A FEW years ago when we learned of the imprisonment of our brethren because they could not obey the statute requiring Sunday observance, Seventh-day Adventists were stirred. “We have long expected it,” was the earnest comment of brethren and sisters at the family altar and the social service. Later, when the startling news, “Adventists in the chain-gang!” flashed over the wires, and appeared in display head lines in the great metropolitan dailies, a thrill of horror ran through all hearts. But again were heard the earnest words, “It is only what we have long expected. Surely these are solemn times.” Events have recently occurred which indicate that we are still nearer the great crisis. One of the last and most serious signs of the final struggle to which we have looked forward is predicted in the following paragraph:—
Those who honor the Bible Sabbath will be denounced as enemies of law and order, as breaking down the moral restraints of society, causing anarchy and corruption, and calling down the judgments of God upon the earth. Their conscientious scruples will be pronounced obstinacy, stubbornness, and contempt for authority. They will be accused of disaffection toward the government.—“Great Controversy,” Vol. IV, page 592.
A literal fulfilment of this prediction appeared recently at Ellsworth, O. Two of our young ministers held a series of meetings in that city, which aroused the usual opposition. A committee of citizens, desiring a discussion of the Sabbath question, called upon a clergyman by the name of McConnell, chairman of the Christian Citizenship Committee of the Mahoning County Christian Endeavor Union, and asked him to defend Sunday observance. This he refused to do, but charged that Seventh-day Adventists were teaching sedition against the government, and announced his willingness publicly to affirm the charge if the Adventist minister would deny it. Accordingly, an appointment was made at the town hall, and Mr. McConnell made his charge of sedition before an audience of three hundred citizens. Brother W. J. Fitzgerald answered the charge, and Mr. McConnell replied, closing the discussion. The addresses were published by Mr. McConnell, and are now being circulated under the title “Religion or Sedition?”
The Christian Citizenship chairman spoke as follows:—
The charge I make against Mr. Fitzgerald and his associates, known as Seventh-day Adventists, is that they turn away the hearts of Christians from the United States government. Sedition is from sed, “aside,” and ire, “to go”—a going aside. It is a word that indicates the preliminary steps in treason. It is defined as “of the like nature with treason, though without the overt act.” “It consists,” Webster tells us, “in arousing discontent against government, and disturbance of public tranquillity by speaking and circulating inflammatory publications and the like, or excitement of resistance to lawful authority.” It is my purpose now to show you that the Seventh-day Adventists meet every part of this definition.
Mr. McConnell offered in support of the charge of sedition, first, that Seventh-day Adventists teach that human governments end with the destruction of the fourth beast of Daniel 7. “Repudiating the continuance of civil government in the hands of the followers of Christ, these teachers,” said Mr. McConnell, “assert that human government ends when the fourth beast perishes.” His second argument was that Seventh-day Adventists teach that the United States government is symbolized by the two-horned beast, which makes an image to the papacy, and persecutes the people of God. His third point was that Seventh-day Adventists teach that the animating spirit of the beast is the spirit of Satan, and since the two-horned beast becomes animated by the papal spirit, therefore the United States government will become animated with the spirit of Satan. In support of these points Mr. McConnell read extensively from the work, “America’s Crisis,” by Elder U. Smith.
After picturing the glories of our country’s past, and predicting a reign of righteousness and peace for the future of the United States, the speaker continued:—
In their discouraging doctrine, our noble ship of state is sailing under orders that guide it, not toward the haven of a reign of peace and righteousness on earth, but toward a fiery maelstrom that is its final destruction. Where is patriotism, loyalty, or even hope to be had for the government after these Adventists have placed their unclean hands upon the Bible!
In order to influence his hearers in favor of his views, Mr. McConnell, by pre-arrangement, produced the United States flag, and handing it to an old soldier, called on the audience to give three cheers for it, but to cheer with a distinct understanding that it stood for the ideas of Christian Citizenship as presented by himself. This is the scene set forth in the accompanying illustration. (See note on last page.)

To the intelligent Seventh-day Adventist the occurrence is ominous indeed. It raises the curtain on a most solemn scene in the last act of earth’s final tragedy. And looked forward to, as it has been by us all, nevertheless the actual fulfilment of the predicted scenes, in startling detail, brings over the heart an indescribable feeling of solemnity. One instinctively asks, Has it really come to pass that in America, the birth-place of religious freedom, it is regarded as sedition, by a powerful organization of professing Christians, to teach that earthly governments will be destroyed at Christ’s second advent, and the kingdom given to the saints of the Most High! Is it sedition, or the budding of treason, to speak of the “blessed hope” which cheered the apostles, prophets, and martyrs in every age! We are led to say, in the famous words of Patrick Henry, “If this be treason, make the most of it.”
Again: has it become sedition in the opinion of a Protestant organization, to teach that a union of church and state in the United States is an image of the papacy! Has it become sedition to warn our fellow men against the awful results of such a union! Is it sedition in the eyes of Protestants to teach that it was not the spirit of Christ, but the spirit of papacy, the spirit of Satan, which imprisoned in the United States, in the last eleven years, forty-one Christians for a total of seventeen hundred and twenty-two days, and drove twelve others in the chain-gang for a total of four hundred and forty-five days, for no offense save obedience to the commandment of God, which reads, “Six days shalt thou labor, and do all thy work; but the seventh day is the Sabbath of the Lord thy God!”
No people in the United States have so exalted the religious liberty principles of the Constitution, which have been the crowning glory of the nation, as have Seventh-day Adventists. They have taught that these principles were borne in the heart of the world’s Redeemer. How more could they exalt them? No people have done more to maintain these divine principles than have Seventh-day Adventists, and no people will sacrifice and suffer more still to maintain them than will they. But now this very loyalty is denounced as sedition,—the preliminary step in treason. What we warn the nation against now is simply the work of those misguided men, who, though they know it not, would overthrow these grand principles, and thus destroy this government.
If we must lie under the charge of sedition, we are comforted with the thought that we are not alone. All the prophets and apostles, and even Christ himself, predicted the destruction of earthly governments, and were charged with sedition. Better faithfully proclaim the warning, and suffer at the hands of a maddened multitude, than compromise our allegiance to God. Our experience to-day is like the experience of the prophet Jeremiah, as told in Jer. 26:11–15. God gave the prophet a warning to deliver to backsliding Israel, similar to the warning of Revelation, which Seventh-day Adventists are called upon to give to-day. The courage and faithfulness that were manifested by the “weeping prophet” are recorded “for our admonition, upon whom the ends of the world are come.” Here is the record:—
Then spake the priests and the prophets unto the princes and to all the people, saying, This man is worthy to die; for he hath prophesied against this city, as ye have heard with your ears. Then spake Jeremiah unto all the princes and to all the people, saying, The Lord sent me to prophesy against this house and against this city all the words that ye have heard. Therefore now amend your ways and your doings, and obey the voice of the Lord your God: and the Lord will repent him of the evil that he hath pronounced against you. As for me, behold, I am in your hand: do with me as seemeth good and meet unto you. But know ye for certain, that if ye put me to death, ye shall surely bring innocent blood upon yourselves, and upon this city, and upon the inhabitants thereof: for of a truth the Lord hath sent me unto you to speak all these words in your ears.
Many who read these lines have long been familiar with the truths taught by Seventh-day Adventists, but have not identified themselves with the “little flock.” For years they have been almost persuaded. To all such we say, “How long halt ye between two opinions?” If the striking fulfilments of the past few years are not sufficient evidence, would you believe “if one rose from the dead”?
It is gratifying to state that notwithstanding this charge of sedition was made by an experienced clergyman, backed by one of the leading journals of the Christian Endeavor Society, and replied to by a young minister of limited experience, yet at the close of the discussion two thirds of the audience remained, and without a dissenting vote, passed the following resolutions, drawn up by one of the most prominent citizens of the county, and later published in the Mahoning Dispatch at Canfield, O.:—p. 137
Whereas, Elders W. J. Fitzgerald and A. Carey have been with us (citizens of Ellsworth, O.) for several weeks, preaching the gospel and teaching the truths of the Bible; and,—
Whereas, We have been much profited and edified by their teaching and Christian example while in our midst; therefore be it,—
Resolved, That we hereby tender these Christian ministers our most heartfelt thanks for their unrequited labor of love during their stay with us; and that we shall ever treasure with kindly regard their earnest devotion to their holy calling, and their abiding interest in our happiness and eternal welfare.
Resolved, That we have more confidence in their loyalty and devotion to the flag of our common country, and the best interests of religion and humanity, than we have in those who seek, by misrepresentation and covert abuse, to malign them.
Resolved, That we take great pleasure in testifying to their gentlemanly deportment during their sojourn with us, and do very cordially recommend them to any thoughtful and intelligent community wherever they may see proper to labor for the uplifting of society and the eternal welfare of the human family.
A. F. BALLENGER, New York City.