AdventAI

HOW SHOULD WE THINK?

By M. E. K.

From Review and Herald, Vol. 74, No. 9., March 2, 1897

Two years ago a Protestant Episcopal minister in New York City became dissatisfied with his church relations, and joined the Baptists. He was reordained, and became pastor of a Baptist church. He has now become dissatisfied with the Baptist Church, and has returned to the Protestant Episcopal Church. In a long letter he explains his vacillating conduct, and says he left the Episcopal Church in a “spring-tide of religious emotion,” and that he is longing for the “eucharistic presence of Jesus,” which he now thinks he cannot obtain in the Baptist Church. This is a view of the eucharist which may not leave him long in the Protestant Episcopal Church; and it would not be surprising should his troubled soul not find peace until he joins the Roman Catholic Church, where he can have the supposed “real presence” of Christ in the communion, and worship it as God.

But the most surprising thing of all in this change of church relations is the confession of this minister. He does not believe that he ought to think for himself! He says, “I regard it as a piece of impertinence for any man to think for himself on matters of dogmatic importance.” He has now got where he wants to be, and henceforth he surrenders his right to think to his superiors. It would seem from his confession that when he joined the Baptist Church, he did think a little. But, growing tired of it, he proposes to go where thinking upon “dogmatical” and difficult subjects is unnecessary. Now his “fathers in God” will think for him, and he can rest in peace. He thinks this is a safe rule for him; yes, for “any man.” How, then, will it work for the millions reared in the tenets of the Roman Catholic Church? By that church it is also regarded as an “impertinence for any man to think for himself on matters of dogmatic importance;” hence a vast multitude are held in bondage, for there is no slavery like the slavery of the mind.

When a man surrenders the right to think, everything which makes a man better than a brute is lost. Where would the world be to-day had men never dared to think, and to think in regard to the fixed theories of religion? Indeed, there would be no Protestant Episcopal Church to-day had not men dared to think they would no longer be controlled by certain dogmas for which they could see no sufficient reason in the Scriptures. An open Bible, a sincere prayer for the guidance of the Holy Spirit, and the exercise of the right to think upon anything and everything taught in that word, are the three most important requisites for the one who desires to be led into all truth. But we should not allow ourselves to think that what is contrary to that word is right. For instance, when that word says, “The seventh day is the Sabbath of the Lord thy God,” we should not allow ourselves to think that any church, creed, or father in God knows more about the Sabbath than God’s word does. When one is really anchored to the word, it is perfectly safe for him to think. If one is not so anchored, he is not safe, whether he thinks or not. This rule applies to all churches and to all thinkers.

M. E. K.