AdventAI

In the Question Chair.

By Uriah Smith

From Review and Herald, Vol. 74, No. 10., March 9, 1897

[Designed for the consideration of such questions as will be of interest and profit to the general reader. All correspondents should give their names and correct post-office address, that queries not replied to here may be answered by mail.]

747.—LIVED NOT AGAIN.

In a work called “The Millennial Dawn,” the words in Rev. 20:5, “But the rest of the dead lived not again until the thousand years were finished,” are marked as spurious, being an interpolation. Is this criticism correct? G. C. S.

Ans.—It is not correct. The very best authorities support that passage as a genuine reading. But even if the “Dawn” could maintain its contention, and throw out the passage as spurious, it gains nothing for its position; for the closing part of the verse, “This is the first resurrection,” is not called in question by any expositors; and this, with the context, is sufficient to substantiate all we claim; namely, that the first general resurrection embraces only the righteous dead, and that all that are then left in the grave are the wicked, and they are not raised, and do not live again till the end of the thousand years. Thus the latter part of verse 4, after speaking of the martyrs of Jesus, says that “they lived and reigned with Christ a thousand years;” then the last sentence of verse 5 reads: “This is the first resurrection;” then the statement of verse 6 comes in, that all who have part in this first resurrection are blessed and holy, exempt from the second death, and reign with Christ a thousand years; and then verse 7 opens with these words: “And when the thousand years are expired,” etc. This shows that this prophecy passes over in absolute silence every class except the righteous, who reign with Christ during the thousand years. Now to say that the wicked dead are raised up and live and are converted during this time, is illogical and utterly anti-scriptural. A first resurrection implies a second. As the subjects of the first are all righteous, so the subjects of the second are all wicked. The period that elapses between the two is a thousand years. Therefore, after the first resurrection takes place, “the rest of the dead” live “not again till the thousand years” are “finished.”

748.—RETURN OF THE JEWS—APOSTLES IN THE CHURCH.

1. We hear a good deal from the popular pulpits and the so-called Latter-day Saints, about the return of the Jews; and here are some of the texts referred to as proof: Jer. 23:3, 8; Eze. 36:24; Zech. 10:6; Hosea 3:5. Do these texts teach the common idea of the return of the Jews? 2. Were apostles to continue in the church? Mormons refer to 1 Cor. 12:28 in support of their doctrine of maintaining a board of twelve apostles. A. B.

Ans.—(1) Some prophecies of the Old Testament refer to the experience of Israel in their captivity to other nations, and their deliverance therefrom. Thus Eze. 36:24 was written the year following the third capture of Jerusalem by Nebuchadnezzar, B. C. 588; and there appears to be no reason whatever to suppose that Ezekiel refers to anything else, in this passage, but the promised restoration from the seventy years of captivity on which the Jews had then entered. Again, some of the prophecies are Messianic in their character, and refer to the experience of God’s people during and following what is called the gospel dispensation. But all prophecies which refer to these times under the term “Israel” treat not of the literal seed of Abraham, but the spiritual seed of Christ. After we pass into New-Testament times, the promises pertain to spiritual Israel. Writers and speakers seem to overlook this distinction, and apply the words of the apostles to the literal seed, because the word “Israel” is used. The texts referred to in Jeremiah, Hosea, and Zechariah are doubtless gospel prophecies, applying not to those who are Jews outwardly, but to those who are Jews inwardly. Rom. 2:28, 29. If the principle is true, as we think it is, that all declarations applying this side of the first advent of Christ, pertain to the gospel church, it is vain to look for any fulfilment in the Jews as such; for in respect to future blessings, Paul plainly says that there is neither Jew nor Greek, bond nor free, male nor female; but the only distinction recognized is whether we are Christ’s or not. If we are, then we are counted as Abraham’s seed, and are heirs according to the promise. Gal. 3:27–29. (2) Apostles are among the gifts set in the church. But who sets them there?—The Lord, not men. To elect them as the Mormons do is only an act of human presumption. The original twelve were such as had had personal acquaintance with Christ and his personal work here on earth. There is no evidence that it was designed that just that number of apostles should always be in the church. But God has raised up men to be apostles (the name signifying “one sent”), just as the exigencies of his work have demanded. Many such can be traced through the gospel age.

749.—BEAUTY AND BANDS—THE MARK OF THE BEAST.

1. What is meant by the two staves called “Beauty” and “Bands,” as spoken of in Zechariah 11? 2. Is Sunday-keeping the mark of the beast, independently of its enforcement by the two-horned beast? H. B.

Ans.—(1) Zechariah, in the chapter referred to, impersonates a shepherd having the care of a flock. The two staves represent the shepherd’s crooks. Every good shepherd is said to have had two of these implements, one with a rounded end, with which he separated the good from the bad, and the other with a hook, with which he caught and drew back those who were in danger of straying from the flock. The word rendered “Beauty,” Cowles, in his commentary, says should more properly be rendered “Grace.” These crooks would very fitly symbolize the guidance and protection the Lord had provided for his people. The breaking of these would denote the withdrawal of these favors by the Lord, because of their apostasy from him. (2) An institution may have an inherent nature in itself, and yet be clothed with a new significance, or assume a new character, by special circumstances connected with it. We take this to be the case with Sunday-keeping. It is a child of the papacy, with paganism as its foster-father. It grew to such a position of prominence that the papacy adopted it as an emblem of its authority and a badge of its power. Ever since that time it has been, in its inherent nature, the “mark of the beast.” But multitudes have been led into its observance with no idea that it is an institution of the church, or that it is claimed by Roman Catholics as such. This may be said, perhaps, of the entire Protestant Church. But in the last conflict between truth and error, when those who are coming up to the condition of translation are to be purged from every relic of the apostasy, the fact that this institution is the banner and mark of that power symbolized by the beast, is to be brought out in great distinctness; and when the issue is thus clearly made, every one, by his attitude toward this institution, will show whether his allegiance is to the human or the divine. Then the observance of Sunday will have a new significance; it will then mean a new character. It will then be, in the prophetic sense, the mark of the beast, as opposed to the mark, or seal, of God. And until it reaches this stage, prophecy does not take cognizance of it as the mark of the beast. And it is only in the sense in which it is used in prophecy that we have to do with it.

750.—FLESH DESTROYED—SPIRIT SAVED.

In 1 Cor. 5:5 we read, “To deliver such an one unto Satan for the destruction of the flesh, that the spirit may be saved in the day of the Lord Jesus.” Would like an explanation of this passage. F. B. W.

Ans.—The context shows that the apostle’s subject is the expelling of unworthy members from the church. He speaks of a notorious offender (verse 1), and blames them that they had not so mourned over the offense, or so taken it to heart, as to take away the offending person from among them. His counsel, then, in verse 5 is to sever the connection between such a one and the church, because if retained, his influence was sure to be detrimental to others. “A little leaven leaveneth the whole lump.” Verse 6. This he calls delivering the wicked person unto Satan. It is supposed that the offender here is such a one as no means within the church—advice, instruction, admonition, and prayers—would tend to help, and he could be saved, if saved at all, only by such an emphatic protest on the part of the church against his sin. It is called delivering him unto Satan, because he is put out upon the enemy’s ground, which is oftentimes the only step that will awaken one to his danger. Paul desired the man’s salvation. In order to this, “the flesh,” or the carnal mind, must be destroyed, and “the spirit,” or the spiritual mind, or new man (Eph. 4:24), have control. The apostle does not say that Satan would destroy the man’s carnal mind, but this move would lead the man himself to put it away, if anything would; and then, as a spiritually minded man, he could be restored to the fellowship of the church, and saved in the day of the Lord Jesus.

751.—JESUS—JOSHUA.

In Heb. 4:8 why is the marginal reading “Joshua” instead of “Jesus,” as in the text? MRS. M. C.

Ans.—Because the names Joshua and Jesus are in the Greek the same; i. e., Iēsous. According to a note in Robinson’s Greek lexicon, this form of the name came about in this way: The original name of Joshua was Hoshea or Oshea, which means “he saves.” This name Moses changed to Jehoshua (Num. 13:16), which means “his help or salvation.” This was afterward contracted to Joshua, and after the captivity he was called Jeshua (Neh. 8:17), whence comes the Greek Iēsous (Iesous), which is also the word for Jesus. This name signifies “help, deliverance,” and according to Matt. 1:21, seems to have been given to the Messiah for this reason. Now, in Heb. 4:8, Paul is talking about the work of Joshua in leading Israel into the earthly Canaan; hence the name Joshua should have been used instead of Jesus.

U. S.