of their religious ideas. Even before Congress had taken any decisive action, or voted any money toward the Fair, there arose from these National Reformers, Sabbath Unions, and quite generally from the religious press, the demand that no money should be given to the Fair except upon the condition that the Fair should be closed on Sunday. To this end numerous petitions, many of them fraudulent, were sent to Congress, and several clergymen spent weeks in Washington, lobbying in the interests of this religious legislation. That the question of the observance of a day of rest is a religious question, and hence not a proper subject for legislation, we have already shown; and that it was regarded in Congress as the discussion of a religious question, may be fully proved by what was said by several congressmen at the time. Senator Peffer said, “To-day we are engaged in a theological discussion concerning the observance of the first day of the week.” Senator Hawley also said, “Everybody knows what the foundation is. It is founded in religious belief.” The chaplain of the senate, in an article in the New York Independent, also testified as follows: “During this debate you might have imagined yourself in a general council, or synod, so pronounced was one senator after another.”

The claim has been repeatedly put forth by those favoring this legislation, that 40,000,000 people of the United States had petitioned that the Fair should be closed on Sunday. They attempted to prove this claim by presenting to Congress from churches, Christian Endeavor societies, Sunday-schools, etc., petitions aggregating 25,509,132. An examination of these pretended petitions shows their fraudulent character. Michigan was represented as having sent 4,096,240; Ohio, 4,104,396; Pennsylvania, 15,552,473. As the population of Michigan is only 2,093,896, that of Ohio only 3,672,316, and that of Pennsylvania only 5,258,014, it is very plain to be seen that in the gathering of these petitions an unexampled fraud was committed. No doubt the other States were also equally misrepresented. The way in which this was accomplished was afterward told to a committee of Congress by the Rev. Mr. Cross, a Presbyterian minister, as follows:—

“Mr. Chairman and Gentlemen of the Committee: The real object of my being here to speak a word, is in favor of intellectual honesty on the part of the orthodox churches. I am a minister of an orthodox church. I notice in my territory that these church petitions are exceedingly delusive, as to the number of those that sign them or vote for them. Now, for example, in one instance in our State the Presbyterians passed a resolution, saying that we represent so many, aggregating a certain membership; and then the Christian Endeavor Society, composed of many of the same church-members alluded to by that Presbyterian church, will pass a like resolution, and say we represent fifty, seventy, or one hundred members. And then it will be brought before the Sunday-school. And many of the persons who are counted as voting for the resolutions will have been counted three, four, or five times; and it is almost on the principle of voting early and often, which is so much opposed in secular politics. I am a witness to this fact. There was one petition claiming to represent eighty church-members that signed the petition to Congress, but they were not present at all. It was at a Sunday-school, and the vote was taken by the Sunday-school superintendent, and there were children voted for these resolutions that were not old enough to know whether the expression ‘World’s Fair,’ meant the pretty girls in the next pew or the Columbian Exposition in Chicago.”

Really, the true number of actual petitions, calling for congressional action closing the Fair Sunday, was only 315,154. On the other hand, petitions signed by 300,000 persons were presented, praying Congress not to do anything that would commit the government to the support of Sunday as the Sabbath. The climax of this religio-political farce was reached when Senator Quay, of Pennsylvania, sent his Bible up to the clerk’s desk, that the clerk might read the fourth commandment, which he had marked, as the basis upon which he had asked that the Fair should be closed on Sunday! Then followed the most astounding piece of legislation ever seen in the United States. The bill was passed with the Sunday-closing provision attached to it! In other words, Congress appropriated $2,500,000 of the money belonging to all the people, to hire the directors of the Fair to close the Fair on Sundays, in the interests of a religious institution to please a portion of the people; hired them to do what they had no moral nor Constitutional right to compel them to do!

The evil result of this shameful interference with the God-given rights of the people was such as to cause every true American citizen to hang his head in shame. This attempt of Congress to interfere in the affairs of a sovereign state in such an underhanded manner (the only way it could do it), aroused great opposition. The case was brought before the courts, and contradictory decisions were rendered; the Fair was opened and shut repeatedly; the religious and the secular press waged a bitter warfare upon each other; the laboring classes arrayed themselves against the clergy; sectarian passion so largely superseded patriotism that many religious papers and clergymen urged a boycott of the Fair; and thus the whole nation was at once plunged into the depths of a religious controversy damaging to all and beneficial to none; and all starting in the unwarranted action of Congress, in legislating upon matters actually forbidden by the Constitution. This shows how wisely the foundations of our government were laid, and how any departure from them at once brings trouble and confusion, and the arraying of class against class, where all otherwise would be perfect harmony.

The most important point to be emphasized in this lamentable affair, is that a precedent has thus been established for religious legislation; our government has repudiated the principles upon which it so long has stood and challenged the admiration of the world. It now stands before the world as the supporter of a religious dogma; and if it may support one dogma, why not another? Thus the way is fully opened for other measures of the same nature, and for the establishment, in some form, of a national religion. The immediate results of this will undoubtedly be felt in the several States by the quickening of those who have influenced Congress to take this step, in their efforts to enforce with greater strictness the Sunday laws now upon the statute books, which have in the past been so lightly regarded. Thus we stand in a position similar to that of 1830, with this difference, that now Congress has done in some respects what it then refused to do, and there was in this instance much greater agitation of the question, because of its relation to the World’s Fair, and because of the quite general support that the religious press gave to the Sunday closing.

There is also another very important consideration existing now which did not exist in 1830; and that is the fact that there is now in this country a large and growing body of Christians who observe the seventh day of the week as the Sabbath, agreeably to the letter of the fourth commandment,—the very commandment which was read in the halls of Congress from Mr. Quay’s Bible, as the basis of the Sunday legislation then and there enacted. There are two well-known bodies of Christians who observe the seventh day; namely, the Seventh-day Baptists and the Seventh-day Adventists. The first is the older church, being one of the first in America; the latter is the more numerous, and as the writer is connected with the latter-named society, their experience in relation to the Sunday laws, and their belief as to the final result of that enforcement, will now be considered.

M. E. K.

(To be continued.)