COMMENTS ON THE PAPAL ENCYCLICAL

7%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Feb 19, 1895

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 72, No. 8.

Read the full edition

COMMENTS ON THE PAPAL ENCYCLICAL.

The papal encyclical has now been before the American public long enough to begin to draw the fire of the American press, and the comments that are being made upon it present an interesting study. Of course the Catholic journals are loud in its praise. The Catholic Mirror says that “it is a paper from which fair-minded and intelligent Protestants, as well as Catholics, may derive benefit, and, in fact, while it is addressed to the Catholic prelates, it is intended for the whole American people. By them, as a whole, it has been favorably received.” Referring to the statement that freedom is not the “most desirable status of the church,” the New York Sun says:—
“This, of course, is meant to be received, so far as the United States are concerned, merely as an academic affirmation of what the author deems an abstract truth; the pope is well aware that the transformation of Catholicism into an established church, is, as regards our Federal government, impracticable, and, as regards our State governments, inexpedient. The Constitution of the United States prohibits Congress from making any law respecting an establishment of religion; and there is no reason to believe that it will ever be possible to pass an amendment repealing that prohibition. On the other hand, it is true that the people of any State might at any time by an amendment of their State constitution establish a given form of religion within the confines of their domain. Of all the original thirteen States, two only, Virginia and New York, embodied guarantees of religious liberty in their first State constitutions. The other States retained religious tests for their officials, or in some form made religious discriminations. What the States did then, they could do again; and, therefore, should Catholics constitute a majority in any of our commonwealths, they could make Catholicism the established church therein. But such a step, although feasible, would be injudicious; for the establishment of Catholicism in one State would, through the jealousy and antagonism excited, provoke other States to give like exclusive or superior privileges to Protestant denominations.”
The Sun is correct in the statement that any State can, if the majority choose, establish a State religion. It is no doubt also correct in saying that if the Catholic Church should be established in one State, Protestants would be likely to do the same. But the Sun has overlooked one point. The divisions existing among Protestants would prevent their working in harmony, as the Catholics do, and would be likely to bring their efforts to naught. Again, Catholics will be more likely to seek their object by undermining, rather than by openly attacking the Constitution. They are skillful at that kind of work.
The Outlook evidently does not think the expression about the relations of State and Church here as not being the most desirable, is worthy of notice, for it is not mentioned, and declares that “the matter in his letter of greatest public interest is that which relates to secret societies and labor organizations.”
The Christian Work refers to this statement, but thinks this is brought in because of France. We quote the statement: “But lest France should, therefore, infer an argument for the separation of State and Church, he makes haste to deliver the opinion that the ‘church would bring forth more abundant fruits if, in addition to liberty, she enjoyed the favor of the laws and the patronage of the public authority.’ Of course such an assertion will pass for nothing here.”
So the Outlook gives what the Catholic Mirror called a “significant remark” to France, and that in the face of the fact that it is “the American encyclical,” and is said by the Mirror to be “intended for the whole American people”!
The Independent, while criticising with considerable sharpness the particular statement in regard to the union of the Church with the State, also holds that it was intended for Italy and other countries of Europe, but not for America.
“The encyclical begins with a eulogy of the American republic and the prosperous condition of the Catholic Church, due in good part to ‘the equity of the laws which obtain in America and to the customs of the well-ordered republic.’ He recognizes that here the church is ‘fettered by no hostile legislation, protected against violence by the common laws and the impartiality of the tribunals.’ Yet, and here comes the one thing which Americans will criticise, he tells us that we ‘cannot draw the conclusion that in America is to be sought the type of the most desirable status of the church; or that it would be universally lawful or expedient for State and Church to be, as in America, dissevered and divorced;’ and that it would be better if, ‘in addition to liberty, she enjoyed the favor of the laws and the patronage of the public authority.’ Of course we do not believe a word of this. We believe it would be much worse for the Catholic Church and for all other churches if we had this union of Church and State; and we presume a vast majority of our Catholic citizens agree with us. They have said a thousand times that the first amendment to the United States Constitution, providing for religious liberty, gives the Catholic Church here an ideal charter. But we must remember that this cautionary paragraph was never intended for America. It was put in for Italy and other countries in Europe; for a national church, be it Catholic or Protestant, is extremely slow to give up its supposed advantages. If the pope thus makes it clear that he does not wish the Catholic Church disestablished in Italy or Spain, it is nothing more than the archbishop of Canterbury says in England, or than Emperor William says in Germany.”
Thus this influential paper, while it sees the point aimed at in the encyclical, gives it all away to the countries of Europe! The Independent thinks the Catholic Church will prosper here better without a connection with the State than with one. But the Catholic Church will hardly allow the Independent to think for her upon this point. She has always prospered, in her way of prosperity, by her connection with the State, and she will not be backward to try it here, as in Europe, when the favorable time shall arrive.
Of all our exchanges, the New York Observer seems to see this matter in the clearest light. The following is from that paper:—
“It is interesting to notice how the pope mingles together his praises and his criticisms of our institutions. He has a word of praise for our national Constitution, as well as for our tribunals and our laws; but it is easy to see that he regards them all as seriously defective. They cannot be perfect in his eyes, as long as there is not a union between Church and State. It is instructive to read what he has to say upon this subject. He says: ‘It would be very erroneous’ to regard the position of the church in America as ‘the type of the most desirable status of the church.’ His reason is, because, in America, the State and the Church are ‘dissevered and divorced.’ He expresses his ideas still more plainly, when he declares that his church ‘would bring forth more abundant fruits if, in addition to liberty, she enjoyed the favor of the laws, and the patronage of the public authority.’ Precisely so. There is no longer any doubt about it. This is the goal of his ambition. He is not satisfied that his church should stand upon an equal footing with all other churches. ‘In addition to liberty,’ he wants his church to be favored with special legislation and with governmental patronage. In view of this plain language, it is now in order for those members of the Romish hierarchy who recently published elaborate denials of this doctrine, to recant their hasty utterances; and now that the position of the Roman Catholic Church, touching this question, has been plainly stated by its highest authority, it is evident that ‘Societies for the Preservation of American Institutions’ have not been organized a day too soon. It is further evident that the protection of these institutions will require persistent care and sleepless vigilance.”
We may not be able to see the utility of the “Societies for the Preservation of American Institutions,” preferring the gospel instead, as the power to meet Rome; but aside from this one point, the Observer is right when it says that a union of Church and State here is “the goal of her ambition.” On the whole, the comments of the religious press on the pope’s encyclical are about what we have expected they would be. Protestantism is thought to be so largely in the ascendency that Rome is not feared; and then it is thought that the Rome of the past,—the crafty, cruel, bigoted, heresy-hunting, persecuting Rome has passed away, and a new Rome, of a more kindly spirit, has taken her place! So when she asserts through her infallible (?) head, writing to the Catholic Church in the United States, that there is a better place for the church than equality and freedom, it makes but little impression upon the people generally. There are those, however, who can hear in these words of Leo an ominous clanking of ecclesiastical chains.
M. E. K.